Roy keane- Curtis
- Thread starter Tony Angelino
- Start date
-
Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
-
It's not Caulker I've got the issue with, it's bloody Smalling. He's been **** for Man U and he's only got 10 caps so he isn't being taken for his existing experience. At least with Cole over Ward there'd be that argument, there's just no good reason for Smalling to be ahead of Davies or Caulker, and yet I can see him being the only one of the 3 to actually be included.
Johnson will, and Walker, Naughton, and Jones can also play right back. Jones is going to be in the squad as a centreback, so pick Johnson and one of the Spurs lads and we don't need another centreback that can play out wide.
That's not the same argument. Look at the table, Smalling's playing in a side that you would expect to have more high quality players. The reason they're struggling this season (by their standards) is because the likes of Smalling and Cleverley and one or two others are not of the quality you would expect at Man Utd. That and the fact that quite a number of their older players have suddenly passed the point of no return.
He has been playing with Figeuroa LB and Elmo RB for most of the season, it's not like he's been in a team of brilliant defenders. He has played much better than Caulker and Smalling this season.
This is my point.
The reason why Man United are above you is because they're a better team. Not because Smalling/Jones are better than Davies.
The reason why Hull are above Cardiff is because they're a better team. Not because Davies is better than Caulker.
I know Davies has suggested that he is more comfortable in a back four and I suspect the same applies to Chester. He was more like his old self today, got beaten by Fletcher in the air a couple of times but got some great tackles in and his all round game was much better than recently.
But we have a better defence than them. By far. Even despite Figueroa.
If you'd watched us as much as you say you have, you'd realise that the reason we've occupied a mid table spot most of this season, is down to the fact that our defensive unit has been outstanding and Davies has been the most consistently high performing component in that.
I don't know how much you've seen of Caulker but from what I've seen, on current form, he's not as good as Davies.
You obviously have a deep seated issue with Davies from the past that seems to be making it difficult for you to see the reality of the situation.
Yes, but you've also been doing well because Mcgreggor, Rosenoir, McShane (wouldn't have guessed that) and even Chester. While I think Davies has been the pick of the bunch, I don't think he's done as well as other English defenders. This is my opinion.
I've seen a fair amount of Caulker and he'd still get into the Spurs squad. He's working with absolute ****e (Marshall aside). Not to mention the troubles the squad has had both on and off the pitch. They also lack Tom Huddlestone.
I haven't got a problem with Davies at all. He was excellent with the fans when he was at Leicester.
What makes you think that Macca?
Because you've don it so many times in the past can't help yourself.
