The General Football Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Your stretching and jumping from one context to another too flippantly. And why are you using the race/gay card? Your Sunday League reffing is slightly different from a professional game in the Turkish Superlig.

I totally agree with you about abuse from players and coaches btw, in all contexts. Should be totally outlawed and punished accordingly. I also agree that at a non-professional level, abuse by fans should be treated in the same way.

Your original response however seemed to imply that any abuse from the fans shouldn't be tolerated either. While I tend to agree with the sentiment, it just isn't realistic to expect a crowd of thousands of passionate fans to behave in a totally respectful way. Again, a few angry chants is a world away from a fan actually running on the pitch and violently attacking a ref. But if we outlaw antagonistic chants towards referees, then we have to do the same about those towards players, and eventually what? Towards opposition fans? Okay, well bye bye atmosphere then.

And then Tom wouldn't be able to shout at Nathan Jones telling him his football is **** <whistle>

Not necessarily related to this conversation but I honestly believe we're only about 15-20 years from some clubs trying to ban swearing in grounds.
 
Your stretching and jumping from one context to another too flippantly. And why are you using the race/gay card? Your Sunday League reffing is slightly different from a professional game in the Turkish Superlig.

I totally agree with you about abuse from players and coaches btw, in all contexts. Should be totally outlawed and punished accordingly. I also agree that at a non-professional level, abuse by fans should be treated in the same way.

Your original response however seemed to imply that any abuse from fans shouldn't be tolerated either. While I tend to agree with the sentiment, it just isn't realistic to expect a crowd of thousands of passionate fans to behave in a totally respectful way. Again, a few angry chants is a world away from a fan actually running on the pitch and violently attacking a ref. But if we outlaw antagonistic chants towards referees, then we have to do the same about those towards players, and eventually what? Towards opposition fans? Okay, well bye bye atmosphere then.
Maybe I wasn't being clear enough. I wasn't talking about the generic chants from the stands. I was more thinking of incidents like what happened to Anthony Taylor after the EL final last year. Mourinho went off on one, confronted him in the car park after the game. The Roma fans saw that then harassed him and his family at the airport. That's what I'm talking about by verbal abuse. The fans saw Mourinho do it so it gave them the confidence to confront him in the airport. That's why I was referring to racist language.
 
Maybe I wasn't being clear enough. I wasn't talking about the generic chants from the stands. I was more thinking of incidents like what happened to Anthony Taylor after the EL final last year. Mourinho went off on one, confronted him in the car park after the game. The Roma fans saw that then harassed him and his family at the airport. That's what I'm talking about by verbal abuse. The fans saw Mourinho do it so it gave them the confidence to confront him in the airport. That's why I was referring to racist language.

Ah okay, fair enough. Yep totally agree.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tomw24
The professional clubs are the ones that SHOULD be setting the right examples for everyone to follow, but they do the opposite.
I’ve told this story before as an example of the difference between football and rugby union fans.
I was watching a game at Syston (near Leicester and the home of Pukka Pies) refereed by a lad who was either late teens or early twenties. The club has good support, including several ex-players, standing on the sidelines. At one point the referee made a decision that one of the ex-players (50+ years old) disagreed with and he let the ref know by saying “I think you got that decision wrong, sir”.
The respect for the referee is amazing, even at ground roots level, and long may it continue.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Schrodinger's Cat
I would be a fan of introducing a rule, like rugby, where protestations result in a free kick being moved forwards 10 yards, or as close to it if it's less than 10 yards outside the box originally. It could act as a warning before the yellow card comes out. It would be a good deterrent for surrounding the referee for example.
 
I would be a fan of introducing a rule, like rugby, where protestations result in a free kick being moved forwards 10 yards, or as close to it if it's less than 10 yards outside the box originally. It could act as a warning before the yellow card comes out. It would be a good deterrent for surrounding the referee for example.
I’ve been saying this for years. Why not turn a free kick outside the box into a penalty if there’s dissent though? Players would soon learn to behave.
 
I’ve been saying this for years. Why not turn a free kick outside the box into a penalty if there’s dissent though? Players would soon learn to behave.
That would cause more trouble than it's worth I think. Players and coaches would argue how a penalty could be awarded for an offence outside the box.
 
And then Tom wouldn't be able to shout at Nathan Jones telling him his football is **** <whistle>

Not necessarily related to this conversation but I honestly believe we're only about 15-20 years from some clubs trying to ban swearing in grounds.
Good. I swear like a trooper at home, or with pals. But in a public space, including at the football, I`m conscious that there are children around, and people who I don`t know who might find it offensive, so I refrain. I can still shout or sing without swearing.
 
I would be a fan of introducing a rule, like rugby, where protestations result in a free kick being moved forwards 10 yards, or as close to it if it's less than 10 yards outside the box originally. It could act as a warning before the yellow card comes out. It would be a good deterrent for surrounding the referee for example.
That's what I posted earlier and also mentioned the rule being used in Glasgow evening leagues played on red blaes pitches around 1987/88. I was working on assignment in an engineering office on George Street, good times back in the day.
 
Umut Meler, the referee who was assaulted, has unsurprisingly quit. He was a FIFA referee, on UEFA's elite list so this is going to have repercussions way beyond Turkey. I think a referee strike is not far away. It almost happened in England when Clattenburg was falsely accused of racial abusing Jon Obi Mikel. I think a strike may well be necessary. Let's see what happens when fans miss out on going to games at the weekend and broadcasters miss out on TV revenue and pundits miss out on getting paid.
 
Umut Meler, the referee who was assaulted, has unsurprisingly quit. He was a FIFA referee, on UEFA's elite list so this is going to have repercussions way beyond Turkey. I think a referee strike is not far away. It almost happened in England when Clattenburg was falsely accused of racial abusing Jon Obi Mikel. I think a strike may well be necessary. Let's see what happens when fans miss out on going to games at the weekend and broadcasters miss out on TV revenue and pundits miss out on getting paid.
Hope the ref sues the attacker for all his money. Suppose he was lucky it wasn’t a knife or gun. Greek and Turkish football owners are well out of control.
 
I would be a fan of introducing a rule, like rugby, where protestations result in a free kick being moved forwards 10 yards, or as close to it if it's less than 10 yards outside the box originally. It could act as a warning before the yellow card comes out. It would be a good deterrent for surrounding the referee for example.
I thought they tried this once, but it never made it to a second season ??