Mafia 4

Status
Not open for further replies.
moreinjuredthanowen said:
that is an interesting point as they could ask for their own team member to be voted for and then people would think they are innocent.

I think we must be missing something that will be revealed as aside form this being a weak move by mafia they must have had some reason for going this way. either weak or there's something else at work.
Click to expand...

I don't agree at all. I think its a good tactic and the only on available to them at the time. The only thing I'd question is the timing of it, they could have waiting until the third day before getting involved in mind game etc.
 
Gerrez said:
I don't agree at all. I think its a good tactic and the only on available to them at the time. The only thing I'd question is the timing of it, they could have waiting until the third day before getting involved in mind game etc.
Click to expand...

Because it's your tactic?
 
moreinjuredthanowen said:
not if the 4 way vote has one of them in it. I said focus on the vote.

in the last 2 hours since brb made it a 4 way there have been no votes including you. your vote does nothing right now.

so do we have the right 4 guys up... very little to go on.... and how many votes each. I'd rather get 2/3 up to 3 than leave it like this. I'd ideally like later the non voters come on and help make it a good 3/4 way tie.
Click to expand...

The four way vote had me (KGB) in it last time, I survived with zero intervention from Biscan or Magic, nor did I do anything myself.
 
moreinjuredthanowen said:
well i think its got lots of possibilities. he can lock up someone who might be killed or lock up a suspect of his who is not getting a vote. Can he save someone from a lynch?
Click to expand...

Lynch is first in the nightfall order of actions with custody second so no <ok>
 
Gerrez said:
I don't agree at all. I think its a good tactic and the only on available to them at the time. The only thing I'd question is the timing of it, they could have waiting until the third day before getting involved in mind game etc.
Click to expand...

why only move available

I am assuming here the mafia can talk to each other. therfore the very best option is to select a non mafia member and get an innocent to vote for them then they only need a couple more votes and someone is i nthe tie. you could say completely hidden.

this way IBWT might be mafia might be not but we are still right now going for the tie. all they've got done is putting IBWT at risk in the tie.

its not really any better than forcing a vote for an innocent.

HOWEVER... it depends on what people think the rules mean and if ibwt is in trouble or not. I feel as though he didn't really reveal it in his post but he didn't exactly try to deny it either. i dunno where to go with any of that so using the option for me might put someone at risk of gobbing and dying Or it puts someone at risk.. hell why not select IBWt as the votee if you want him up on the board.

who knows..
 
I need to stop posting and get some work done...

You must log in or register to see images


...<laugh>



PS..."work" = <laugh>
 
Gerrez said:
In the first round the Mafia don't need tactics, its easy to avoid losing one of your own because there is so little to go on. By forcing Biscan to vote for sky its taken any potential focus off them completely. We're already almost five hours into the game and all we've discussed is Sky and Biscan <laugh> I'd say the Mafia's plan is working!
Click to expand...

I'd say this is probably the most likely scenario. Though I agree IBWT and his voting pattern should definitely be scrutinised closely in days to come for any other anomalies.

Whoever the heavy is, I take it back, I said you were ******ed by making Bisc vote for Sky, but it has turned out to be a complete mindfuck for the rest of us.
A complete dick move! Bravo <applause>
 
Gerrez said:
The four way vote had me (KGB) in it last time, I survived with zero intervention from Biscan or Magic, nor did I do anything myself.
Click to expand...

agreed... you'll note however the self same 4 way vote did end up stimulating brb to be suspicious and he got lynched. if the 4 way had gone down it would have been you and brb with lucaas and one more. thats 2 of the bad guys up game 3... i think that shows its not perfect but having pressure on is good.

I'd much rather a 4 way tie than someone running away with it day one.
 
moreinjuredthanowen said:
why only move available

I am assuming here the mafia can talk to each other. therfore the very best option is to select a non mafia member and get an innocent to vote for them then they only need a couple more votes and someone is i nthe tie. you could say completely hidden.

this way IBWT might be mafia might be not but we are still right now going for the tie. all they've got done is putting IBWT at risk in the tie.

its not really any better than forcing a vote for an innocent.

HOWEVER... it depends on what people think the rules mean and if ibwt is in trouble or not. I feel as though he didn't really reveal it in his post but he didn't exactly try to deny it either. i dunno where to go with any of that so using the option for me might put someone at risk of gobbing and dying Or it puts someone at risk.. hell why not select IBWt as the votee if you want him up on the board.

who knows..
Click to expand...

Only move IF they want to stir things since the only person we know anything about is Sky. They're hardly going to stir things up picking anyone else are they? As I said though, its a bit early to do it IMO, the first couple of days are easy to get through.

I'm happy with how things are apart from Biscan being at risk for the lynch. I want to see what happens at nightfall since he's revealed he's been pressured into voting for Sky.
 
Gerrez said:
I need to stop posting and get some work done...

You must log in or register to see images


...<laugh>



PS..."work" = <laugh>
Click to expand...

btwo only a few would be in trouble with a 10 post min rule and i know for a fact 2 of them coudl easily have posted more if they bothered... just saying.

I don't know othe others circumstances nor skys for that matter. i am assuming danilo will be along this evening.
 
Gerrez said:
Only move IF they want to stir things since the only person we know anything about is Sky. They're hardly going to stir things up picking anyone else are they? As I said though, its a bit early to do it IMO, the first couple of days are easy to get through.

I'm happy with how things are apart from Biscan being at risk for the lynch. I want to see what happens at nightfall since he's revealed he's been pressured into voting for Sky.
Click to expand...

ok then... if stirring is what they want sure.... if they were really up to that you'd have been picked though... #mafia?

I wan IBWt left up there just cos. I'd rather he was than he is not. If its a 4 wya its 25% risk of lynching a guy who would die anyway... if the rule is that way.. compared to letting him off the hook.
 
moreinjuredthanowen said:
agreed... you'll note however the self same 4 way vote did end up stimulating brb to be suspicious and he got lynched. if the 4 way had gone down it would have been you and brb with lucaas and one more. thats 2 of the bad guys up game 3... i think that shows its not perfect but having pressure on is good.

I'd much rather a 4 way tie than someone running away with it day one.
Click to expand...

Depends who is under pressure :) KGB was fortunate last time; Magic, Biscan and I remained very calmed and sat it out. Of course, Magic wasn't online anyway so you were never getting a reaction from him <laugh>
 
Bodanki' said:
I'd say this is probably the most likely scenario. Though I agree IBWT and his voting pattern should definitely be scrutinised closely in days to come for any other anomalies.

Whoever the heavy is, I take it back, I said you were ******ed by making Bisc vote for Sky, but it has turned out to be a complete mindfuck for the rest of us.
A complete dick move! Bravo <applause>
Click to expand...

meh.... only if nobody forcuses on the vote table.

gerrez you have gone to "work" i presume that means you are having a ****.... you still have not changed your vote. why not. it seems pointless right now. just saying....
 
moreinjuredthanowen said:
btwo only a few would be in trouble with a 10 post min rule and i know for a fact 2 of them coudl easily have posted more if they bothered... just saying.

I don't know othe others circumstances nor skys for that matter. i am assuming danilo will be along this evening.
Click to expand...

If only Tobes would post more...
 
Gerrez said:
Depends who is under pressure :) KGB was fortunate last time; Magic, Biscan and I remained very calmed and sat it out. Of course, Magic wasn't online anyway so you were never getting a reaction from him <laugh>
Click to expand...

just cos brb broke first <whistle>

all that matter is it stimulates something so what are we stimulating now aside from you defending ibwt that is?
 
moreinjuredthanowen said:
btwo only a few would be in trouble with a 10 post min rule and i know for a fact 2 of them coudl easily have posted more if they bothered... just saying.

I don't know othe others circumstances nor skys for that matter. i am assuming danilo will be along this evening.
Click to expand...

There are fifteen names there but Tobes and AFc aren't playing. Magic and Danilo are yet to post at all <ok>
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom
Back