Hull City Transfer Rumours - Summer 2014

[GLP]

I posted the section from the rule book that has the guidelines for how compensation fees are determined in the other thread. Here's the post:



He cost Blackpool £150k. There's no way all the other criteria add up to even £1m, never mind £3.35m, so I think the media are just speculating and are well wide of the mark.

Compensation fees are there to stop clubs being left empty handed for investing in youth once a young players had his head turned by a more favourable club and run his contract down. It's not about getting the transferor club the market value of the player, it's about recovering the costs of developing a young player. If they wanted to get a big fee for Ince, they should have sold him when he was under contract. They had big offers and they turned them down, that's their own fault. Whatever clubs may have offered to buy him or paid to loan him previously has no baring on what the tribunal will deem they deserve.

Even taking all this into account, how much credit can Blackpool take for his development, when his formative years were at Liverpool? Surely they made the biggest contribution to his development? Blackpool just gave him playing time and got a player on the cheap.

 

[Anal Frank Fingers]

It seems that Blackpool are basing their valuation on the amount that they rejected from Cardiff. They are arguing that they bought him at £500k from Livepool and rejected £8m so he has developed by £7.5m. Hopefully, the rulebook works as previously noted.

Then Liverpool have 35% sell on clause.

 

[cheshireles]

The only independent benchmark is Sturridge's move from Chelsea to Liverpool; another England U21 International with limited Premier League experience, tribunal set fee at £3.5m! Based on that and with Blackpool supposedly having already received a loan fee from Palace of £1.5m can't see it being above £3.5m, and potentially less.

 

[The FRENCH TICKLER]

The Joel Campbell(Costa Rica & Arsenal) rumour on a season long loan wont go away either.

Andrew Robertson(Dundee Utd left back) is also supposed to be in Hull this week ?

 

[originallambrettaman]

The Joel Campbell(Costa Rica & Arsenal) rumour on a season long loan wont go away either.

The only link we've had with Joel Campbell, was someone's article 'Five World Cup Players That Hull City Should Look At'.

 

[Pool Tiger]

Just got back from hols so to save me trawling through past pages, what happened to our enquiry with the Blades for Harry Mcguire?

 

[lewisc29]

Just got back from hols so to save me trawling through past pages, what happened to our enquiry with the Blades for Harry Mcguire?

I think we made an offer but not much has happened since.

 

[PLT]

I completely forgot about him.

 

[Jezz511]

I forgot about McGuire as well. Thought that was going to be a deal where he spent the season with them though.

 

[Steven Toast]

I forgot about McGuire as well. Thought that was going to be a deal where he spent the season with them though.

That'd be totally pointless, we'd pay £2m for a player we wouldn't get for another year. Even then Sheffield United are playing in League 1, we'd need him getting experience at a higher level. Had they been promoted this season, I could've seen it, but I think if we were to buy him we'd hang on to him for the European games.

 

[lewisc29]

"We are delighted to announce that Joe Dudgeon has signed a new one-year deal with the Club #UTT"

I'm pleased for him and think it's the right decision to give him a chance.

 

[ellewoods]

"We are delighted to announce that Joe Dudgeon has signed a new one-year deal with the Club #UTT"

I'm pleased for him and think it's the right decision to give him a chance.

I am sure that in the worst situation if he has lost something we can loan him out or sell him to a lower division side. Hopefully he regains the form he had with us before his injury.

 

[Steven Toast]

"We are delighted to announce that Joe Dudgeon has signed a new one-year deal with the Club #UTT"

I'm pleased for him and think it's the right decision to give him a chance.

Has he fully recovered from his injury yet? Is he back in full contact training?

 

[lewisc29]

Has he fully recovered from his injury yet? Is he back in full contact training?

He said he got back to full fitness last season and featured in two or three friendlies. So hopefully after a full pre season he should be ready to go.

 

[ellewoods]

Having Dudgeon back is almost like a new signing.

 

[lewisc29]

Having Dudgeon back is almost like a new signing.

Does that change our interest in the Dundee lad?

 

[PLT]

Does that change our interest in the Dundee lad?

I don't think Dudgeon's return from injury will have come as a surprise, so no. I'm not totally convinced we're actually after that Dundee lad anyway, although I hope we are. Didn't Burnsy say there was nothing in it, and it's just been crappy media sources that have linked us with him hasn't it?

 

[ellewoods]

Does that change our interest in the Dundee lad?

I would guess it wouldnt. From all the talk in the articles about him being a future star I think the club is trying to get a really good future player in young as opposed to shelling out lots of cash later for an equally good player. Its just my guess though.

 

[originallambrettaman]

I don't think Dudgeon's return from injury will have come as a surprise, so no. I'm not totally convinced we're actually after that Dundee lad anyway, although I hope we are. Didn't Burnsy say there was nothing in it, and it's just been crappy media sources that have linked us with him hasn't it?

I believe we are after him, assuming that the price doesn't get daft, though it looks like Everton might be in for him now.

 

[The FRENCH TICKLER]

The only link we've had with Joel Campbell, was someone's article 'Five World Cup Players That Hull City Should Look At'.

Ive not seen that mind.