Costel Pantilimon

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
PLT said:
Have to say after all the speculation about Schmeichel, Schwarzer, Mannone and Stockdale I'd be a bit disappointed if we got this McGregor guy. It's just cos I've never really heard of him until recently and he could be great I suppose but all four of the above keepers are definitely good keepers, some of them brilliant ones.
Click to expand...

He is the best of the bunch you mention. Followed by Schwarzer, who is a bit old.
 
originallambrettaman said:
I've been saying I wanted Schwarzer from day one, including regularly on your board, is your memory playing you up.
Click to expand...

I know you have.

But I didn't quote that part, did I?


You're claiming Alan McGreggor is still a better player than Schmeichel and thats simply not true.
 
I just want to hear some real ****ing news!
Where's the helicopter spotters, the hotel stalkers and the airport sniffer-outers?
I want, nay demand to read posts from unknown best mates with someone high at the club. Even youngsters getting lifts with directors will do!l
All I am getting is recycled newspaper pap. Come on lads you can all try harder!
 
Melu said:
I just want to hear some real ****ing news!
Where's the helicopter spotters, the hotel stalkers and the airport sniffer-outers?
I want, nay demand to read posts from unknown best mates with someone high at the club. Even youngsters getting lifts with directors will do!l
All I am getting is recycled newspaper pap. Come on lads you can all try harder!
Click to expand...

Surely Tickles will hear something from the snooker club.
 
Andy King's Crown Jewels said:
I know you have.

But I didn't quote that part, did I?


You're claiming Alan McGreggor is still a better player than Schmeichel and thats simply not true.
Click to expand...

Put simply, yes it is.

Schmeichel is a very good Championship goalkeeper. He's failed once at Premiership level, though now with a bit more experience he might make the grade. Looks like we won't find out until next season when he leaves you on a free.

I think McGreggor is better, and my opinion is just as valid as yours.
 
TygerTyger said:
Put simply, yes it is.

Schmeichel is a very good Championship goalkeeper. He's failed once at Premiership level, though now with a bit more experience he might make the grade. Looks like we won't find out until next season when he leaves you on a free.

I think McGreggor is better, and my opinion is just as valid as yours.
Click to expand...

You're opinion isn't as valid as mine when you say he failed at Premier League level.

What makes you think McGreggor is better?
 
TygerTyger said:
Seen them both play.

What success did Kasper have at Premiership level?
Click to expand...

The fact a lot of Man City fans wanted him to stay instead of Hart.


What success has McGreggor had at Premier League level?
 
Andy King's Crown Jewels said:
The fact a lot of Man City fans wanted him to stay instead of Hart.


What success has McGreggor had at Premier League level?
Click to expand...

So, none then.

5 years at Man City, 8 appearances, sold to a league 2 side. Hardly an unqualified success. 1 Denmark cap. I'm sure he has improved, but still has to be said he failed at premiership level 1st time around.

Allan McGregor is untried at our level. Neither good nor bad. Though of course he does have 29 Scotland caps (yes I know Scotland are ****e)..

I would have welcomed Schmeichel, and applaud him for wanting to make the step up from your level, but there is a limit to what you would pay for an untried player (McGregor) or once failed player (Schmeichel). At £1.8m I think McGregor is a better bet.

I appreciate that Kasper is your player currently, and therefore you have a loyalty and bias towards him. It's only right that you should feel that way, but for an objective view (I have no axe to grind with either and am therefore providing an unbiased view) I prefer McGregor.
 
True story here AKCJ - when Kaspar's dad was played in the first few seasons at Man Utd I know some fans who didn't rate him. Hart is obviously the better keeper out of him and Kaspar as who has a PL medal and is rated as £15 million plus by people who aren't just fans of the club. Hopefully we can find a future Hart as second choice keeper (unless Oxley - spelt it right, is him). Given the names being mentioned (the question still being apart from Kaspar, who else have we bid for) it is looking like Bruce is keeping his options open when it comes to who we sign.
 
mostynthecat said:
True story here AKCJ - when Kaspar's dad was played in the first few seasons at Man Utd I know some fans who didn't rate him. Hart is obviously the better keeper out of him and Kaspar as who has a PL medal and is rated as £15 million plus by people who aren't just fans of the club. Hopefully we can find a future Hart as second choice keeper (unless Oxley - spelt it right, is him). Given the names being mentioned (the question still being apart from Kaspar, who else have we bid for) it is looking like Bruce is keeping his options open when it comes to who we sign.
Click to expand...

I'm not saying Schmeichel is better than Hart now.

Just at the time Schmeichel was playing better and looked a fantastic prospect (which he still is)
 
TygerTyger said:
So, none then.

5 years at Man City, 8 appearances, sold to a league 2 side. Hardly an unqualified success. 1 Denmark cap. I'm sure he has improved, but still has to be said he failed at premiership level 1st time around.

Allan McGregor is untried at our level. Neither good nor bad. Though of course he does have 29 Scotland caps (yes I know Scotland are ****e)..

I would have welcomed Schmeichel, and applaud him for wanting to make the step up from your level, but there is a limit to what you would pay for an untried player (McGregor) or once failed player (Schmeichel). At £1.8m I think McGregor is a better bet.

I appreciate that Kasper is your player currently, and therefore you have a loyalty and bias towards him. It's only right that you should feel that way, but for an objective view (I have no axe to grind with either and am therefore providing an unbiased view) I prefer McGregor.
Click to expand...

You're paying 1.8m for McGreggor?!?!

****ing hell, I thought he was on a free and I still thought it'd be a **** deal.
 
Circa said:
Is schwarzer a pipe dream or was there a rumour I missed?
Click to expand...

He's at the end of his contract and Fulham have signed (or are about to at least) Maarten Stekelenburg.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back