A Flag poll

Which (if any) design would you like on the banner?

  • City of Culture

    Votes: 18 17.6%
  • Ebenezer Cobb Morley

    Votes: 40 39.2%
  • Player of the season

    Votes: 5 4.9%
  • Liam Rosenior, his nana's from 'ull.

    Votes: 23 22.5%
  • Other. Please describe.

    Votes: 16 15.7%

  • Total voters
    102
Shame that the flag issue, like everything else, has descended into a farse. Dutch and Mauled are trying to do something good, something positive. Not confrontational or devisive but inclusive and genuine. Shame the some are trying to derail it. Petty point scoring. Grow up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Happy Tiger and DMD
Getting all defensive and dismissive when you should be listening the fans. <laugh>

Eh? How on earth is that dismissive or defensive?

I've tried to answer the point raised. I see that as preferable to posting some pithy comment and a smiley head.
 
What is to be done about what?

We have flags that are of a size to go in the ground, people dis playing them are aware they need to respect other fans and meet ground rules, the club like them so much, they want to give everyone a replica.

Some look for problems, others look for opportunities and solutions.
No need to get stroppy! Just surprised at your position.
 
Shame that the flag issue, like everything else, has descended into a farse. Dutch and Mauled are trying to do something good, something positive. Not confrontational or devisive but inclusive and genuine. Shame the some are trying to derail it. Petty point scoring. Grow up.

I can't work out why seeing Hull City fans showing a united support for Hull City players in Hull City's ground seems to worry them.

Perhaps it's part of the reason so many people insisted the banner be kept clean of the politics.
 
No need to get stroppy! Just surprised at your position.

It's not stroppy at all. It's a simple reply stating the facts of the situation to try to answer the concerns you raised.
 
I can't work out why seeing Hull City fans showing a united support for Hull City players in Hull City's ground seems to worry them.

Perhaps it's part of the reason so many people insisted the banner be kept clean of the politics.
I can't work out why seeing Hull City fans showing a united support for Hull City players in Hull City's ground seems to worry them.

Perhaps it's part of the reason so many people insisted the banner be kept clean of the politics.

It's easy to see why this happens. Predictable really. I'm sure you know why people don't want it to work out.
 
Others felt a similar show of support to Steve Bruce would be good. He mentioned it in his interview about renewing his contract. It's nice to think that this order played some small part in his decision .

Absolutely spot on, this is what this was about, a one-off show of support when Bruce was under the cosh of injuries. It was you who took it further, gaining support was inevitable, we all know that.

The nonsense about disrespect to other Hull City supporters is laughable; I am sure that those who disagree with me will take my comments with a pinch of salt - at least I am sincere in what I say.
 
It's easy to see why this happens. Predictable really. I'm sure you know why people don't want it to work out.

Oh I can guess. I think there's different reasons from different posters.

It's all straightforward for me. Some fans want to show appreciation to the players. That's all there is to the flags, no more, no less.

Still, despite all of that and with current announcements, people have approached me away from the board with offers of donations, and the collection is once again better than I expected.

Well done to all. <ok>
 
Shame that the flag issue, like everything else, has descended into a farse. Dutch and Mauled are trying to do something good, something positive. Not confrontational or devisive but inclusive and genuine. Shame the some are trying to derail it. Petty point scoring. Grow up.

I forget, Charle1, are you in favour of changing the name of the club and the style of Allam's strategy in doing it? Do you consider the actions of the owner as 'petty point scoring', is is that just reserved for folk who oppose his views and methods?
 
So Balks wants to remove the banner this forum agreed on and paid for with his own protest banner?

A banner only he wants with a banner many on here wanted?

<laugh>

Fez is demanding people stop doing anything, at all, that could be construed as offering the owners support? So, like going to games?

<laugh> Good luck with that Fez.

Balks, if you want a giant Hull City AFC banner, why don't YOU speak to James Mooney, directly, then YOU arrange for somewhere for it to go in the ground after you've got it made? Bearing in mind the challenges finding spots with the 2 existing new FANS ones, and the reason Dutch has suggested we drop to 6x4s? Nowt to stop you doing your own thing at all, just don't try and usurp the majority fans views on here whatever stupid stunt you try to pull. If you do...

Oh don't tell me you're just all hot air and bollocks and looking for a rejection of your idea, without actually having to do it? You must be an awesome poker player with that type of bluff.

<laugh>

Let us know what James tells you.

<laugh>

Fez, I agree, those as allegedly passionate about wanting Allam out should stop going to games. All games. Not going to happen though.

Oh Happy. I am trying to get a banner put up that only I want and remove the one many on the forum wanted agreed to and paid for, If thats how you see it then your views are so entrenched and wrong no matter what i say you will disagree with me.

Dutch has said many times the club has no problem with a banner saying Hull City, I don't believe that and want to show otherwise. To that end I made my offer. If WE ARE HULL CITY can by some be seen as a protest sign I am more than willing to compromise as long as it says HULL CITY.

After reading other posts this morning it may be best to get something in writing from the club before paying, it looks like promises from the club mean nothing and much worse when they get other people to speak on their behalf.
Only one more little thing
 
Perhaps it's part of the reason so many people insisted the banner be kept clean of the politics.

Is saying 'City Till We Die' or 'We Are Hull City' political, or is the political element when someone labels one of those statements as being a protest statement?
 
It's easy to see why this happens. Predictable really. I'm sure you know why people don't want it to work out.

I know that on my own behalf I certainly want it to work out, which is why I donated to the original banner, I would also love for the follow-up project to be successful, but I would prefer it to be actioned when the name-change is resolved. I think anyone can see that some form of conflict of opinion in this is inevitable, depending on your viewpoint. Despite the lick-spittle reasons offered, we all know that Hull City AFC is being avoided by this project to dodge the inevitable rebuttal from the club.
 
  • Like
Reactions: balkan tiger
so 'we are Hull City' is a protest banner - you're possibly the stupidest **** I've ever come across - you remind me of Alec Guinness in Bridge over the River Kwai - he got all confused about whose side he was on
It's all about intent.

This is a pure protest from Balkan.

Actually, it's a virtual protest because he'll never see it through, it's classic keyboard warrior stuff in fact.

He's asking "what IF I paid for a Hull City AFC banner eh? Can it replace the In Bruce we Trust one? Can it? No? OMFGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG THIS IS TYPICAL OF THE CLUB!!!!111!!!1!"

Bluff has been called though, if he wants to get his own banner, nowt to stop him, Dutch can point him in the right direction, and he can arrange for it to be made, and arrange with James to try and find somewhere suitable.

He won't though, because he's just being angry about something online.

Why don't you chip in? He might appreciate the help.

Regarding being the stupidest ****, Im way out of your league for ****ery, you surpass even the worst on here and CI.
 
Oh Happy. I am trying to get a banner put up that only I want and remove the one many on the forum wanted agreed to and paid for, If thats how you see it then your views are so entrenched and wrong no matter what i say you will disagree with me.

Dutch has said many times the club has no problem with a banner saying Hull City, I don't believe that and want to show otherwise. To that end I made my offer. If WE ARE HULL CITY can by some be seen as a protest sign I am more than willing to compromise as long as it says HULL CITY.

After reading other posts this morning it may be best to get something in writing from the club before paying, it looks like promises from the club mean nothing and much worse when they get other people to speak on their behalf.
Only one more little thing
So stop ****ing bleating on about it, you got your attention, well done. Just do it. Contact Mauled, get one made, contact James, find somewhere to put it.

It's really that simple.

Unless you're just making noise on the internet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DMD
I forget, Charle1, are you in favour of changing the name of the club and the style of Allam's strategy in doing it? Do you consider the actions of the owner as 'petty point scoring', is is that just reserved for folk who oppose his views and methods?

Why do you need to know what an individual thinks of that situation? Is it because then you can then negate their views on everything else based on what they think about one area?

This is about flags showing support for the team Hull City. If anyone chooses to make it about something else and their own personal agendas is up to them. But by trying to derail something positive at a time when positivity, dialogue and building bridges is needed then that is a sad state of affairs.