May may have said it was blown out of all proportions, but he also said he was too blind drunk to notice anything. A rather inconsistent witness.
Top Gear will never be like it was so I'm not going to carry on watching it.
I agree - and am still waiting for proof of what happened. How come May said it was "blown out of all proportion"? If he punched someone, he should go - I would do the same in a company disciplinary committee if it came to it. And fair play to the Beeb for ignoring commercial reasons. But did he? Or is it just because he's got too big for "them upstairs"? Top Gear won't continue and if Chris Evans (aka the Ginger Twat) takes over, I might even stop watching the BBC out of spite .............
There has been no official news about Clarkson yet, has there?
I'm not saying what Clarkson did was right, but surely him and the producer he allegedly punched could have settled this over a handshake and a pint and moved on. The BBC have just shot themselves in the foot and if they start charging for individual shows they can **** right off.
Just bought my ticket for Goodison. Yay!
I have never attempted to settle an argument physically (which should come as no surprise) but I have also never seen it happen between male co-workers either. Even heated arguments never went on for long either. Unless someone's idiocy threatened the safety of yourself or others, I can't even imagine why it would. Differences of opinion are surely best sorted by argument/discussion, because what does physical supremacy prove...doesn't make you right does it, just more violent or stronger.
I agree about trying to settle things between you rather than involve management, but remember Clarkson was on a final warning...he had previous. The BBC (once they became aware) has to support the injured party. From what we hear (gossip I know), a lot of people who work with Clarkson want him dealt with. If this is how he behaves, he must be hell to work with if you are the little guy. As they say, be careful who you tread on on the way up, because you will meet them on the way down.
Oh I completely agree Fran. I've never actually been in what one would term as "a fight" in my adult life, despite having boxed at a low level for some time. It's just utterly pointless and shows a lack of imagination! Saying that, there was one incident where I was working in recruitment (ugh!) where a co-worked in the pub was hassling a female friend. I asked him (very nicely) to leave it out and he grabbed my shirt and started ripping it - my instinctive reaction at that point was to hit him to stop him, and I did. Not something I'm proud of (well, maybe a little as he ran off crying, which under the circumstances was pretty funny). I found him shortly after and apologised for hitting him. He mumbled something back. That was it. I never stopped thinking he was an idiot, I suspect he never liked me much either, but we carried on working together. The idea of involving management or trying to get one another in any more trouble was anathema.
I've also seen a drummer hit/throw things/behave like a child....but then that's drummers for you....
Why could we not have sacked Osvaldo?
I have certainly had heated discussions at work, but never physical (although I did throw a pen across a board room table once, during a heated discussion).
I like Top Gear and I like Clarkson on it, so maybe I am unusual in that I can say I like it and him, but also think he is a buffoon and that the BBC have taken the moral ground, even if it is over an accumulation of controversy rather than the one incident. It is not necessarily about being holier than thou, but it is equally distasteful for someone to say, "oh it could have been sorted out over a beer," especially when that is from someone who is a fan (not you LTL)... if they weren't a fan, they would be agreeing with it. To me that approach smacks of double standards or a 'not in my back yard' view and....... I'm not a fan of that
I think they've done the right thing but it is not because I don't like the program or Clarkson. I do.
*makes mental note, to not fallout with LTL*
On Osvaldo, we could have done... probably, but I suspect that the commercial monster took a higher view than the moral saint.
It was an impulse buy. My thought process:in-laws visit at Easter plan backfire
![]()
It was an impulse buy. My thought process:
1. Am I doing anything over Easter? No.
2. Do I have the car available? Yes.
3. Are tickets reasonably priced? Yes
**** it I'm going.
I hear you FLT, and I think under the circumstances they've put themselves in a position of 'damned if they do, damned if they don't', but all things considered this was probably the only course of action. The part I struggle with is that there was no official complaint lodged, so I just think, having been managed and having managed people myself, there were far better ways of dealing with this internally.
The guy it got reported to (whose name escapes me) is widely known to have it in for Clarkson and sounds like a 'sort' himself to be perfectly honest. That's the part I don't really like in this whole episode.