WAR! What is it good for?

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
No US president will abondon Israel because of the influence of the Jewish lobby and these days the religious right . Most that will happen would be a bit of rhetoric and possibly some pressure to actually decide genocide isn't a good look .

It's probably more due to the fact that Israel is by a country mile America's most important ally in the most complex region on the planet, than the influence of the "Jewish lobby" (a dangerous generalisation btw, huge numbers of American Jews are pretty anti-Israel, while the overwhelming majority of American Jews have always voted Democrat).

Of far greater influence is the Evangelical lobby, which numbers upwards of 90 million citizens who believe that the second coming can't happen until all Jews are settled in the land of Israel.
 
SKY News crew stuck with thousands of people trying to flee south Lebanon, seven hours just to travel 15km. Israeli strikes killed 492 people and a field commander, Israel says it has taken out tens of thousands of rockets in strikes, US to send a small number of additional troops to the Middle East. No confirmation of another senior commander being killed.
 
SKY News crew stuck with thousands of people trying to flee south Lebanon, seven hours just to travel 15km. Israeli strikes killed 492 people and a field commander, Israel says it has taken out tens of thousands of rockets in strikes, US to send a small number of additional troops to the Middle East. No confirmation of another senior commander being killed.
35 of which were children, no number given for women yet but where children are women are usually close.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BobbyD and brb
35 of which were children, no number given for women yet but where children are women are usually close.

I just don't get why Palestinian people (or Lebanese) are allowing terrorists to live within their homes, surely if anything was learned by now after months of war is that Israel will strike anything that harbours them. Would you allow a terrorist to hide in your home and put your kids at risk, at what point do the civilians stand up for themselves and drive those that hide behind them out?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Diego
I just don't get why Palestinian people (or Lebanese) are allowing terrorists to live within their homes, surely if anything was learned by now after months of war is that Israel will strike anything that harbours them. Would you allow a terrorist to hide in your home and put your kids at risk, at what point do the civilians stand up for themsleves and drive those that hide behind them out?
People in Belfast harboured IRA men, can you imagine the **** storm if we had bombed the **** out of Belfast?
Civilised countries just don't do that ****.
 
People in Belfast harboured IRA men, can you imagine the **** storm if we had bombed the **** out of Belfast?
Civilised countries just don't do that ****.

But British troops did open fire on and kill civilians, unless I'm remembering my history wrong?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Diego
I just don't get why Palestinian people (or Lebanese) are allowing terrorists to live within their homes, surely if anything was learned by now after months of war is that Israel will strike anything that harbours them. Would you allow a terrorist to hide in your home and put your kids at risk, at what point do the civilians stand up for themsleves and drive those that hide behind them out?

The civilians are just cannon fodder and acceptable casualties in this conflict, Hamas do not care how many of their people die just so long as they kill some jews

If the Hamas fighters were told they could not stay they would probably just shoot the families themselves and then blame it on the jews
 
  • Like
Reactions: brb
No, it happened and squaddies were punished for it.

Were they, I thought they were struggling to bring justice for those that required it in Ireland, either way they still killed civilians. Plus I'm sure the British Government or it's agencies arranged hits as well. The British were certainly no innocent in some of the events that happened. Plus it was a land we had forced our way onto without the agreement of half of the Irish people, ie we were not welcome.
 
The civilians are just cannon fodder and acceptable casualties in this conflict, Hamas do not care how many of their people die just so long as they kill some jews

If the Hamas fighters were told they could not stay they would probably just shoot the families themselves and then blame it on the jews

and that's what the Palestinian people and it;s supporters need to say then, there are two sides to this war mate, it;s not all Israels fault as some like to portray, not getting at anyone in particular.
 
Were they, I thought they were struggling to bring justice for those that required it in Ireland, either way they still killed civilians. Plus I'm sure the British Government or it's agencies arranged hits as well. The British were certainly no innocent in some of the events that happened. Plus it was a lad we had forced our way onto without the agreement of half of the Irish people, ie we were not welcome.
I agree with much of that but will repeat my original question, what would have been the reaction if we had just bombed the **** out of Belfast with no regard to civillian life?
 
  • Like
Reactions: brb
I agree with much of that but will repeat my original question, what would have been the reaction if we had just bombed the **** out of Belfast with no regard to civillian life?

I don't think you can compare the two, two completely different regions where the logistics between peace and fighting are completely different as a land battle.
 
I've never served so I can't say but to my naive eyes I see the logistics of the two areas completely different, that the British and Israeli troops would have to cope with. Happy to accept being wrong, but the middle east just seems a fire pit to me occupied by raving lunatics. Not suggesting Ireland didn;t have it's lunatics obviously.
 
I don't think you can compare the two, two completely different regions where the logistics between peace and fighting are completely different as a land battle.
Are you telling me that the Israili army were/are incapable of going into Gaza and sealing the tunnels then rooting out the hamas fighters left in the city?
This is/was a sealed city which is very hard to escape from when locked down so in effect the hamas fighters were locked in
 
Are you telling me that the Israili army were/are incapable of going into Gaza and sealing the tunnels then rooting out the hamas fighters left in the city?
This is/was a sealed city which is very hard to escape from when locked down so in effect the hamas fighters were locked in

I'm sure if the Israeli troops could have done it, they would have, maybe you should lend them your expertise. <whistle>