Lia Thomas

  • Thread starter Thread starter Prehab26
  • Start date Start date
  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
It's the equivalent of years of unrestricted doping. Yes, their testosterone levels might be low now, but they've had the benefit of much higher levels than is legal for a woman for a long time.

Maybe it should be like disability sports, various categories for various levels of transition.

Sooner or later a trans woman (or is it man, not sure on the terminology) will kill or seriously injure a woman in a contact sport and then it will all kick off.

Better still, their own sport with their own funding ...

.... lets see how far that gets them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Blond Bombshell
I'm all for supporting the transgender community and their rights to compete.

It's the combat sports that I worry about. There's women having their faces punched in and getting beat up quite badly from women who have transitioned from being male. I hope it isn't going to take for somebody to get seriously hurt, or worse, until the governing bodies step in and review it.

I don't see why we can't have an extra category for sports, now. Male, Women, Trans.

I can't see any other way forward than this. It's not ideal for trans people because there aren't that many of them, relatively, and it would affect their careers negatively but realistically it's the only option.

Nothing else makes sense imo and I suspect the authorities know that.
 
I can't see any other way forward than this. It's not ideal for trans people because there aren't that many of them, relatively, and it would affect their careers negatively but realistically it's the only option.

Nothing else makes sense imo and I suspect the authorities know that.
It wouldn't be too difficult to create a class for them within the paralympic structure if necessary.
 
  • Like
Reactions: C Montgomery Burns
I can't see any other way forward than this. It's not ideal for trans people because there aren't that many of them, relatively, and it would affect their careers negatively but realistically it's the only option.

Nothing else makes sense imo and I suspect the authorities know that.
Yeah, I totally agree.

It's not fair as it stands. It is the only option.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nacho
Trans people aren't gay though, they're just born in the wrong gender.
They're covered under the umbrella of the organisation. From their FAQ's...

"The Gay Games welcome athletes of any sexual orientation or gender identity. And the people who participate in the Gay Games continue to compete in sport between each edition of the Gay Games. Some do so exclusively in LGBTQ+ sports organizations, but most compete in mainstream sport, both individual and team sport."
 
  • Like
Reactions: C Montgomery Burns
They're covered under the umbrella of the organisation. From their FAQ's...

"The Gay Games welcome athletes of any sexual orientation or gender identity. And the people who participate in the Gay Games continue to compete in sport between each edition of the Gay Games. Some do so exclusively in LGBTQ+ sports organizations, but most compete in mainstream sport, both individual and team sport."

It's the first time I've heard of them and I doubt trans athletes would be keen to accept what is both a professional demotion and a potentially inaccurate labelling of their sexuality. They will want to compete with the best.

Unfortunately I don't see how that's possible realistically.
 
It's the first time I've heard of them and I doubt trans athletes would be keen to accept what is both a professional demotion and a potentially inaccurate labelling of their sexuality. They will want to compete with the best.

Unfortunately I don't see how that's possible realistically.
The only way in reality that i can see for them to move forward and be accepted is to have their own competitions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Saf and Nacho
The only way in reality that i can see for them to move forward and be accepted is to have their own competitions.

I agree I just think the only way it could happen in the long term is if it was of equal popularity with the others, which I don't think would happen for a long time.

It's a shame but I don't think there's a neat solution to this problem.
 
I agree I just think the only way it could happen in the long term is if it was of equal popularity with the others, which I don't think would happen for a long time.

It's a shame but I don't think there's a neat solution to this problem.
I agree however i don't think they should be able to compete with the gender they're transitioning to.

Could you imagine if a country put a team of transitioning males into something like the womens world cup?
 
I agree however i don't think they should be able to compete with the gender they're transitioning to.

Could you imagine if a country put a team of transitioning males into something like the womens world cup?

Neither do I mate I think we're on the same page.

My only point really is that there's no satisfactory answer to the problem and I don't think there ever will be unfortunately.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ozzymac
I can't see any other way forward than this. It's not ideal for trans people because there aren't that many of them, relatively, and it would affect their careers negatively but realistically it's the only option.

Nothing else makes sense imo and I suspect the authorities know that.

I was rejected by the RAF because I was slightly colour blind, so I chose a different career ...

... shyte happens, just do summat else and get on with your life ffs.