Transfer Rumours January '22 Transfer Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
Or it's a younger player and they need game time but can't move till their club has numbers in and could possibly have the same impact as Wilson and Campbel did...

I think we would need to be lucky for that to happen. First criteria will be they have to pay us to play.
 
Whatever you think of McCann, and he did a fantastic job last year, he was dealt a s**t hand in the January transfer window when we sold Bowen and Grosiski. He is currently in that exact same boat, being asked to deliver championship performances with a predominantly L1 squad, you have got to have some sympathy for him.
On the flip side, when he has been allowed to bring people in, they just haven't been good enough... Wasted loan deals Matty Smith, signings Andy Cannon, George Moncur, Randell Williams.... in fact come to think of it we likely haven't taken up our quote of loan options (correct me if im wrong) and whats the common denominator in the failures!!?
 
Whatever you think of McCann, and he did a fantastic job last year, he was dealt a s**t hand in the January transfer window when we sold Bowen and Grosiski. He is currently in that exact same boat, being asked to deliver championship performances with a predominantly L1 squad, you have got to have some sympathy for him.

If I liked your post some would interpret that as a weakening in my stance. I'll grant you his job is not being made any easier by all this shenanigans or by having Allam as a boss.
 
On the flip side, when he has been allowed to bring people in, they just haven't been good enough... Wasted loan deals Matty Smith, signings Andy Cannon, George Moncur, Randell Williams.... in fact come to think of it we likely haven't taken up our quote of loan options (correct me if im wrong) and whats the common denominator in the failures!!?
Not sure you can say Williams isn't good enough when he was one of the best when he finally came on against Stoke?
I think he's done a reasonable job when asked to tbh
 
Not sure you can say Williams isn't good enough when he was one of the best when he finally came on against Stoke?
I think he's done a reasonable job when asked to tbh

I think Williams has a good deal of potential to be a starter. Not sure why McCann persisted with Wilks in front of him for the first half of this season
 
On the flip side, when he has been allowed to bring people in, they just haven't been good enough... Wasted loan deals Matty Smith, signings Andy Cannon, George Moncur, Randell Williams.... in fact come to think of it we likely haven't taken up our quote of loan options (correct me if im wrong) and whats the common denominator in the failures!!?
I agree on this because how many of the signings have got in the first team but the only thing I will say is that because of the budget he wasn’t going to get many established championship players so gambled on lower league players hoping they would become good. In hindsight he would have been better bringing in less players but more proven players at this level but then you have a smaller squad. It’s difficult with a low budget.
 
I agree on this because how many of the signings have got in the first team but the only thing I will say is that because of the budget he wasn’t going to get many established championship players so gambled on lower league players hoping they would become good. In hindsight he would have been better bringing in less players but more proven players at this level but then you have a smaller squad. It’s difficult with a low budget.

I think it's difficult to question the signings personally, they were pretty good considering the budget.

The budget is the problem, not the signings. I think the transfer market is without a doubt one of Grant's biggest strengths, I actually feel it's the only thing keeping us competitive. When you look at what we spent this summer and where the lads had come from I think it's gone pretty well.

Baxter, and Longman have been fantastic, Bernard has done okay as have Tyler and Randell, Moncur and Cannon. It's sort of what it is on the current budget, we've not been helped by injuries either but still have a nice little cushion above the bottom 3
 
I think it's difficult to question the signings personally, they were pretty good considering the budget.

The budget is the problem, not the signings. I think the transfer market is without a doubt one of Grant's biggest strengths, I actually feel it's the only thing keeping us competitive. When you look at what we spent this summer and where the lads had come from I think it's gone pretty well.

Baxter, and Longman have been fantastic, Bernard has done okay as have Tyler and Randell, Moncur and Cannon. It's sort of what it is on the current budget, we've not been helped by injuries either but still have a nice little cushion above the bottom 3

I see the signings as very different to you.

Baxter has been a very good signing and unlike others, have been impressed by Bernard, although his form is patchy.

Everyone else has been in and out of the team so much, its difficult to get a handle on them. As it stands, I don't feel as though any of them were better than what we already had.
 
I see the signings as very different to you.

Baxter has been a very good signing and unlike others, have been impressed by Bernard, although his form is patchy.

Everyone else has been in and out of the team so much, its difficult to get a handle on them. As it stands, I don't feel as though any of them were better than what we already had.

I would add we don' have much of a cushion above the bottom three.
 
I see the signings as very different to you.

Baxter has been a very good signing and unlike others, have been impressed by Bernard, although his form is patchy.

Everyone else has been in and out of the team so much, its difficult to get a handle on them. As it stands, I don't feel as though any of them were better than what we already had.

Can I ask what you expected?

The signings were mainly about adding more depth and that was done successful and the hope was that our key players would step up to the Championship.

I don't think we signed anyone that another Championship side was interested in. Maybe Longman, I think he was linked with Forest. But apart from that we were proper scraping the barrel. Most the signings had to step up a least 1 level and the couple we signed from championship clubs had been released by lesser sides
 
Status
Not open for further replies.