Staring into the abyss?

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
You can have whatever catchment are you want, Bristol's must be huge, but if you don't offer the sort of experience people want, they won't go.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Polly13
Given that more than half of City's season ticket holders live in the East Riding, I don't think much to the ides that urban areas are what counts.

We have a massive area around us with no serious competing clubs in any direction. That should be a huge advantage but it hasn't been tapped into.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tinker Taylor
Given that more than half of City's season ticket holders live in the East Riding, I don't think much to the ides that urban areas are what counts.

We have a massive area around us with no serious competing clubs in any direction. That should be a huge advantage but it hasn't been tapped into.

Cant get away from the 18k who do Rugby although I would love to
 
Given that more than half of City's season ticket holders live in the East Riding, I don't think much to the ides that urban areas are what counts.

We have a massive area around us with no serious competing clubs in any direction. That should be a huge advantage but it hasn't been tapped into.
It would be interesting to note how far out into the East Riding those season pass holders are located, though. I don't think that 'massive area' is a real factor.
 
If we got only a few thousand less for Swansea in Division 3, there's absolutely no reason we shouldn't get 30,000 for the PL whoever the opponent is.

We're not some little backwater we're a major City with a much bigger population than some teams which get excellent crowds. Sunderland used to get 15,000 at one point. They turned that round and Hull is a bigger City. Brighton is a relatively small place with a large proportion of non-local residents yet they get incredible crowds because they look after their fans and make them welcome. That's after having no ground for about 10 years only a few years ago.

That small place Brighton with a population of 280,000, urban population of 475,000 and metropolitan population of about 750,000?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Polly13
It's not only the owners, people want to see decent football. It's true we've produced it in patches but too many dire, lethargic performances have made the ticket prices seem a waste of money.

I have a mate who's a WBA fan and he says he's stopped watching them under Pulis - and this is a PL team

They should **** off and watch Barser or Real Madrid then.

What they really mean is 'famous players' and ' a winning team who plays at a very high level'.
 
It's not only the owners, people want to see decent football. It's true we've produced it in patches but too many dire, lethargic performances have made the ticket prices seem a waste of money.

I have a mate who's a WBA fan and he says he's stopped watching them under Pulis - and this is a PL team
I agree.the football has bored the soul out of the place.there is no pre- match buzz around the kc at all.love brucie but it's thanks and cheerio from me.and take the owners with you please.
 
Sad thing is, I don't really care if we go up or not. I've lost interest. First game 1974, season ticket holder since 1997.

And I'm not ashamed to admit it.
Thats the thing aint it Cilly.
People find other things to do and it isnt easy to tempt them back.
I know personally at the minute I'll take a Saturday afternoon with a few ales with a few mates in the town over going to City.
And its cheaper!!
 
[
I'm trying to look at it in a different way, CC. I'm not convinced that a large, largely rural, catchment area necessarily equates to massive potential support. I think people like yourself, travelling in from places like Brid, will always be quite few and far between, and that the more immediate urban population is the main factor in the size of a football club's support.

FWIW, these are the clubs who have larger immediate, urban catchment areas than us.

Arsenal
Chelsea
Spurs
West Ham
Palace
Villa
Birmingham City
WBA
possibly Wolves?
Man U
Man C
Liverpool
Everton
Newcastle
Leeds
Sheff Weds
Sheff United
Nottingham Forest (Notts Couty?!)
Bradford City
Bristol City (Bristol Rovers?!)
Leicester City
Portsmouth
Middlesbrough
Coventry City
Cardiff City
Stoke City
Hull City

Then there are clubs with smaller, or similar-sized, immediate catchment areas but who have better support than us right now:

Brighton
Southampton
Derby
Sunderland

A lot of those are just plain wrong.

Brighton's population, as I replied in another post, is 280,000, urban area 475,000 similar to Hull. Portsmouth is nothing like Hull's. Wolverhampton doesn't have as large a population. Also a lot of them have nearby rivals. Go outside the city boundaries and there are nearby clubs, you can be in Elland Road living on the outskirts of Bradford quicker than you can get from Longhill to the KC.
As for Sunderland, it is smaller than Hull but draws a lot of support from all over Wearside. Back in the old days when there were dozens up in court on Monday morning after a game against Sunderland there were loads from Chester Le Street, Durham, Washington, Houghton Le Spring and elsewhere.
Saw City win at Roker Park in fron it 13,000 A couple of years later they had tens of thousands of life long fans wanting Wembley tickets and a couple of years after brought 16,000 down here. They were doing a survey of people going in to the ground. It turned out over 60% were from outside the city boundary.
BTW, years ago they did a survey of PL season ticket holders. Turned out the club with the highest percentage living outside the postcode wasn't Man .Utd, they were third, Liverpool, they were second, it was Leeds.
 
You can have whatever catchment are you want, Bristol's must be huge, but if you don't offer the sort of experience people want, they won't go.

Bristol has never been a particularly football mad area. We could take a leaf out of their book regarding utilising the waterfront. Though they have the advantage of having a decent river running into the city.
 
They should **** off and watch Barser or Real Madrid then.

What they really mean is 'famous players' and ' a winning team who plays at a very high level'.


Agree.

To paraphrase Mr Micawber, "More goals for us than against, even one, result happiness. More goals against us than for, result unhappiness". I want City to win. iIf I want entertaining I can always watch a so called big club on TV. Or go to the cinema or theatre (where there could possibly be more atmosphere).
 
I'm trying to look at it in a different way, CC. I'm not convinced that a large, largely rural, catchment area necessarily equates to massive potential support. I think people like yourself, travelling in from places like Brid, will always be quite few and far between, and that the more immediate urban population is the main factor in the size of a football club's support.

FWIW, these are the clubs who have larger immediate, urban catchment areas than us.

Arsenal
Chelsea
Spurs
West Ham
Palace
Villa
Birmingham City
WBA
possibly Wolves?
Man U
Man C
Liverpool
Everton
Newcastle
Leeds
Sheff Weds
Sheff United
Nottingham Forest (Notts Couty?!)
Bradford City
Bristol City (Bristol Rovers?!)
Leicester City
Portsmouth
Middlesbrough
Coventry City
Cardiff City
Stoke City
Hull City

Then there are clubs with smaller, or similar-sized, immediate catchment areas but who have better support than us right now:

Brighton
Southampton
Derby
Sunderland
That list shows that we are not even a top 30 team in this country which i would have thought the day we 1st got to premier league
 
  • Like
Reactions: Polly13
Cant get away from the 18k who do Rugby although I would love to

They rarely clash.

It would be interesting to note how far out into the East Riding those season pass holders are located, though. I don't think that 'massive area' is a real factor.

Indeed. I think the most untapped bit is within the City itself. I know loads of football fans in Hull who I've worked with or been to school with or whatever. Could talk to them about Leicester winning the league and other PL goings on for hours but the vast majority have never seen a live match. City really need to tap into that.

That small place Brighton with a population of 280,000, urban population of 475,000 and metropolitan population of about 750,000?

Relatively to Hull.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Polly13
How can a man who is a business millionaire not see this happening due to his ideas
Simple - As far as the owners are concerned - football success would be nice but it is far, far more important to p*** off the fans. If that means driving them all away and ultimately ruining the club then so be it. As someone said on here before 'nobody could make that many disastrous business decisions'. Especially a successful business man.
 
Obviously the Allams have alienated supporters. I think Bruce has too. The combination of premier league prices and performances which are not of that standard (we aren't top 3) is going to diminish support. Players play when they feel like it, we've seen that for some time, and they probably don't believe in the tactics as well. Even 2 seasons back at the end of the FA Cup run players just turned up for their appearance fee in the final league games. Once that's allowed it's hard to overturn it. The average time that players have been arsed in games this season is probably near 30 minutes. Even in the good runs there could be games like Ipswich away which depended on a brief spell of effort to get the win and the opposition being poor enough that we could hold out at the other times.

I don't think the support issue is simply about bums on seats, it's about a general disillusionment and tiredness with what is on offer, and the Allams predictably have been completely out of the loop on it, as they always seem to be with the support.
 
It would be interesting to note how far out into the East Riding those season pass holders are located, though. I don't think that 'massive area' is a real factor.

There's actually twice as many season ticket holders at City who live outside the Hull boundary and they're all over, Anlaby, Hessle, Cottingham, Beverley, all the West Hull villages, all the East Hull villages, Brid, Withernsea etc.

There are very few cities which have a single decent club within 30 miles, particularly in the Premier League, with a bit of sustained success and owners who didn't try and alienate the entire fan base, we could easily fill a 30k+ stadium.
 
[


A lot of those are just plain wrong.

Brighton's population, as I replied in another post, is 280,000, urban area 475,000 similar to Hull. Portsmouth is nothing like Hull's. Wolverhampton doesn't have as large a population. Also a lot of them have nearby rivals. Go outside the city boundaries and there are nearby clubs, you can be in Elland Road living on the outskirts of Bradford quicker than you can get from Longhill to the KC.
As for Sunderland, it is smaller than Hull but draws a lot of support from all over Wearside. Back in the old days when there were dozens up in court on Monday morning after a game against Sunderland there were loads from Chester Le Street, Durham, Washington, Houghton Le Spring and elsewhere.
Saw City win at Roker Park in fron it 13,000 A couple of years later they had tens of thousands of life long fans wanting Wembley tickets and a couple of years after brought 16,000 down here. They were doing a survey of people going in to the ground. It turned out over 60% were from outside the city boundary.
BTW, years ago they did a survey of PL season ticket holders. Turned out the club with the highest percentage living outside the postcode wasn't Man .Utd, they were third, Liverpool, they were second, it was Leeds.
I guy i work with goes the watch Leeds.
He said that its just full of fans arriving in coaches form all parts of the country.
Not many in the City actually give a crap about the football team