Summer Transfer Window

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Welshie said:
Lol indeed.

By saying "you" in your post, you made it very clear you're not a fan of this football club.

So I ask again, who are you, who do you support?

Lay bare your bias before you comment like.

I think Panqueta is a better player than Maddison and value for money, I think that you're adding on a "proven premier league" quantity which I generally think is a load of bollocks.

The original point of my post is that we will never sign Maddison for 40m and in the price range we can get better, ala, better value for money.

Aka Pagueta for 30m is better than Maddison for 60m+
Click to expand...

Newcastle fan from the South West. Been a guest to this forum and off and on since 606 was closed. Read many posts, whether this is Tash's player ratings or rants on Ashley.

I do agree that Paqueta for 30 mil is better then Maddison, but I stil don't get where the idea that. Paqueta is avalible for 30 mil is from... Most rumours are saying he is 50-60mil. Premier League quality is hard to determine and do think its overstated by pundits who have to say something rather then stay silent. But from Eddie's position I understand why you would potentially go for more of a know quantity then a risk.. Werner would be decent. He's a great player..

Also regarding negotions, there are times the fan base is better then the negotiatiaters (Carroll to Liverpool etc) and times the scouts/negotiates better then fans (which club would have been excited by singing Gnabry 6 years ago, scouts who did in Germany need a pay upgrade..) ...These days though players value are based on computer models so negotiations are different.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Hung Drawn and Quartered
OssieJoe said:
Newcastle fan from the South West. Been a guest to this forum and off since 606 was closed. Read many posts, whether this is Tash's player ratings or rants on Ashley.

I do agree that Paqueta for 30 mil is better then Maddison, but I stil don't get where the idea that. Paqueta is avalible for 30 mil is from... Most rumours are saying he is 50-60mil. Premier League quality is hard to determine and do think its overstated by pundits who have to say something rather then stay silent. But from Eddie's position I understand why you would potentially go for more of a know quantity then a risk.. Werner would be decent. He's a great player.
Click to expand...
Paquetta would be closer to 40m I think. Probably more if you read some reports.
Maddison is a proven PL player and I reckon 50m will get the deal over the line with addons maybe.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hung Drawn and Quartered
Titus Bramble is 41 today.

I rembember I changed his name from Titus Malachi Bramble to Titus Malarky Bramble on Wikipedia, and it stays there for months.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back