VAR got the disallowing of the Derby goal completely correct AS THE RULES CURRENTLY STAND - so Libby is wrong - it is the rule that it at fault
Match Day Thread General matchday thread.
- Thread starter Libby
- Start date
-
Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
-
VAR got the disallowing of the Derby goal completely correct AS THE RULES CURRENTLY STAND - so Libby is wrong - it is the rule that it at fault
But it doesn't always end up with the right decision, a lot of decisions are subjective so it still won't stop controversy.
The other things that delay play are in the refs control to stop, you think they won't surround refs drawing a tv screen?
Not all change is good
And fans chanting V-A-R ffs
But it doesn't always end up with the right decision, a lot of decisions are subjective so it still won't stop controversy.
The other things that delay play are in the refs control to stop, you think they won't surround refs drawing a tv screen?
Not all change is good
Agreed - but one that will undeniably improve the percentage of correct decisions under the rules has to be a positive
VAR got the disallowing of the Derby goal completely correct AS THE RULES CURRENTLY STAND - so Libby is wrong - it is the rule that it at fault
And there are examples where VAR has still got it wrong.
... but way less than human error getting them wrong ... which is what VAR is intended to do
Wrong - it will definitely help the **** officials to get it right ... but it is a given that we need better officials in any case
Why will it?
Were you in a coma during the World Cup?
... but way less than human error getting them wrong ... which is what VAR is intended to do
At what cost though?
Slowing the game down, killing the atmosphere/emotion and still doesn't kill controversy.
Nah you're right it's a belter
... but way less than human error getting them wrong ... which is what VAR is intended to do
I guess this is where I differ from most. I don't mind seeing a few mistakes as long as it keeps the flow of the game going.
The thing that annoys me about VAR is that sooner or later, being good at charades will get you into a PL side.
You must log in or register to see images
****ing annoys me already seeing players drawing a TV screen. If they are going to introduce VAR then they should introduce a rule giving a yellow card for any **** who does that.
Nope ... neither was I during previous ones when Lampard's shot was a foot over the line or when Maradona cheated ... VAR would have put both of them right ...
... as I said ... it will take time to bed in ... but in a couple of years time it will just be a normal part of the game ...
Nope ... neither was I during previous ones when Lampard's shot was a foot over the line or when Maradona cheated ... VAR would have put both of them right ...
... as I said ... it will take time to bed in ... but in a couple of years time it will just be a normal part of the game ...
Goal line technology would have sorted the first.
The only people who will need to turn up for a game are the players and the guy implementing the decisions as directed by the VAR officials.At what cost though?
Slowing the game down, killing the atmosphere/emotion and still doesn't kill controversy.
Nah you're right it's a belter
Should make a rule that only the captain can ask the ref for VAR (bit like in Rugby) ...
I would also like to see a mandatory yellow card for any **** waving an imaginary yellow card
... with no delays? ...
.. but the second?
... plus it will also sort this type of ****er out
You must log in or register to see media
Nope ... neither was I during previous ones when Lampard's shot was a foot over the line or when Maradona cheated ... VAR would have put both of them right ...
... as I said ... it will take time to bed in ... but in a couple of years time it will just be a normal part of the game ...
But it doesn't get everything correct as I've amply demonstrated.
So why take all the bad that comes with it for the sake of getting 'some' decisions right?
A normal part of a game that's been ruined for the sake if tourists
Should make a rule that only the captain can ask the ref for VAR (bit like in Rugby) ...
I would also like to see a mandatory yellow card for any **** waving an imaginary yellow card
But will the ref do it?
The ref already has the power to book players who surround him but doesn't, which is what makes the 'but there are already delays' claims nonsenical.
Focus on improving official standards and the standard of decision making will improve, give **** officials technology and they'll still make poor decisions because guess what? They're **** officials.
... but that's a misconception - for really controversial incidents the delays will be just as long whilst the handbags are removed and the make-up is reapplied ...
... perhaps you have never really felt cheated whilst watching Arsenal?
... I've got 2 that come to mind ... David Speedie winning the penalty that enabled Blackburn to beat us in the play-off final at Wembley and Erlund Johnson for Chesea that put us out 0f the FA Cup a (another penalty)
Define "amply" - it gets more correct than it gets wrong - and makes less mistakes than humans - therefore overall improves the percentage of correct decisions - no argument ...