The Premier League Thread
- Thread starter TheSecondStain
- Start date
-
Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
-
Shepherd's Clearing
Well-Known Member
Carrot cruncher actually - lived in West Dean, I'm originally from East Dean. I saw the first game he ever referreed - at Whiteparish.
If it was a dive I would award 5 out of 10 for effort, it looked to me that he had lost his footing and had prodded the ball too far, before the defender clattered in to him completing the job, no penalty but not a yellow either in my opinion.
Not for me, he played the ball purposely with no intent of getting it and then fell into the defenders leg.
I have only seen it on the Sky replay, and it isn't that clear, even in slow motion, if it was a dive it wasn't a very convincing attempt.
It is a common known fact that Shane Long doesn't get any decisions, so really if he was diving it would have been futile anyhow.
Yep, had that been a City or Arse player, pretty sure it would have been given. The Swansea player looked ready to complain....
He doesn't get any decisions because he's known as a diver. Not saying that's right but referees are human and that will always be in their mind. The boy who cried wolf and all that...
... and of course he never ever gets genuinely fouled, at least that is what the statistics show.
I can't remember it clearly but didn't the Watford player still have a chance to play the ball? Rather than kick it out of play and wait for the challenge.
Also I still think with Longs, there wasn't a 'reaction to contact', he was already on his way down.
No, he does not get decisions anywhere on the pitch. He gets clattered nearly every game & doesn't get the decision. And as for a reputation for diving, thats pretty unfair, there are plenty of bigger culprits out there. His biggest crime, he runs at pace with the ball while we employ crap refs! 
The debate would be on whether he was deliberately throwing himself down or whether his momentum had caused him to lose his footing, even if he was already going down, the challenge certainly made sure.
There's contact, a delay, then he goes down. Shane by the letter of the law just needed to wait for the pending contact. For me, Shanes is more of a penalty.
Ohhhh controversial!
Ohhhh controversial!
Courtois vaguely says that he might go back to La Liga at some point, The Mirror vaguely say that Chelsea will be in for Fraser if that happens. Which it won't until at least 2018.
http://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/footb...ea-goalkeeper-thibaut-courtois-admits-8874332
http://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/footb...ea-goalkeeper-thibaut-courtois-admits-8874332
That's about right. Buying a penalty is a legitimate part of the game (Suarez was the expert), Shane didn't quite get it right that time. Thought the yellow card was optional, but there we go.