No surprise.

[Trumpton Tiger.]

merchantman5;7133350]So name one school in the East Riding that is now part of a national group that is been used to teach the teachers of tomorrow. It was only a week or two that Sirius Acadamy was in the HDM as been one of those schools. You don't get in that group by been a crap school.

How's Endeavour school getting on ??

How is Hymers College doing? Still a 100% pass rate? I wouldn't be far off the mark to suggest that by far the largest majority of Hymers pupils are from the East Riding.
Perhaps the children of many of those who voted No ?
Children of parents probably who themselves were born, bred and educated in Hull and probably earn a living in the city today.
A living that pays for the private education for their children in the dreaded city of Hull.

 

[DMD]

I thought there were no proposals by either HCC or ERYC? Are you just making it up as you go along again?

What on earth are you burbling about now? HCC are involved in broader discussions with a number of parties on regional issues. There's a working group set up consistig of profs and business folk, but ERYC, despite being invited declined to get involved, but the option's still there. There's web pages explaining it.

If you're an example of ERYC education, God help them.

 

[Carmine Galante.]

I voted no and no.

If it does happen I'll just move further West.

North Cave maybe, mind you I've heard there are some proper gob ****es residing there.

 

[Spook]

What on earth are you burbling about now? HCC are involved in broader discussions with a number of parties on regional issues. There's a working group set up consistig of profs and business folk, but ERYC, despite being invited declined to get involved, but the option's still there. There's web pages explaining it.

If you're an example of ERYC education, God help them.

I was born in Hull, educated in Hull and I still live in Hull. Your sneering attitude is consistent with the majority of your posts when you get involved in an argument you know little about. You haven't provided any evidence or facts at all. Where's the evidence that ERYC are the biggest threat to greenbelts? Where's the evidence that they grossly overspend? Provide some to back up your argument because you look like a tool.

 

[Polly13]

They've voted, what does the outcome have to do with using services in Hull. It's an simplistic opinion that is irrelevant to the issue.

I'd say it has a hell of a lot to do with it.

 

[Polly13]

Eh...let's get this right...people in the East Riding of Yorkshire shouldn't be able to use Hull facilities because they want to remain part of the ERYC?

I think that's what you are alluding to when you say "benifits".

No, he said they should have to pay for some of the things we get for nowt, like the musuems.

Good call, I reckon.

 

[DMD]

I was born in Hull, educated in Hull and I still live in Hull. Your sneering attitude is consistent with the majority of your posts when you get involved in an argument you know little about. You haven't provided any evidence or facts at all. Where's the evidence that ERYC are the biggest threat to greenbelts? Where's the evidence that they grossly overspend? Provide some to back up your argument because you look like a tool.

Given you feel the vote means anything, forgive me for laughing at you. You're dragging in issues that are nothing to do with ERYC's sham vote. It shows you have't done even the most basic research.

Here's a starter for you.

http://www.hullcc.gov.uk/portal/page?_pageid=221,1051673&_dad=portal&_schema=PORTAL

 

[Polly13]

.

 

[Ron Burguvdy]

Build a big moat to keep the "Ezzies" out !
( & tourists , traders, students, in fact anyone not living & working in Hull only)

Solve the flooding as well ...

 

[Carmine Galante.]

Does anyone actually do research before posting on here?

Anyway back to my previous question;

In what way is service delivery poor?

I've lived in the East Riding for ten years and I have no complaints at all.

 

[philhul]

Given you feel the vote means anything, forgive me for laughing at you. You're dragging in issues that are nothing to do with ERYC's sham vote. It shows you have't done even the most basic research.

Here's a starter for you.

http://www.hullcc.gov.uk/portal/page?_pageid=221,1051673&_dad=portal&_schema=PORTAL

Typos on this HCC report ....shocking

 

[Polly13]

Err...what evidence are you using for that completely incorrect statement? Use any measure you care to use, Hull schools lag far behing ER schools . Gcse rates, levels of progress, value added data etc etc.

I've worked in both Hull schools and East Riding schools, and only way ER schools are "better" is because they tend to have have kids from wealthier, healthier, more educated and more supportive families. Ignore what league tables or Ofsted say - their benchmarks are utterly pointless and artificial - the quality of teaching in Hull's schools is generally excellent.

 

[Sir Cheshire Ben]

I'd say it has a hell of a lot to do with it.

Why has it, would you have voted yes to be engulfed by ERYC?

The argument used for charging ER folk for using HCC services is both stupid, childish & irrelevant.

If it did happen there would only be one group of losers & that would be the people of Hull.

Democracy has spoken, why take it so personal?

 

[Spook]

Given you feel the vote means anything, forgive me for laughing at you. You're dragging in issues that are nothing to do with ERYC's sham vote. It shows you have't done even the most basic research.

Here's a starter for you.

http://www.hullcc.gov.uk/portal/page?_pageid=221,1051673&_dad=portal&_schema=PORTAL

The vote doesn't mean anything, but it's a sign that the people in the East Riding don't want Hull extending its boundaries into their areas. The National Boundary Commission will take the referendum into consideration as it reflects the views of the people, and they overwhelmingly don't want it.

 

[billywoofsdog]

As is the quality of teaching in the ER

 

[Edelman]

If you actually kept abreast of local news you might actually find that most of Hull's schools are as good as if not better than East Ridings. Hull Council is also NOT closing Primary Schools down thereby increasing the school bus costs to the taxpayer

HCC was good enough when Dunswell primary wanted them to absorb it when closure was announced

 

[DMD]

The vote doesn't mean anything, but it's a sign that the people in the East Riding don't want Hull extending its boundaries into their areas. The National Boundary Commission will take the referendum into consideration as it reflects the views of the people, and they overwhelmingly don't want it.

Nope, the boundary commission will carry out their ow review IF boundaries are the issue. It really was a meaningless waste of time and money.

 

[Chazz Rheinhold]

Given you feel the vote means anything, forgive me for laughing at you. You're dragging in issues that are nothing to do with ERYC's sham vote. It shows you have't done even the most basic research.

Here's a starter for you.

http://www.hullcc.gov.uk/portal/page?_pageid=221,1051673&_dad=portal&_schema=PORTAL

If the Commission finds that boundary changes would benefit the whole area, who will have the final say?
Any change to Hull’s boundaries could only take place following an order by the Secretary of State based on a recommendation from the government’s national Boundary Commission for England. It would be the responsibility of this body to consult with local people to get their views before making any recommendations to the Secretary of State.



ER just getting it in early job done.

 

[Spook]

Does anyone actually do research before posting on here?

Anyway back to my previous question;

In what way is service delivery poor?

I've lived in the East Riding for ten years and I have no complaints at all.

DMD still hasn't provided evidence that proves ERYC overspend more than HCC, or that they do more harm to greenbelts than HCC.

 

[DMD]

If the Commission finds that boundary changes would benefit the whole area, who will have the final say?
Any change to Hull’s boundaries could only take place following an order by the Secretary of State based on a recommendation from the government’s national Boundary Commission for England. It would be the responsibility of this body to consult with local people to get their views before making any recommendations to the Secretary of State.



ER just getting it in early job done.

They don't to use data like that as it's quite likely the wrong question asked. A better question is why are ERYC fearful of and independent commission.