Diverse in that all north-west Europeans are essentially the same people, yes. Anglo is as ill defined as any national identity, all peoples have an ethnogenesis, a cake exists, but a cake is still made up of ingredients.
New Head Coach
- Thread starter FellTop
- Start date
-
Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
-
Diverse in that all north-west Europeans are essentially the same people, yes. Anglo is as ill defined as any national identity, all peoples have an ethnogenesis, a cake exists, but a cake is still made up of ingredients.
Highly regarded, he'll do for me. After watching the Still vid I didn't take to him. Hope they get it sorted before pre-season friendlies
I'd say as a youth coach he better hit the ground running mind or the fans will be on him as too inexperienced.
Believe it came from twitter/otr last night then echo etc brought out stuff this morning about it saying he has been on the shortlist
No just Large White lies.You think they're telling porkies
Was he the assistant through Jansen's whole four years there?
I hope he's not the John Robertson to Martin O'Neill or the Taylor to Clough if we are in for Jansen...
I think you’re right. Beale and Dodds are/were both highly regarded as coaches but it’s been disastrous for both of them in charge. If we were to make the same mistake a third time running it wouldn’t take the fans long to turn
Being honest for me
Rosenior - ready for the league
Wait for it Alex Neil - ready for the league / though I’d like also to hit him with a rock
Janson
Still
Hes been more than just a youth coach, hes been an assistant at dortmund, gladbach, leeds and Salzburg.
I get what you are saying but lets be honest whoever comes in, if they get off to a bad start some of the fans will be all over them
Highly rated coaches have had success in the championship, certainly last season and i think Maric's upside is so exciting
It might not work, if he did come in, but we could say that about pretty much every manager
I don’t really understand the ‘ready for the league’ argument. These are professional head coaches.
If it’s from a non league background or someone who’s never been a gaffer before then maybe it’s a factor.
However, both Jansen & Still have been a manager for years at a top level, and Jansen has midweek European games experience too. It’s not like they’re going to get a shock playing in the 2nd tier in England.
That depends on how you define 'the same people'. At the points at which the various groups that make up the English people (if you use the definition that fell out of usage in the 1950s), came together, they were culturally significantly different from one another and that would have been highly obvious to anyone living at the time.
Unless used as part of a term to denote a combination, such as Anglo-Scottish or Anglo-Italian, the term Anglo has attracted some negative connotations. 'Anglo-Saxon' for example has been suggested to be a racist term, partly due to its use in 19th century racial theories, which have been scientifically dismissed, and to cast the 'Celtic' (also an inaccurate term) peoples as outsiders. It has also been dismissed as being inaccurate as a historical term. This latter point, although technically true, I don't agree with because it's replacement term 'early medieval' is even less accurate. I addressed this point in a book I had published recently. Nonetheless, the description of your 'cake' as 'Anglo' is jarring on the basis that, generally, academic thought is now moving towards it use only to describe the Angles (so Crosby, being of Old Norse or Gaelic origin can't be Anglo) and because a much more accurate word, English, exists to describe things from or of England.
Sure, but it's a gamble and the club have to decide what sort of appointment to make, for every success there are likely even more failures, my mind immediately goes to Clement at Derby who had an absolutely elite CV before being appointed.
A big part of having a good management CV is that when things are going tough you can point to experiences prior that suggest they can get out of it, you want as many things to grasp onto as possible.