New poll - in or out?

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

Pellegrino in or out?


  • Total voters
    163
I honestly don’t see the point in sacking a manager who has used the first 12 games to assess the squad he has ahead of a key transfer window. His philosophy on how the game should be played is not far from MP1 - he needs time to implement it. I personally think he should have stamped his style right from the off but can see why he did not want to alienate the dressing room. I’m quite sure Saints will give him at least to the end of the season no matter what.
 
  • Like
Reactions: VocalMinority
I honestly don’t see the point in sacking a manager who has used the first 12 games to assess the squad he has ahead of a key transfer window. His philosophy on how the game should be played is not far from MP1 - he needs time to implement it. I personally think he should have stamped his style right from the off but can see why he did not want to alienate the dressing room. I’m quite sure Saints will give him at least to the end of the season no matter what.

Out of interest, where do you think we would finish if we did that?
 
He does make some obviously correct points, but bringing back Koeman simply wouldn’t work. He alienated the Academy and reports stated that many parents were considering removing their boys because of his attitude. I have said this before, but in my opinion we still haven’t recovered from that situation, as there is still a gulf between the Academy and the first team which seems to be crossed very rarely. As for Nicola, I just don’t know any more. I understood the reasons he was sacked but looking at the apathetic mess the board is today, we need someone with his flair and drive to get things moving in the right direction. If not Nicola himself, then a slightly more financially prudent version of him. Ralph Krueger was a Katharina appointment, and that’s where Mr Gao needs to start in terms of shaking things up, followed by Les Reed. Bring in a chairman and director of football with sound knowledge of the Premier League and the ambition to go to the next level (a cup and regular Europa qualification would do for starters), as well as the will to improve the pathway for the best Academy boys, and let them make the decision about the manager and coaching staff.

Oh, and appoint Sir Rickie Lambert as U23 coach...

Completely agree. Before Puel was appointed I'd hoped we would make a move for Slavisa Jokanovic, plays attacking football with a high press and, as evidenced by his move to Fulham, isn't afraid to get the youngsters involved (iirc he gave Ryan Sessengon (?) his debut at 16 he then went on to play throughout the season). Not sure he'd be wonderful coming in mid-season especially given our attacking weaknesses, but perhaps he'd be willing to re-open the pathway to the first team for our youngsters and we'd see more of the likes of Hesketh around the first team. More than anything we need a manager who can give belief and confidence to our players. Puel wasn't able to do that, and it looks like Pellegrino lacks that ability too.
 
Out of interest, where do you think we would finish if we did that?
Difficult question to answer. If he starts to impose himself we could still have a top half finish. If he fannies around as he has done it will be a relegation battle (at least we’ll see some more academy players in the championship!). On balance, we’ll probably finish about where we are now which not be undeserved.
 
Difficult question to answer. If he starts to impose himself we could still have a top half finish. If he fannies around as he has done it will be a relegation battle (at least we’ll see some more academy players in the championship!). On balance, we’ll probably finish about where we are now which not be undeserved.

Interested. in what way do you think he has been fannying about? I see and hear a manager with one plan and one plan only. No experimentation, not mixing up formations or line ups as he searches for the formula. He doesn't seem to be searching for anything.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GoodOlStNick
The first home game of the season was positive, remember commenting that there were hardly any passes back to Forster, unless forced. By the WHU match we were regressing to Puel style.