Off Topic YOUR VOTE COUNTED...

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

ON 23rd of June which way are you going to vote?.

  • IN

    Votes: 28 43.8%
  • OUT

    Votes: 34 53.1%
  • DON'T KNOW

    Votes: 4 6.3%

  • Total voters
    64
  • Poll closed .
So best case nothing changes except we have £80m extra a week, or about £4 billion a year.

For context, that's the same amount we lose each year because the government doesn't go after tax evasion.

Put it this way. 4bil is easily going to be lost as jobs flood out.

Nobody wants to deal with the fact that a lot of companies come to UK cos of eu and we speak English
 
Put it this way. 4bil is easily going to be lost as jobs flood out.

Nobody wants to deal with the fact that a lot of companies come to UK cos of eu and we speak English

Sorry I misread the stats. £4b is the amount HMRC loses just because it makes calculation errors. The total tax gap from not doing their job properly is about £34 billion.

FFS.
 
So best case nothing changes except we have £80m extra a week, or about £4 billion a year.

For context, that's the same amount we lose each year because the government doesn't bother to go after tax evasion.

Especially the money squirrelled away in havens by the four families that run our right wing press - money the EU were legislating to go after.
 
Put it this way. 4bil is easily going to be lost as jobs flood out.

Nobody wants to deal with the fact that a lot of companies come to UK cos of eu and we speak English

Hopefully our loss will be a united Ireland's gain. Or an independent Scotland (not that they talk English there).
 
Especially the money squirrelled away in havens by the four families that run our right wing press - money the EU were legislating to go after.

The entire EU funding could be covered by still letting rich people avoid tax, but just making HMRC double check their numbers.

£4b a year lost by HMRC just typing the wrong numbers.
 
German Chancellor Angela Merkel has said the European Union has "no need to be particularly nasty in any way" in the negotiations with Britain about its exit from the bloc.
She insisted that deterring other countries from leaving the EU should not be a priority in the talks.
And she added she was not in favour of pushing for a speedy withdrawal.
Britain narrowly voted to end its membership in a historic referendum last Thursday.
Mrs Merkel was speaking after several EU foreign ministers - including Germany's - had urged Britain to quickly implement its exit.

"It shouldn't take forever, that's right, but I would not fight for a short timeframe," she said.
She added that she was seeking an "objective, good" climate in the talks with Britain, which "must be conducted properly".


Merkel has our backs <ok>
 
  • Like
Reactions: afcftw
If you're the EU right now, it would be political suicide not to support Scotland in any attempt to remain in there. They will provide all sorts of incentives. I also think the scottish people would go for it.

Where I think it will fall down is the UK government agreeing to it.

But the thing that's been missed here is how all this got missed when the SNP were first offered the referendum? Why didnt they insist any Scottish referendum happen AFTER the EU referendum. I get the feeling they've been right royally duped! SNP were absolutely naive and shortsighted!
 
That's fine.

If the 2 greens and 63 SNP go for it they have numbers

The whole point is the only way to be at the table to stay in is to have a referendum decision fast to say hey we want to stay and hope the negotiation done then encompasses Scotland staying in.

It's a massive reaction that the SNP have not expected so soon but they have to use it.

The thing it's Scotland saying we leave union to stay in eu would be a huge boost to eu at a desperate time so I would say the eu will fall over itself to help out the SNP for that boost. It would also hugely hurt us position at the negotiation table.

I've said all along we would probably need to do some appeasing of Scotland upon an exit vote, guarantee all the current EU funding and do a good enough deal with the EU that the scots don't feel like they are losing out and they will happily stay.

If Scotland left us to join the EU it would be seen as embarrassing for the uk, but wouldn't particularly damage our negotiating position. Also other EU nations with separatist movements won't be keen on taking in Scotland. The economic plan for an exit however which didn't convince the Scottish people in 2014 was based largely on oil revenue which is now massively effected by volatile prices which are less than half what they were then. The Scottish people will be worse off outside of the U.K. but inside the EU. The numbers for independance don't work anymore, if you even believe they worked in 2014.
 
German Chancellor Angela Merkel has said the European Union has "no need to be particularly nasty in any way" in the negotiations with Britain about its exit from the bloc.
She insisted that deterring other countries from leaving the EU should not be a priority in the talks.
And she added she was not in favour of pushing for a speedy withdrawal.
Britain narrowly voted to end its membership in a historic referendum last Thursday.
Mrs Merkel was speaking after several EU foreign ministers - including Germany's - had urged Britain to quickly implement its exit.

"It shouldn't take forever, that's right, but I would not fight for a short timeframe," she said.
She added that she was seeking an "objective, good" climate in the talks with Britain, which "must be conducted properly".


Merkel has our backs <ok>

She just wants a bit of time to make sure all the funding we were getting will be going to Germany instead.
 
I've said all along we would probably need to do some appeasing of Scotland upon an exit vote, guarantee all the current EU funding and do a good enough deal with the EU that the scots don't feel like they are losing out and they will happily stay.

If Scotland left us to join the EU it would be seen as embarrassing for the uk, but wouldn't particularly damage our negotiating position. Also other EU nations with separatist movements won't be keen on taking in Scotland. The economic plan for an exit however which didn't convince the Scottish people in 2014 was based largely on oil revenue which is now massively effected by volatile prices which are less than half what they were then. The Scottish people will be worse off outside of the U.K. but inside the EU. The numbers for independance don't work anymore, if you even believe they worked in 2014.

Different if the financial centre moved from London to to Edinburgh.
 
I've said all along we would probably need to do some appeasing of Scotland upon an exit vote, guarantee all the current EU funding and do a good enough deal with the EU that the scots don't feel like they are losing out and they will happily stay.

If Scotland left us to join the EU it would be seen as embarrassing for the uk, but wouldn't particularly damage our negotiating position. Also other EU nations with separatist movements won't be keen on taking in Scotland. The economic plan for an exit however which didn't convince the Scottish people in 2014 was based largely on oil revenue which is now massively effected by volatile prices which are less than half what they were then. The Scottish people will be worse off outside of the U.K. but inside the EU. The numbers for independance don't work anymore, if you even believe they worked in 2014.

No, a lot of the resistance to the referendum (especially from universities) was that leaving the UK would mean having to apply to join the EU and in the meanwhile losing all EU funding for a while.

That worry is now completely moot since the UK is on course to deliver the main thing that worried them about independence.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Peter Saxton
If you're the EU right now, it would be political suicide not to support Scotland in any attempt to remain in there. They will provide all sorts of incentives. I also think the scottish people would go for it.

Where I think it will fall down is the UK government agreeing to it.

But the thing that's been missed here is how all this got missed when the SNP were first offered the referendum? Why didnt they insist any Scottish referendum happen AFTER the EU referendum. I get the feeling they've been right royally duped! SNP were absolutely naive and shortsighted!

There's no way this current government will agree to a referendum before 2020 and they'd justify it by saying the negotiations with the EU could remove the reasons Scotland may feel like they want to leave the uk. Though if the SNP are sensible they will wait until after we see how negotiations are shaping up before attempting to go for independence anyway.
 
No, a lot of the resistance to the referendum (especially from universities) was that leaving the UK would mean having to apply to join the EU and in the meanwhile losing all EU funding for a while.

That worry is now completely moot since the UK is on course to deliver the main thing that worried them about independence.

Unless they simply say they will guarantee continuing the funding, then that issue no longer exists.
 
There's no way this current government will agree to a referendum before 2020 and they'd justify it by saying the negotiations with the EU could remove the reasons Scotland may feel like they want to leave the uk. Though if the SNP are sensible they will wait until after we see how negotiations are shaping up before attempting to go for independence anyway.

How many times! If and when the Scottish parliament votes for a referendum there would be constitutional chaos if London denied it. Get real - when Scotland wants it then it gets it. Just a question of when.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Peter Saxton
How many times! If and when the Scottish parliament votes for a referendum there would be constitutional chaos if London denied it. Get real - when Scotland wants it then it gets it. Just a question of when.

Read my comment again, then calm down. I've said that even if the Scottish Parliament wants to go for another referendum this current government won't allow it before 2020 and will have reasonable excuses why. Before Holyrood tries to pass a bill for a referendum they will also look to get the agreement from the UK government before casting the vote which the government can drag its heels with.
 
German Chancellor Angela Merkel has said the European Union has "no need to be particularly nasty in any way" in the negotiations with Britain about its exit from the bloc.
She insisted that deterring other countries from leaving the EU should not be a priority in the talks.
And she added she was not in favour of pushing for a speedy withdrawal.
Britain narrowly voted to end its membership in a historic referendum last Thursday.
Mrs Merkel was speaking after several EU foreign ministers - including Germany's - had urged Britain to quickly implement its exit.

"It shouldn't take forever, that's right, but I would not fight for a short timeframe," she said.
She added that she was seeking an "objective, good" climate in the talks with Britain, which "must be conducted properly".


Merkel has our backs <ok>

Ze Germans are practical and will want to continue trading with us as freely as possible <ok>
 
  • Like
Reactions: philo beddoe