Match Day Thread QPR v Reading

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
If there was a league for playing slow side to side and backwards football we would be the European champions.

Against Fulham we finished the final quarter of the game well. Today JFH decides to drop our player of the month and our two goalscorers from the Fulham game as well as our motm Washington. If you keep chopping and changing the side it prohibits continuity and establishing your best Xl. He split up our midfield and our centre back pairings when he should be trying to fashion the spine and core of the team which we don't have.

I really don't get the resting of Luongo after being on International duty, it's not as if he's travelling cattle class. Tennis players travel the globe all year and compete in intense matches in arduous conditions every two days or so. I'm beginning to wonder if it's the club doctor and medical team picking the side such is the supposed advancement in sports science.

As for the game, we started slowly and finished slowly. You could swap slowly for negatively in that last sentence, the players didn't appear to have the correct mindset to compete in a professional football match. We hardly strung three passes together in the first half as ball retention was forsaken for the tactic of pump it up to Polter and the ball spent 50% of the first half in the air. Some positive points were Shodipo's pass to Wszolek which was sublime as was the finish. Smithies had a good game and did a good impression of Manuel Neuer as he played sweeper for most of it. And that's it! The rest of the game and its points have been well documented above so it's pointless me reiterating.

The only other thing I'd like to mention is the substitutions. The Caulker for Hall was enforced due to injury so fair enough, as was bringing on Sylla and Washington. But he replaced them at the expense of our width, and as our full backs can't get forward because they're not full backs so we had zero width, but we had two holding midfielders on the pitch. So with three forwards on we had to resort to medieval football. Bang it forward and hope Sylla or Polter can knock it down for each other or for Washington or Chery. The problem with that was we were sat so deep we couldn't get any possession to try and create anything half decent. In fact we were worse after the subs and there was only one team who looked like they were going to win all three points and it wasn't us. Henry who had a poor game should've made way as should've Perch who didn't do one single thing right all game.

We can't be as poor as this on Tuesday night surely? I've yet to see us win at home this season.
 
If there was a league for playing slow side to side and backwards football we would be the European champions.

Against Fulham we finished the final quarter of the game well. Today JFH decides to drop our player of the month and our two goalscorers from the Fulham game as well as our motm Washington. If you keep chopping and changing the side it prohibits continuity and establishing your best Xl. He split up our midfield and our centre back pairings when he should be trying to fashion the spine and core of the team which we don't have.

I really don't get the resting of Luongo after being on International duty, it's not as if he's travelling cattle class. Tennis players travel the globe all year and compete in intense matches in arduous conditions every two days or so. I'm beginning to wonder if it's the club doctor and medical team picking the side such is the supposed advancement in sports science.

As for the game, we started slowly and finished slowly. You could swap slowly for negatively in that last sentence, the players didn't appear to have the correct mindset to compete in a professional football match. We hardly strung three passes together in the first half as ball retention was forsaken for the tactic of pump it up to Polter and the ball spent 50% of the first half in the air. Some positive points were Shodipo's pass to Wszolek which was sublime as was the finish. Smithies had a good game and did a good impression of Manuel Neuer as he played sweeper for most of it. And that's it! The rest of the game and its points have been well documented above so it's pointless me reiterating.

The only other thing I'd like to mention is the substitutions. The Caulker for Hall was enforced due to injury so fair enough, as was bringing on Sylla and Washington. But he replaced them at the expense of our width, and as our full backs can't get forward because they're not full backs so we had zero width, but we had two holding midfielders on the pitch. So with three forwards on we had to resort to medieval football. Bang it forward and hope Sylla or Polter can knock it down for each other or for Washington or Chery. The problem with that was we were sat so deep we couldn't get any possession to try and create anything half decent. In fact we were worse after the subs and there was only one team who looked like they were going to win all three points and it wasn't us. Henry who had a poor game should've made way as should've Perch who didn't do one single thing right all game.

We can't be as poor as this on Tuesday night surely? I've yet to see us win at home this season.
Succinctly put as always, Mr 9s.

I was also going to point out the inane team line up and drop offs to the bench. Yes he did bring in Washington but for the wrong man. Did we change formation? If they tried, then obviously it didn't work for scoring, it was meant to see the match out but we barely hung on. At least get the front guys to try to hold the bal up better and give them flank support but more diagonal back passing nearly cost us.

I've never been one for JFH as you know, so there must be some backroom stuff going on that we don't know about that we're subjected to watching this drivel
 
  • Like
Reactions: QPR999
I can't understand why, after his energetic performance at Fulham, Washington didn't start rather than have to come on as a sub

Great pass for our goal by Shodipo, but I would've expected to see him used as an impact sub

Lynch I thought had a very uncertain game at left back, and Chery had one of his less effective games. In fact his corners couldn't be described as anything other than poor today

However, my biggest frustration was our hesitancy in going forward yet again. Yes - sitting deep when playing away maybe acceptable, but at home surely not

Two tough games coming up - we really need to see greater positivity; even I am struggling to get enthusiastic about going to our games at the moment
Wasn't Perch LB and Lynch CB?
 
Great idea, get yet another manager in for the umpteenth time and then all the stayaways might start supporting the team again.
Or keep this idiot watch dross every wk an more will stay away while we get relegated!
 
I was also there
Wszolek Man of the match for me not sure why he was taken off
Borysiuk was quiet for me but then playing alongside Henry is impossible
Henry was terrible
Lynch is a good lad and has talent but is not a left back
Him and shodipo is not a good left sided mix defensively
BFG got better last 30 mins sorighrightlyhas to stay on maybe meaning sylla didn't get a game
Reading were not that good so as every one says why be so negative
Shodipo is still a last 30 mins player in my opinion .he needs time
Perch has never had a good game on th right for us but has on the left
Of the current available player I,d have perch on the left Henry on the right and caulker plus 1 in the middle
Any 2 central Mid from 4 and see how they go without karlos to shackle them

Central mid is lifeless and we probably have the players there plus wszolek wide to do something now
Frustration is setting in
 
Then I'll support the club in League one like before
Getting relegated is not the answer. What fan would want his team to go down? The idea is to win and go up not down. JFH has proved this season (with his own team) that he will not take us forward. The football is dross and the fans are unhappy. It's not just yesterday it has been all season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rangercol
If there was a league for playing slow side to side and backwards football we would be the European champions.

Against Fulham we finished the final quarter of the game well. Today JFH decides to drop our player of the month and our two goalscorers from the Fulham game as well as our motm Washington. If you keep chopping and changing the side it prohibits continuity and establishing your best Xl. He split up our midfield and our centre back pairings when he should be trying to fashion the spine and core of the team which we don't have.

I really don't get the resting of Luongo after being on International duty, it's not as if he's travelling cattle class. Tennis players travel the globe all year and compete in intense matches in arduous conditions every two days or so. I'm beginning to wonder if it's the club doctor and medical team picking the side such is the supposed advancement in sports science.

As for the game, we started slowly and finished slowly. You could swap slowly for negatively in that last sentence, the players didn't appear to have the correct mindset to compete in a professional football match. We hardly strung three passes together in the first half as ball retention was forsaken for the tactic of pump it up to Polter and the ball spent 50% of the first half in the air. Some positive points were Shodipo's pass to Wszolek which was sublime as was the finish. Smithies had a good game and did a good impression of Manuel Neuer as he played sweeper for most of it. And that's it! The rest of the game and its points have been well documented above so it's pointless me reiterating.

The only other thing I'd like to mention is the substitutions. The Caulker for Hall was enforced due to injury so fair enough, as was bringing on Sylla and Washington. But he replaced them at the expense of our width, and as our full backs can't get forward because they're not full backs so we had zero width, but we had two holding midfielders on the pitch. So with three forwards on we had to resort to medieval football. Bang it forward and hope Sylla or Polter can knock it down for each other or for Washington or Chery. The problem with that was we were sat so deep we couldn't get any possession to try and create anything half decent. In fact we were worse after the subs and there was only one team who looked like they were going to win all three points and it wasn't us. Henry who had a poor game should've made way as should've Perch who didn't do one single thing right all game.

We can't be as poor as this on Tuesday night surely? I've yet to see us win at home this season.


As I said...............................

JFH isn't up to the job and with him in charge, we're ****!
 
Henry's negativity yesterday epitomised the failure to offer a real threat in the second half. The problem was, while Reading were playing like an integrated unit by the end, we had a big hole where the midfield should be, and faced with it, Henry went backwards. Do we blame the player or a manager whose fear of failure seems to limit the extent of his ambition as doing no worse than Chris Ramsey?
 
Getting relegated is not the answer. What fan would want his team to go down? The idea is to win and go up not down. JFH has proved this season (with his own team) that he will not take us forward. The football is dross and the fans are unhappy. It's not just yesterday it has been all season.

Who said anything about wanting us to go down? He hasn't proved to me that he will not take us forward. I've seen much worse football at Rangers and OK I accept some 'fans' are unhappy, but I don't believe that changing the manager again is the answer or do you think that all of our managers have not been up to the job? Under the constraints of what the club are trying to achieve I think that JFH is doing a better job than Hughes and Redknapp did with much better players. I can't think of a manager (who might want the job) who would suddenly get us winning and take us up.
I get frustrated when things don't go well and I wish we would start putting the ball in the box more often, but I believe every player is giving his all at the moment and it's been a long time since I believed that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: QPR Oslo