Transfer Rumours Summer Transfer window

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
I dont agree mate, Patto is not as bad as half of yous are making out . Ive said it once and ill say it again i feel like he is getting badly disrespected on here.

Of course id love a World class keeper for Patto to compete against, it’s far from a priority position for us to fill though. Infact id say its last port of call behind getting a new LW, RW, CB and a striker.
opinions isn’t it, I think he’s nowhere near as good as you rate him
 
What's the source of this? Not sure I buy this administration agreeing to a sell on and a buy back. Sounds like a poor deal in the long term.
The buy back will be for a decent bit of profit at least. It’s how a fair few clubs operate now.

If it’s £20m for Petrovic, the buy back will last however long the initial contract is and will be for around £45m+
 
I dont agree mate, Patto is not as bad as half of yous are making out . Ive said it once and ill say it again i feel like he is getting badly disrespected on here.

Of course id love a World class keeper for Patto to compete against, its far from a priority position for us to fill though. Infact id say its last port of call behind getting a new LW, RW, CB and a striker.

Us wanting to sign a potential world class keeper has nothing to do with disrespecting Patto
 
I dont agree mate, Patto is not as bad as half of yous are making out . Ive said it once and ill say it again i feel like he is getting badly disrespected on here.

Of course id love a World class keeper for Patto to compete against, its far from a priority position for us to fill though. Infact id say its last port of call behind getting a new LW, RW, CB and a striker.
Wouldn’t say there’s much disrespect going on. We need another top keeper in the prem, it’s a massive key position.

Can save 8-10 points across the season if the defence stays solid throughout too. That’s crucial when trying to stop up.
 
I dont agree mate, Patto is not as bad as half of yous are making out . Ive said it once and ill say it again i feel like he is getting badly disrespected on here.

Of course id love a World class keeper for Patto to compete against, its far from a priority position for us to fill though. Infact id say its last port of call behind getting a new LW, RW, CB and a striker.

He did very well in the playoff final but can't let one game cloud our judgement, he was average at best for large chunks of the season. I think he's an upper Championship level keeper, or decent backup in the Prem, but simply not good enough to be relied on week in week out in the PL, imo.
 
Patto was statistically an average championship goalkeeper who conceded more goals than the xG model would expect from a goalkeeper facing the shots he faced

That’s not opinion, it’s fact

He was exceptional in the play off final (and the semis tbh) but that was a flash in the pan ultimately compared to the entire season - thank God that it was those games when he performed above his usual level. He isn’t good enough for a top champ club never mind a prem one. No time for sentiment, bye bye
 
Mikautadze is by far the best option but he’s already too high of a reach if we are being honest. He’s gonna have European football offers left and right.

Abline is still good and has a lot of promise. Wouldn’t be sad if we got him instead

Curious as I have no idea about Abline to be honest, but if we dropped £20m on him is he really that far ahead of Mayenda that he’d be a guaranteed starter? The last thing I want is 3 strikers who are all about as good as each other
 
opinions isn’t it, I think he’s nowhere near as good as you rate him

Yes mate, and i dont massively rate him. For what its worth though i rate him enough to think we'd be in safe hands with him as number 1 till at least January.
He also deserves abit of respect for what hes done to get us here. Sheff Utd could easily have beaten us without his saves.
 
Patto was statistically an average championship goalkeeper who conceded more goals than the xG model would expect from a goalkeeper facing the shots he faced

That’s not opinion, it’s fact

He was exceptional in the play off final but he isn’t good enough for a top champ club never mind a prem one. No time for sentiment, bye bye
Yep. He’s a standard good championship keeper imo. Nothing more and nothing less
 
Depends what the buy back is.

If its £20m now and the buy back is £40m that's a good deal for us. Gets us a brilliant keeper for at least a season and double our money if they buy back.

Like a loan deal just much better

Depends how much the sell on is as well though. Didn't Villa sign someone back from Hull recently and it worked out as a pittance because they had a buy back and a sell on clause?

I'm a bit sceptical about buybacks. Makes it feel like you're just developing another team's player for them and I wouldn't like to do that for a team in the league we are in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: alcoauth
Patto was statistically an average championship goalkeeper who conceded more goals than the xG model would expect from a goalkeeper facing the shots he faced

That’s not opinion, it’s fact

He was exceptional in the play off final but that was a flash in the pan ultimately compared to the entire season. He isn’t good enough for a top champ club never mind a prem one. No time for sentiment, bye bye
100% agree with this.
 
Depends how much the sell on is as well though. Didn't Villa sign someone back from Hull recently and it worked out as a pittance because they had a buy back and a sell on clause?

I'm a bit sceptical about buybacks. Makes it feel like you're just developing another team's player for them and I wouldn't like to do that for a team in the league we are in.

Will all come down to how well we negotiate the details. Could do it contractually so the sell on is only applicable to other clubs and not with the buy back.

Or the buy back could be £50m. Or £60m

It can work. And its common especially in europe to have these sorts of buy backs and release clauses etc. There may well be more of them in our club that we dont even know about.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Disco down under
Status
Not open for further replies.