Summer window

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
Have done some reading on buybacks and to clarify:

1. It's unaffected by this new deal Cirkin has signed; it's a completely separate contract between the clubs only.
2. As a result of 1, even if Spurs do activate it, Cirkin has the final say whether he wants to go back as he is not party to the "buyback contract" between the clubs. If they can't convince him, he stays [EDIT: This might be wrong, different sources say different things. I think it depends on how the deal was structured?]
3. The Sunderland Echo reported that the buyback clause expires on 30 June 2024. No guarantee they're right, but it would make sense. That gives Spurs three years from Dennis signing with us which seems like a fair compromise for all parties involved.

This is a good read, I think people are maybe mixing up first refusals and buy-back clauses;

https://www.mondaq.com/uk/sport/421830/football-transfers-buy-back-clauses-explained
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hefty fullback
It'll definitely have a time limit on it, otherwise he could grow to be worth well in excess of that fee and Spurs could sweep in and get him well below market value. Not a chance we'd be silly enough to agree to that.

It wont be longer than his original contract
 
  • Like
Reactions: Robertson
You must log in or register to see media

Fantastic news. Both of our full backs tied down long term.

They're both nailed on starters for me and can also be that for us in the Premier League. Tough defenders, first and foremost which I really like. Both have the ability to play in a back 3 too, which gives us a lot of flexibility.
 
My issue with the buy back clause is that they could do a deal to bring him back and sell him on at huge profit to a club he is happy joining. They could off him a hefty lump of their profit to sweeten the deal too. Its happened before - I think perhaps we did when we signed on of the German lads.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Daz and Robertson
Agree. It's something that I was really strong about in the Donald era. People saying we couldn't stop the best young talent leaving.

If you create the environment, engage correctly and provide structured opportunities, they won't want to leave.

Thats where we are now. Class.

...... if you build it, they will come
 
Thing is, everyone knows the size and potential of this club.

Our top players could all move to PL, any one of them signing shows that they see what we see within the club and the direction and ambition.

Regardless of the clause the fact he’s signed on shows where the club is heading.

The lad is a quality l, quality footballer.
 
Thing is, everyone knows the size and potential of this club.

Our top players could all move to PL, any one of them signing shows that they see what we see within the club and the direction and ambition.

Regardless of the clause the fact he’s signed on shows where the club is heading.

The lad is a quality l, quality footballer.
Both Hume and Cikin have mentioned this being the best place to be for young players to develop themselves. Great to see this change in culture is paying off. Long may it continue.
 
Wonder what happens with the buy back clause now ?
It will still be in, the terms of a sale has nothing to do the the players personal terms, 2 totally different things mate, the buy back and any sell on fees will be locked in stone till he leaves
 
My issue with the buy back clause is that they could do a deal to bring him back and sell him on at huge profit to a club he is happy joining. They could off him a hefty lump of their profit to sweeten the deal too. It’s happened before - I think perhaps we did when we signed on of the German lads.
When does it expire? Has to have a shelf life! Let’s just hope we keep him until it dies, or there’s something written in that increases it over time!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Oliver's Army
He could decline the move to Brighton as it’s a new transfer but he couldn’t refuse the buy back to Spurs as it’s already a negotiated clause. Cirkin will’ve agreed to the terms when the transfer to us was arranged
Normally a buyback clause is just a set fee and first refusal, the player can still turn the move down
 
  • Like
Reactions: Robertson
Status
Not open for further replies.