I actually have quite a good idea that I’m sure the mods would appreciate, this forum should have opening hours like the old bbc 606 site used to.
Transfer Rumours Winter 2025 Transfer Thread
- Thread starter originallambrettaman
- Start date
-
Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
-
I actually have quite a good idea that I’m sure the mods would appreciate, this forum should have opening hours like the old bbc 606 site used to.
I agree with the opening time proposal but Big Vern should be exempt.
We can’t miss out on his wisdom due to the rest of our antics.
We can’t miss out on his wisdom due to the rest of our antics.
I haven’t read all of this forum in depth since yesterday because the messages just pile on, but if I’m not mistaken,what I have understood from all of this is that we are signing Ian Ashbee with the sell-on fee we are getting from Philogene.
It is a bit weird that the club basically never gets to announce signings because it drags on so long that the local press has already moved on from announcing Crooks to analysing his move before the club has even said anything. Takes all the wind from their sails and makes it all a bit redundant. If he genuinely did sign two days ago, not sure what the wait is for?
Can a mod move the Ash posts to its own thread as it would be useful to read about transfer news on the transfer thread rather than having to sift through pages of nostalgic irrelevance.
Ta.
Ta.
Not even just 2-3m, we're also losing out on the sell on from Ipswich, where if he does well and ends up going for 30-40m we're missing out on that too.
All that being said, we did earn a tidy profit on him when we otherwise may have only had him in on loan, so can't be too whiny about it.
So you have pushed the narrative for several seasons around us needing a defensive midfielder. I can’t believe you have not mentioned his name in vain in supporting this. I’m shocked that you now describe him as an ‘average’ player. I honestly believed your bedroom would be a shrine to the great man.
I don't think we had any control over any part of the situation, certainly not once we'd agreed his purchase with a buy back option. We couldn't turn down villas offer, couldn't avoid the sell on clause and it was purely up to JP where he went, he chose to go back to villa, he's now their player and they can sell him to whoever they want.
All things being equal, his ability was similar to someone like Docherty. His legacy as a club legend is because he captained us from League Two to the Premier League and was a servant of the club for nine years, not because he was a particularly talented player. We hold him in high regard for the same reasons Luton fans hold Pelly Ruddock Mpanzu in such high regard.
I honestly don’t know why some people are struggling with this very basic concept. He is a club legend; I don’t think any City fan would disagree with that. This discussion is about his technical abilities as a player and he was average (again, that is not an insult).
I do. It's the same reason people constantly harp on about wanting us to go back to the old badge, and other nostalgic guff, people look back on 'the old days' as being better times and pine for anything that reminds them of that.
“Decent” Captain?Decent captain, average player, if that's rubbishing him I'm losing my touch!
The views expressed in my posts are not necessarily mine.
Really? I prefer the old badge because in my opinion it's better, I prefer my midfielders to be technically better (yet again, decent captain average player) than Ashbee was, that's anything but nostalgic.
The views expressed in my posts are not necessarily mine.
Really? I prefer the old badge because in my opinion it's better, I prefer my midfielders to be technically better (yet again, decent captain average player) than Ashbee was, that's anything but nostalgic.
The views expressed in my posts are not necessarily mine.
I said it's the same reason, not that the same people are consistent about all nostalgic elements.
I can name several central/holding midfielders we’ve had since Ashbee who are more talented and better footballers, but none were better captains or leaders than him. Closest was probably Meyler.