Maybe because Alex is not afraid to stick his boot in to a tackle more often than most.
McShane's done one...
- Thread starter originallambrettaman
- Start date
-
Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
-
Maybe because Alex is not afraid to stick his boot in to a tackle more often than most.
He could certainly do a job for one of the newly promoted sides. I think he has been excellent when selected this season. He would have been well up on my retention list.
If we start the championship season with the defenders we currently have then losing Rosenior and McShane is irrelevant, we'll have the best defence in the league. Releasing those two becomes a bad decision if we sell start to sell some of those that are left.
Yet again another example of the mismanagement of the last couple of seasons, we have/had six centre backs yet a very thin central midfield, and now seemingly, based on the fact that all three are rumoured to want to leave, absolutely no forwards.
The complete imbalance of our squad is probably one of the main reasons that we now find ourselves in the Championship, and after last seasons spend of £42M I think the big question should be why. The loss of stalwarts such as Rosie and Macca simply add more fuel to the fire for me. As much as I like Steve Bruce it appears that he hasn't really helped himself, or us, with many of his bizarre decisions.
If Davies goes, and if a PL club offers for Chester and starts to woo him, then I think we may very well look back on the easy relinquishing of McShane ruefully.
Same if offers come in for Elmo and Rosie isn't there.
Let's hope our club knows what it's doing...
Same if offers come in for Elmo and Rosie isn't there.
Let's hope our club knows what it's doing...
All we actually know he did was tweet that he was training with the U21s. He nor Bruce never revealed the reason why, but he was treated poorly in being dropped after Burnley away with the 'big time charlies' comments.
Let's face it forget what luck we have not had or late goals or bad ref decisions we are down because quite a few of our players can't cut it in the top league.
We are bound to lose some and maybe now Bruce is realising you can't have sentiment with players as a manager and has decided to let people go and try and bring in better ,we do not know what finances he will have to bring in players or if he has some loans lined up and he needs to free up finances to pay them.
We are not managers if we knew better we would be at some club doing it,i have no problem with rosey or mcshane going it was inevitable we would lose some and just because they put in 100% so what they got paid to do that like all the team did and hopefully those who never will be gone as well it is to early to say what bruce is going to do yet.
We are bound to lose some and maybe now Bruce is realising you can't have sentiment with players as a manager and has decided to let people go and try and bring in better ,we do not know what finances he will have to bring in players or if he has some loans lined up and he needs to free up finances to pay them.
We are not managers if we knew better we would be at some club doing it,i have no problem with rosey or mcshane going it was inevitable we would lose some and just because they put in 100% so what they got paid to do that like all the team did and hopefully those who never will be gone as well it is to early to say what bruce is going to do yet.
Brucie feathers juniors nest for another two years - disgusting - and I thought Sepp Blatter was bad
We have got a lot of centre backs. Maguire was apparently outstanding for Wigan at that / this level.
True, same goes for McShane though and he doesn't have to go off after an hour every week.
I actually agree with keeping Bruce, said it weeks ago, not sure a 2 year deal was really warranted but still. Just don't get why you'd get rid of McShane if you're giving a new deal to the lesser player.
I'd have Rosenior as an upgrade on Danny Simpson to be fair.
The Wigan team that got relegated? I know a ST holder at the Latics - said he was 'Ok'. Certainly not 'Outstanding'.
I thought you signed Brady and Chester on loan under Nige but then signed them up permo under that short bloke (can't for the life of me think what his name is, not had my coffee. Even though his lad plays for us).
I agree. It is a shame that McShane is to be released but come on, this is football, the players know they are not here for ever when they sign for a club. Paul McShane has had seven good years at Hull City. The club has probably made him a millionaire.
Macca is a player who wears his heart on his sleeve and he always gives 100%, which is why he we have kept him on for seven years, but players move on for all sorts of reasons.
I thank Macca for his service to Hull City and wish him all the luck in the world with his next move.
He will be looked back on with legendary status, and we cannot say that about too many ex-City players.
I also think it is grossly unfair to be comparing his departure with Alex Bruce signing a new contract as though they are connected.
Alex Bruce also never lets us down and is as committed as Macca ever was.
And no-one on here knows the details or the figures behinds these contracts.
Erm, yes. Signing one centre back when you're already in the bottom 3 is hardly likely to save them. You talk as if they were well clear of the bottom 3 and then signed Maguire. It's not like Derby being top, signing Ince and then hardly winning another game.
That is what I worry, but maybe it is a sign that they a determined to keep Chester and Davies, unless of cause a large offer comes in for either.
On Elmo, I get the feeling he is very much an ally SB and SB of him, and with the owners being Egyptian I expect he will stay.