Everyone of those players besides Shelvey would be in Spurs first 11..
Let's see:
Reina. On current form, Friedel > Reina. Supposedly Lloris is world class, but haven't seen enough of him to tell yet
Agger. Verts and Kaboul are better IMO. Agger is probably equal to Dawson. I would prefer Caulker to Agger, he's younger and one of our own.
Sterling. Doesn't he play left wing? Are you really suggesting he would replace Gareth Bale?
Allen. He would probably be on the bench, ready to replace Dembele/Sandro/Parker as needed.
Suarez. Spurs would never sign such a horrible, cheating, lying scumbag in the first place. But if we had him he'd probably be there or abouts.
I make that 1/5.

Joke board