Jak or Marshall

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
TIGERSCAVE

TIGERSCAVE

Well-Known Member
Dec 6, 2015
19,755
13,881
113
South Cave
Personally think Jak was dealt a bad hand getting dropped after the Arsenal game... for conceding 4.. on that basis Marshall has to be dropped for conceding 5.....

Also, Jak to my eye seems far more agile, hard to judge Marshall one game admittedly, but i'm pretty certain would have saved at least one of Milners pens.. what Jak also brings is the passion that saw the 12 through the first few weeks.. i'd rather have him in than out especially reading his stats ratio published the other day making him the best shot stopper out there..
 
  • Like
Reactions: over18and legal, SydneyTiger14, Kempton and 4 others
Marshall is the better keeper IMHO, shame for Jak but Marshall showed how good he was against Stoke, and tbf I don`t see what he could have done about any of the Liverpool goals, the defence got over run through our midfield not coping, poor bugger must have felt like he was in a coconut shy. Marshall has also proven opver the last few years how good he is in a fairly average Cardiff team.
 
Happy Tiger said:
Marshall.

No question at all.

He was not at fault for the Liverpool game. In fact, he helped keep it down.
Click to expand...

Baloney...Jak would have saved 2-3 of those goals. Marshall never moved on two of them....rooted to the spot. There was a reason Cardiff let Marshall go and they are a bottom of the table Championship team. He's ok as long as the shots go straight at him or above him. But like McG he no longer has the agility to get down to shots in the corners...even slow rollers like Lailanas and Manes. Jak is always moving and anticipating. Jak should only be dropped to give Marshall some playing time in League Cup games.
 
  • Like
Reactions: over18and legal, Dr.Stanley O'Google, HCFC, Kempton and 2 others
Hull City AFC (GLP) said:
I'll be honest Dusan and say I don't know why the **** we bought you either. Completely pointless signing.
Click to expand...
My thinking is Greegsys back problem was well known but he soldiered on, hopefully to the end of the season. He lasted longer than we thought.
We didnt have much money to spend for a 3rd choice. So Dusan gets bought as cover for Greegsys bad back.
I saw him pre season. He looked alright made a good save at Grimsby, tipped onto the bar i think.
 
CANADATIGER said:
Baloney...Jak would have saved 2-3 of those goals. Marshall never moved on two of them....rooted to the spot. There was a reason Cardiff let Marshall go and they are a bottom of the table Championship team. He's ok as long as the shots go straight at him or above him. But like McG he no longer has the agility to get down to shots in the corners...even slow rollers like Lailanas and Manes. Jak is always moving and anticipating. Jak should only be dropped to give Marshall some playing time in League Cup games.
Click to expand...

I can think of five million reasons Cardiff let him go.

Marshall all day long for me.
 
You can't keep swapping goalies every time you lose! Jak needed to be replaced after Arsenal & Marshall deserved the start. He has to get a run going & it's unfortunate it's happened with all these "big" teams coming up.
Saturday has to be:

Marshall

Snodge, Davies, Livermore, Maguire, Robbo

Clucas, Mason, Meyler

Abel H, Bob

I'm hoping MP doesn't stick with a back 4 & bung Meyler at RB, or Weir for that matter.
 
On another note about this weekends game, I had a dream/vision of 2 sendings off.... For Chelski!
We won 4-0, 2-0 up in under 5 minutes!<badger>
Not changing my predictions though or putting a bet on it.
Just a thought. Probably 100% bollocks.:cheesy:
 
Brucebones said:
On another note about this weekends game, I had a dream/vision of 2 sendings off.... For Chelski!
We won 4-0, 2-0 up in under 5 minutes!<badger>
Not changing my predictions though or putting a bet on it.
Just a thought. Probably 100% bollocks.:cheesy:
Click to expand...
Oi sod off, the regulation 4-0 is mine, get your own thing.

Like the MDT or sommat.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kempton
Brucebones said:
You can't keep swapping goalies every time you lose! Jak needed to be replaced after Arsenal & Marshall deserved the start. He has to get a run going & it's unfortunate it's happened with all these "big" teams coming up.
Saturday has to be:

Marshall

Snodge, Davies, Livermore, Maguire, Robbo

Clucas, Mason, Meyler

Abel H, Bob

I'm hoping MP doesn't stick with a back 4 & bung Meyler at RB, or Weir for that matter.
Click to expand...

I assume you're saying that because Meyler or Weir would be out of position at RB. That being the case, how is Snodgrass at right wing back any better

Whatever we do we haven't got a right back or right wing back for this game and someone will have to play slightly out of position. The question is do you piss about with the formation and move your best attacking player into a more defensive role or do you trust Meyler to slot in and do a solid but unspectacular job and leave everyone else as they are?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back