Time to replace Hamilton at McLaren?

[SgtBhaji]

just out of curiosity does anyone else believe this to be a WUM thread?

If yes, I'd love to know why.

Erm... not really. The art of WUMing is usually somewhat veiled or just out and out ridiculous. But I'd say there are some points and opinions that have validity. I might not agree with all of them, but they were clearly stated.

 

[Forza Bianchi]

are you alonso?
can you realy be sure...
hamilton is a very good driver and he has had a bad season, lots of drivers have had bad seasons and the only reason that you have hope for him leaving is bvecause you know that when he is back on top form he is a threat to your beloved ferrari.

Why would he give a fellow rival a confidence boost out of the kindness of his heart? No way he would not watch Vettel closely in pre-season testing.

your unbelievable bias reminds me of the idiots on the 606 forum. its ok to be biased to a particular driver or team, but completely disregarding reason for the support of your team is not

Would you change that comment if I changed my username?

 

[Di Resta is faster than u]

To be fair to him this was his worst ever year,

he won joint 2nd most amount of races and the only non red-bull pole position in his worst ever year.

 

[Max Whiplash]

What is funny about my opinion?

Well, firstly, I think your opinions are generally good and very intelligent but you can't seriously think that saying Hamilton should be replaced has any real currency. I mean, you've always been pretty forthright about how much you dislike Lewis and that is at the root of your article here.

 

[Kahn F1HR]

lol Hahaha jesus another idiot saying he doesn't deserve to be in F1 WHY create a thread like this Forza seriously you just couldnt help yourself yes this has been a bad season but dont be saying he should be replaced when he has had 3 wins and a pole this year despite everything thats gone on . You have obviously got personal issues with him should i go and make a thread saying how ferrari should drop alonso NO because i aint a retarted idiot talking crap. Even though im a hamilton fan i have high respect for what alonso has done in that dog of a ferrari . Him and button are my drivers of the year. END OF RANT

 

[Forza Bianchi]

Well, firstly, I think your opinions are generally good and very intelligent but you can't seriously think that saying Hamilton should be replaced has any real currency. I mean, you've always been pretty forthright about how much you dislike Lewis and that is at the root of your article here.

My dislike of him hasn't affected my original comment - my opinion is based on Hamilton's driving and that alone.

 

[tribo32]

Why would he give a fellow rival a confidence boost out of the kindness of his heart? No way he would not watch Vettel closely in pre-season testing.

well could it be PR or maybe even actual respect? they're still people and they can compliment each other, even their competitors. think about tennis, they say someone is the best or someone was better than they were out os respect.

Would you change that comment if I changed my username?

nope. it would be exactly the same, bias is bias, i just wouldn't know which team you were heeavily biased towards

 

[McFerrari]

I'm going to have to swear. I'm so sorry.

I ****ING hate ignorant moronic threads like this. I ****ing hate it when people have personal agendas against drivers. Do you have anything better to do in your life? Why can't we all admire them as the heroic, hard working, daring sportsmen they ALL are rather than resorting to such gutter football style hate? Unbelievable.

 

[cosicave]

I'm going to have to swear. I'm so sorry.

I ****ING hate ignorant moronic threads like this. I ****ing hate it when people have personal agendas against drivers. Do you have anything better to do in your life? Why can't we all admire them as the heroic, hard working, daring sportsmen they ALL are rather than resorting to such gutter football style hate? Unbelievable.

Stay cool McF!

Surely it's the nature of a forum to find lots of threads and opinions one does not agree with? It is also likely that many people present their opinions strongly. Perhaps you've even done this yourself on occasion?

 

[McFerrari]

Stay cool McF!

Surely it's the nature of a forum to find lots of threads and opinions one does not agree with? It is also likely that many people present their opinions strongly. Perhaps you've even done this yourself on occasion?

Ok maybe a bit of an overreaction. Yes we can criticise drivers because we all have to. But I really feel we shouldn't have these agendas against them that lead to ridiculous threads which says that Hamilton should get replaced at McLaren. He's had a bad year but this is the same guy who just two weeks ago won a race! Now if that doesn't scream 'RIDICULOUS' then I don't know what will.

 

[SgtBhaji]

One good thing for Hamilton this weekend... Apparently he and Massa buried the hatchet.

 

[Kyle?]

One good thing for Hamilton this weekend... Apparently he and Massa buried the hatchet.

About time too. It's embarrasing watching two grown men acting like spoilt children.

 

[Ajay Fernando]

I am no Hamilton fan. But i think he deserves another year with Mclaren.
Alonso and hamilton put on a good show-Agreed, but they didnt win the championship this year.
Hamilton will be competitive and will definitely fight back when he s got a good car.

 

[Bergkamp a Dutch master]

Forza - (yes a good idea - GO) Stupid opinion.
Alonso does nothing all season, Ferrari in disarray, Massa taking a personal vendetta against another driver -
and you try to deflect the report card for Ferrari to HAMILTON !!

Sad.......

 

[allsaintchris.]

just out of curiosity does anyone else believe this to be a WUM thread?

If yes, I'd love to know why.

Not at all.

You set out reasons, view points etc, it wasn't just a stupid 'get rid he's rubbish' and then sit back and watch everyone jump in.

Was going to prompt a debate and it did.

 

[El_Bando]

may I remind you.

WUM calling is against house rules if you have any problems please enquire a mod or discuss on the house rules thread.

Come on people! its nearly christmas.

 

[Bergkamp a Dutch master]

Bloody stupid mercenary tradition that should be banned.

Bah. Humbug.

 

[Bergkamp a Dutch master]

El_Bando - why the sudden jumping in?

getting lots of complaints are you?

 

[EternalMSC]

I'm going to have to swear. I'm so sorry.

I ****ING hate ignorant moronic threads like this. I ****ing hate it when people have personal agendas against drivers. Do you have anything better to do in your life? Why can't we all admire them as the heroic, hard working, daring sportsmen they ALL are rather than resorting to such gutter football style hate? Unbelievable.

Seconded, good heart felt comment my man. Say what you think, this forum needs sorting out.
There is an unbalance of morons who enjoy hating on one person behind a computer screen.
It is a joke.

 

[El_Bando]

El_Bando - why the sudden jumping in?

getting lots of complaints are you?

TBH I was not expecting a warzone. So as a mod it is my duty to clean up. If you want to offer anything constructive please refer to the House rules discussion.