State vs Religion

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
The CofE is pretty moderate in terms of what people are and aren't supposed to do so I presume that even if bishops did have an influence it wouldn't make any real difference.


They do turn up en masse with certain issues

Iirc they held back portions of the equality legislation for some time
 


There are various articles mate (probably on wikki etc too, I haven't checked). I heard it on a news show a little while back, think posted it on the politics thread

The UK automatically gives 26 seats in HoL to bishops.

These bishops are able to (and do) vote on legislation, make interventions, and lead prayers at the start of each day’s business

The UK is the only democratic country in the world to give seats in its legislature to religious representatives as of right.

Source: Humanists UK ( <laugh>, I know but it came up on Google)
 
  • Like
Reactions: PleaseNotPoll
There are various articles mate (probably on wikki etc too, I haven't checked). I heard it on a news show a little while back, think posted it on the politics thread

The UK automatically gives 26 seats in HoL to bishops.

These bishops are able to (and do) vote on legislation, make interventions, and lead prayers at the start of each day’s business

The UK is the only democratic country in the world to give seats in its legislature to religious representatives as of right.

Source: Humanists UK ( <laugh>, I know but it came up on Google)

Is your debate about how much influence religion has in our laws or just how many clergy are present in our lawmaking chambers?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Quesadaad and DMD
Is your debate about how much influence religion has in our laws or just how many clergy are present in our lawmaking chambers?

I think it should be even wider than that. There's more to religion influencing the State than just making laws.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BobbyD
I think it should be even wider than that. There's more to religion influencing the State than just making laws.

Even so i think fan is wrong on both accounts.

I was just interested in what his pov was. For example if it was the former, surely brunei would be far higher straight away as the leader makes laws based on religion. Same with places like Malaysia and vatican city
 
Bangladesh is the best place to live according to a source.

Maybe we should reward UK ISIS types at let them move there? It's part of our commonwealth after all. <ok>
 
The fact is mate that we rank second to Iran in unelected clergy having a say. That's before you add in the monarch, albeit her involvement is pretty much to sign off on things presented

It was Henry the 8th who started it
Having a say isn't influencing, though.

Definitely not 2nd in the world for our laws being influenced by religion. 2nd last maybe.
 
Even so i think fan is wrong on both accounts.

I was just interested in what his pov was. For example if it was the former, surely brunei would be far higher straight away as the leader makes laws based on religion. Same with places like Malaysia and vatican city

Well this is what I was arguing earlier.

I also don't think it's just about religious people having a position of power, but rather the influence of religious groups and ideology on a state or on someone with a position of power. So for example, in Israel or India there is no religious pre-requisite to become PM but both are heavily influenced by particular religious groups - often extreme. Same with the U.S.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BobbyD
Having a say isn't influencing, though.

Definitely not 2nd in the world for our laws being influenced by religion. 2nd last maybe.

No mate we are second. We let Barbara who likes to make cakes down the church on Sunday call the shots, Saudi is below us because they don’t even remotely consider religion when they decide to behead people at the supermarket for a laugh.