Bit of fun - and passing the time. Saw this on the Arsenal board so I thought I'd do a Liverpool version. I'll say now I'm an avid FIFA player (ps3) and will try to be realistic. GK: Reina 85 GK: Doni 75 GK: Jones 70 GK: Gulasci 64 GK: Hansen 58 RB: Johnson 80 RB: Kelly 77 RB: Flanagan 70 RB: Mendy 59 CB: Carragher 81 CB: Agger 82 CB: Skrtel 80 CB: Kyrgiakos 77 CB: Ayala 74 CB: Wilson 72 CB: Wisdom 64 LB: Aurelio 75 LB: Insua 75 LB: Robinson 71 CDM: Lucas 80 CDM: Poulsen 73 CDM: Coady 67 RM: Maxi Rodriguez 78 RM: Henderson 78 RW: Kuyt 81 (Hopefully he'll finally be a RW, not a ST) RW: Amoo 62 CM: Meireles 82 CM: Aquilani 81 CM: Adam 80 CM: Shelvey 75 CM: Spearing 71 CAM: Gerrard 85 (Poor season but always has a high rating) CAM: Cole 77 CAM: Suso 66 LM: Downing 81 LW: Sterling 69 CF: Suarez 84 (Could be anything from 83 to 86) CF: Pacheco 74 ST: Carroll 81 (Hopefully over the 80 rating, won't be much higher unfortunately) ST: N'Gog 75 ST: Eccleston 69 ST: Morgan 67 Possible signings LB: Enrique 77 CB: Dann 78 Have I missed anyone? Thoughts?
Good thread! It is somthing I have been thinking about myself. I agree with your ratings generally, but here goes For me: Reina: 85 Doni: 80 Hansen 58 Johnson 80 Kelly 78 Flanagan 72 Carragher 80 Agger 82 Skrtel 80 Kyrgiakos 77 Ayala 70 Wilson 68 Aurelio 78 Insua 75 Robinson 70 Lucas 80 Poulsen 74 Maxi Rodriguez 78 Henderson? God knows. Kuyt 82 Meireles 80 Aquilani 82 Adam 79 Shelvey 75 Spearing 77 Gerrard 83 Suso: 70 Downing 80 Sterling 70 Suarez 85 Carroll 80 N'Gog 78
Spearing's a bit low and I reckon Enrique would be 81-82, Lucas probably deserves a 82 as well, but apart from that I agree.
They always short change us... I'd be happy if most of the starting team was 80+ to be honest. If the manager mode player growth is sorted out, we could have a really strong team with those young players improving. Enrique is talented enough to be over 80, but FIFA do seem to level out player skills in batches. IE. Enrique will go in the late 70's bracket along with Taiwo, Riise etc. and the only ones above 80 will be Abidal, Zanetti, Marcelo and the like.
Reina- 87 Henderson- 78 Carroll- 85 - Just because of his price. Suarez- 86 I think Flanagan, Robinson and Ayala will be lower than you'v put though.
I cant see too much movement from last year. Carroll and Lucas will be higher, not much else. We will still be a 4.5 star team but at least there will be more options from the bench.
Can't see Doni being an 80. He's 75 in Fifa 11, and hasn't done anything to suggest he needs to be 5 points higher. Think Carroll will be around the 80 mark though. He was increased from the low 70s to a 79 in the most recent player update, while Raul also went up a couple of points. I often adjust player ratings and stats myself if I feel they're particularly inaccurate anyway (like Maicon being a 90 sprint speed to Bale's 85!), so I'm not overly concerned. I just hope we have a few less generic faces in our squad! P.S: £10 says Baines still isn't rated higher than Evra or A. Cole.
Reina 86 Doni 74 Jones 70 Gulasci 63 Johnson 82 Kelly 76 Flanagan 70 Carragher 82 Agger 83 Skrtel 80 Kyrgiakos 74 Ayala 72 Wilson 70 Wisdom 64 Aurelio 75 Insua 73 Robinson 69 Lucas 82 Poulsen 72 Coady 65 Maxi Rodriguez 77 Henderson 79 Kuyt 82 Amoo 60 Meireles 81 Aquilani 82 Adam 80 Shelvey 73 Spearing 72 Gerrard 85 Cole 76 Suso 63 Downing 83 Sterling 67 Suarez 86 Pacheco 74 Carroll 82 N'Gog 74 Eccleston 68 Morgan 66
its hard to tell with fifa. sometimes all the points are too high. sometimes too low. It's like when the highest rating used to be 93, now its 89 or whatever. anyway, i can't do them all because i haven't watched all of them play, but as an impartial opinion i would say... GK: Reina 84 GK: Doni 76 GK: Jones 70 GK: Gulasci 64 GK: Hansen 58 RB: Johnson 81 RB: Kelly 76 RB: Flanagan 70 RB: Mendy 59 CB: Carragher 80 CB: Agger 82 CB: Skrtel 79 CB: Kyrgiakos 77 CB: Ayala 74 CB: Wilson 72 CB: Wisdom 64 LB: Aurelio 75 LB: Insua 75 LB: Robinson 71 CDM: Lucas 80 CDM: Poulsen 73 CDM: Coady 67 RM: Maxi Rodriguez 78 RM: Henderson 78 RW: Kuyt 80 RW: Amoo 62 CM: Meireles 82 CM: Aquilani 81 CM: Adam 83 CM: Shelvey 75 CM: Spearing 71 CAM: Gerrard 84 CAM: Cole 77 CAM: Suso 66 LM: Downing 81 LW: Sterling 69 CF: Suarez 86 CF: Pacheco 74 ST: Carroll 82 ST: N'Gog 76 ST: Eccleston 69 ST: Morgan 67
GK: Reina 86 GK: Doni 75 GK: Jones 70 GK: Gulasci 66 GK: Hansen 58 RB: Johnson 81 (With 'Dribbler' speciality) RB: Kelly 79 RB: Flanagan 70 RB: Mendy 59 CB: Carragher 82 CB: Agger 83 CB: Skrtel 80 CB: Kyrgiakos 77 CB: Ayala 74 CB: Wilson 72 CB: Wisdom 64 LB: Aurelio 75 LB: Insua 75 LB: Robinson 71 CDM: Lucas 80 (Possibly 'tactician' or 'tackling' speciality) CDM: Poulsen 73 CDM: Coady 67 RM: Maxi Rodriguez 79 (Positioning - 81-84) RM: Henderson 78 RW: Kuyt 81 ('Engine' speciality) RW: Amoo 64 CM: Meireles 81 CM: Aquilani 81 ('Playmaker' speciality') CM: Adam 80 CM: Shelvey 75 CM: Spearing 76 CAM: Gerrard 85 (Wide range of specialities) CAM: Cole 76-77 CAM: Suso 68 LW: Downing 81 (Hopefully 'Crosser' speciality) LW: Sterling 66 CF: Suarez 84 ('Dribbler' speciality) I reckon he'll recieve between an 83-84) CF: Pacheco 74 ST: Carroll 80-81 ('Aerial threat' speciality) ST: N'Gog 76 ST: Eccleston 69 ST: Morgan 67 Possible signings LB: Enrique 81 (Will probably get 79-81) CB: Dann 78 (Will probably get 77-79) Copied the first post so a few might be the same
anyone know the release date? and can we save this thread id love for someone to be absolutely spot on when it comes out.
Probably because he isn't as good as those two... Yeah he's probably third best LB in the prem but over the past 5 years those two have been better than Baines. Baines should go up to be almost equal to those two though.
No doubt judas will be higher rated than suarez for some stupid reason. Rooney will yet again be a ridiculously unjustified 88 or something. I would rate suarez 86/87 downing 82 henderson 80 and Adam 82 won't be that good though we are always short changed by ea Sent from my Desire HD using Tapatalk
Over the past 5 years they've both been better, yeah, but Cole in particular is steadily going downhill and should be, at best, around the 80 mark with Baines. Evra maybe a point or two higher.
Firstly I'd just like to say the ratings vary depending on what the highest overall in the game is. in fifa 10 the ratings were generally quite abit higher than fifa 11. but if its similar to fifa 11 i think liverpools squad will be something along these lines GK: Reina 86 GK: Doni 79 GK: Jones 68 GK: Gulasci 65 GK: Hansen 61 RB: Johnson 80 RB: Kelly 78 RB: Flanagan 67 RB: Mendy 54 CB: Carragher 80 CB: Agger 81 CB: Skrtel 78 CB: Kyrgiakos 75 CB: Ayala 73 CB: Wilson 72 CB: Wisdom 67 LB: Aurelio 76 LB: Insua 76 LB: Robinson 68 CDM: Lucas 80 CDM: Poulsen 72 CDM: Coady 65 RM: Maxi Rodriguez 79 RM: Henderson 77 RW: Kuyt 80 (Hopefully he'll finally be a RW, not a ST) RW: Amoo 65 CM: Meireles 82 CM: Aquilani 82 CM: Adam 79 CM: Shelvey 72 CM: Spearing 75 CAM: Gerrard 84 CAM: Cole 77 CAM: Suso 64 LM: Downing 80 LW: Sterling 67 CF: Suarez 83-85 CF: Pacheco 75 ST: Carroll 80 (Hopefully over the 80 rating, won't be much higher unfortunately) ST: N'Gog 74 ST: Eccleston 67 ST: Morgan 64 Possible signings LB: Enrique 79 CB: Dann 79 Just my opinion on your squad.
Suarez 87? henderson 80 and adam 82? your being far to optimisic of them for next season to be honest. downing 82 i understand though. And no fifa doesnt short change you, last year in fifa 11 if you start a career with liverpool your predicted to finish 4th, liverpool finished 6th for example. stop kidding yourself mate
