How to solve our striker crisis in January?

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
You may laugh, but I think we should consider outbidding Rangers for Lawrence Shankland from Hearts.
Knows where the goal is, puts himself about and leads by example.
Could mebbies get him for £1.5 to £2m, and he could be a perfect fit.

Bart

Wouldn’t laugh one bit, proper goal scorer.

We were linked a few year back when he first went up to SPL I’m sure.
 
Agreed with this, none of those players mentioned are good enough for us. Diaz obviously is quality, its whether he could play as a CF or not - played wide left or in a front 2 for a lot of his time at Blackburn

Muniz from fulham would have been my choice, hes getting game time there at the minute but i was told a few weeks ago that he might be available on loan if they bring a forward in

Obafemi is another one from a PL team with championship experience. Not a massive fan of his tbh but he is quick and has scored 17 goals across the last 2 championship seasons

Chelsea have a young Brazilian called washingston who might be worth a loan deal, swap him with burstow. Hes got 1st team football experience despite only being 18 as played for santos last couple yrs, hes over 6ft so got a bit about him

The young Uruguayan (Rodriguez) we have been linked with n the Japanese striker (cant mind his name), both look very good - would be great to sign both. Japanese striker is very busy n holds the line well, he has good experience as well. Rodriguez could be unreal.

In terms of hemir, hes clearly a longer term signing and we need to be patient with him - not just cut him as folk have mentioned. A loan deal either now or in the summer would be good, depends if he is developing nicely in training

If he grafts , he will get the time he needs. You know as well as I do, there are so many young players who are willing to run through walls , and Hemir isn't. He will cut himself out of he doesn't change his tune.
 
Do you think the jump from League Two to the Championship in January is too much? I ask because I like Al Hamadi at Wimbledon and I believe we have been linked
I think potentially yes, it is too big a jump. Obviously depends on the player, and to an extent the type of football he is used to playing. Wouldnt be against signing players like that at all in a summer window where they can have a pre season with players at this level. I think the championship is a really tough league to adapt to as it is invariably quicker, more physical and so competitive. I think Rusyn said not long after he signed he was surprised at the level of our squad and we would be competing to win the Ukrainian league. I think that shows the level the championship is now.
 
Yeah that’s fair, I’ve not watched the 21s so can’t comment on his performances there, shame cos after pre season I really thought we’d found a gem, time is on his side though (as I clutch at any straw)

The last two games I'v seen him in, (admittedly only on TV) he has looked transformed and is now showing that pre season form again, I think Murty might take some credit here, and if Beale can replicate Murty's influence, we might just have solved our CF problem , I would also like to see Emil, Bennette or Rusyn pushing Roberts more for the right wing spot some time soon, as I think its been our real weakness all season, clutching straws is what we all do on here. <ok>
 
The last two games I'v seen him in, (admittedly only on TV) he has looked transformed and is now showing that pre season form again, I think Murty might take some credit here, and if Beale can replicate Murty's influence, we might just have solved our CF problem , I would also like to see Emil, Bennette or Rusyn pushing Roberts more for the right wing spot some time soon, as I think its been our real weakness all season, clutching straws is what we all do on here. <ok>

You don’t sign a 6’4 lump of a striker to run around like a headless chicken pressing. As long as he’s making runs to occupy the defence and push the defensive line back we’ll be a better team and he looked to be trying to do that against Ipswich but he was being ignored.

Haaland averages about 20 touches a game, 12 passes and runs the least of any of City’s Xl. We normally dominate the ball and have a defensive line that’s much higher than most teams so I’m not sure how necessary it is for him to waste his energy aimlessly pressing.
 
Based on? Our problem isn't the forwards we have it's the service we give them that is the issue. Burstow is the only forward we have given a proper run in the side.

Basic statistical chance? If any of those recommendations were to convert a single chance at any point during the remainder of the season they'd immediately outdo what our current lot have done.
 
Basic statistical chance? If any of those recommendations were to convert a single chance at any point during the remainder of the season they'd immediately outdo what our current lot have done.

You could say that about most players to fit an argument though. If we signed a new keeper and he conceded less than Patterson in the second half of the season he’s outdone him. Bennette has outdone Roberts by registering the same amount of assists in just 8 minutes.

If one of our strikers was thrown in at the start of the season and had played 20+ games average at least an hour a game then I’d agree but they can’t score if they don’t play.
 
Basic statistical chance? If any of those recommendations were to convert a single chance at any point during the remainder of the season they'd immediately outdo what our current lot have done.
Rusyn and Roberts have the exact same amount of goal contributions yet one of them has played over 1000 minutes and the other under 300.
 
Rusyn and Roberts have the exact same amount of goal contributions yet one of them has played over 1000 minutes and the other under 300.
Different players playing in different positions of course. A winger will always see more of the ball than a striker. Ba v Roberts would be a fairer comparison
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sour Patch
Different players playing in different positions of course. A winger will always see more of the ball than a striker. Ba v Roberts would be a fairer comparison
I agree was just trying to make the point that a player coming in and contributing doesn't necessarily make them a better player
 
  • Like
Reactions: TopCat.
I agree was just trying to make the point that a player coming in and contributing doesn't necessarily make them a better player
I think the problem with Hemir is that he was given the no.9 shirt and bigged up by the club's social media when he is (or should have been) a signing for the u21 team and been nowhere near the 1st team.

If what @Prehab26 is saying is true (and i've heard similar) and his attitude is wrong then he's got no future here
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sour Patch
I know we haven't had a forward for most of the season for him to provide for but that is so poor for a player of his ability.

His xG this season is the same as Ballards… his G+A per 90 is 0.06 - Hume is 0.08 and Ballard is 0.13.

Whether we’ve had a striker or not that’s piss poor. Of all championship wingers/inside forwards who’ve played regularly this season that has to be in the bottom 3% and that’s being conservative.
 
I'm pretty sure the recruitment people will have been **** hot looking at strikers in front of the January window,given they haven't got it quite right.
My take on it would be that Burstow would be returned to Chelsea....subject of course to the loan contract. If possible,Hemir would also be moved on and Mayenda would be set for a number of matches in the U21's....looking at next season.
That leaves Rusyn,who I've always thought would be an alternative to Clarke,coming in from the left,if JC was to get injured,or we received an unturndownable offer.
That's what I think they saw in him,rather than a target man. All of which means,I think we can expect an addition in January,who is a little more proven at this level.
No-one wants a Grigg,and no-one wants a 30year old+ journeyman looking to end his career on big bucks....we've already done that....it'll be interesting to see.
If Corey comes back fit and firing on all cylinders,we don't need much else this next month.
 
In my post which you quoted.

Ollie Watkins had played zero championship minutes before Brentford signed him so how would that be an experienced signing? The top scoring player who is playing mainly as a striker this season Rajovic at Watford who had no championship experience. Experience means absolutely nothing.

Shankland looks good up in Scotland. Maja was going for free also, both with experience playing in the British isles and 1st team football 3pm on a Saturday afternoon.
Just 2 examples from the top of my head who we could have brought in as more experienced strikers.
Millwall signed Nisbett in the summer for around 2m. Theres another striker that would have massively improved us upfront.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DH4
Shankland looks good up in Scotland. Maja was going for free also, both with experience playing in the British isles and 1st team football 3pm on a Saturday afternoon.
Just 2 examples from the top of my head who we could have brought in as more experienced strikers.
Millwall signed Nisbett in the summer for around 2m. Theres another striker that would have massively improved us upfront.

Maja has been injured all season and I wouldn’t say Naisbitt scoring in Scotland is any more proven than Rusyn it would’ve been a risk all the same. Plenty have made the jump from the SPL and flopped. It is worrying if the language barrier is the issue though because surely that’s something you plan for when you sign a player that speaks no English.

Hindsight is a beautiful thing we could sit here all day and say we should’ve signed such and such because they’re doing well but they weren’t proven at this level before now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sour Patch
Maja has been injured all season and I wouldn’t say Naisbitt scoring in Scotland is any more proven than Rusyn it would’ve been a risk all the same. Plenty have made the jump from the SPL and flopped. It is worrying if the language barrier is the issue though because surely that’s something you plan for when you sign a player that speaks no English.

Hindsight is a beautiful thing we could sit here all day and say we should’ve signed such and such because they’re doing well but they weren’t proven at this level before now.

I agree im jusy saying we were doomed to fail in the goalscoring department bringing in 4 new strikers and only one of them played for the first team of their former clubs, but doesnt speak a word of English, and his strongest position is where Jack Clarke plays by the looks of him.

I like many others hoped we'd have learnt from last season and losing a goalscorer in Stewart and replacing him with a kid (Joffy), doesnt work so i was expecting to see someone come in around the age of 28, in their prime with years of experience in playing first team football
 
  • Like
Reactions: Brainy Dose
Id have even had Billy Sharp to add experience but hes just signed for Hull. Kieffer Moore was also available and at 6 foot 5 hed have been a big asset up top with our wide men