As I've already said, Fryatt had loads of 1-on-1s earlier in the season and missed nearly all of them. I don't hate the guy, I think he's really, really good at carving out chances from nothing, the way he just turns his man and is suddenly through on goal is incredible at times but he's missed way, way too many chances this season from good positions. If you look back to the Donny game for example we drew 0-0 and the two best chances fell to Fryatt; he dragged one wide after taking 20 or 30 touches and scuffed the second one from almost on the line in the second half. Against Bristol City it didn't matter because we won 3-0 but he missed 4 1-on-1 chances through on goal before eventually scoring the 5th. People (including me) were happy for him because it was his first goal in about 3 months, but it's easy to forget all those missed chances. Against Blackpool on the opening day and West Ham at home he should have won us the game with simple chances (Simpson and Barmby also missed easy ones against Blackpool). They are just the games off the top of my head that I vividly remember him missing easy chances in but there were plenty of others particularly in the first half of the season. He may be our top scorer but he's played almost every game this season as the spearhead of our attack, he's been in a free-flowing team that creates loads of chances (again that applies more to the first half of the season) and yet he didn't score between mid-November and mid-February except for one penalty. He wasn't out of the team or injured in that time he was playing every single game and missing a hell of a lot of chances. If someone like McLean missed anywhere near that many chances he'd be hung, drawn and quartered in Victoria Square.
I think Nick's comment above sums it up. Anyone telling me Fryatt is 'the best finisher we've had for years' all I'd suggest is that you just go back and watch some highlights from ouyr games this season. Even his goals have generally been very scrappy, I can't think of one example of a goal where he's caught the ball well or placed it particularly accurately in the corner, it's always just a scuff with Fryatt (or sometimes no shot at all), sometimes it goes in but far too often it's more like a backpass. Deano, Campbell and JVoH were much better in front of goal than Fryatt, McLean has actually scored much better hit goals (Forest and Coventry away), even Adebola in pre-season caught one better than I've seen Fryatt hit in a year and a half.