Allan Mcgregor

Based on what.
He's played 80 times over the last 8 seasons. Hardly a number 1 keeper.
Good for us in the lower leagues, cracks were showing in the pl and dropped for the journeyman Matt duke.

 

Hilarious that day. Us chanting 'Theo give us a wave' and him just standing hands on hips, looking our way with a massive smile.

He didn't wave, but then you can't really when you're in goal for the opposition and leaking goals

 

Based on his performances for us Not now, talking at their peaks . Same as I wouldn't take present day waggy over Hernandez , tho I probably would take him over Keane

 

I'd take my granny over Keane and she's been gone 20 years.

 

Slim margins fella

 

If Gerrard gets the Rangers there can see Wilson joining him on loan.

 

You're not far off Duffen's. Maybe Mannone for McGregor swap.

What category does Gulasci fit into?

 

None.who he?

 

Gary Sprake did that at Anfield

 

We got him on loan from liverpool a few years ago.

Also noticed you didn't have our highest ever goal scoring goalkeeper anywhere in the lists.

 

If Greggs is off to Rangers in the summer, looks like he's going to be kept busy ........

 

McGregor is steady but seems to struggle getting down to low shots at times and can flap at set pieces. Not saying he is a crap keeper because that's not the case but he ain't in the same league as some of the names mentioned above. Marshall is a complete mystery to me and frustrates many fans. His arrival from Cardiff was heralded by many but once his confidence sank the mistakes soon followed and he lost his place.

Suppose your only going to get what you pay for eh.

 

Fettis? Missed him when I gave City the elbow. I'll miss whoever minds the sticks in 18/19

 

As Waggy is now in his 70s Abel might just shade it.

 

it's hard to say who's the absolute best. From my time watching City

1,2,3 Myhill/McGregor/Norman - refuse to choose!
4. Mannone (shortish time with us)
5. The Jak (from zero to hero)

 

For me McGregor is No 1. Others were good but not in the top flight as long as him as our first choice.

All the names mentioned have faults, including McGregor and it’s a tough call.

 

On the one hand, McGregor is a good keeper of international class who has had a terrific season.

On the other hand, he didn’t get anywhere near the first team when City were last in the Premier League and was farmed our to the Championship.

 

was that one of the reasons we got relegated?

 

Farmed out? Think it was more to do with him coming back from serious injury and needing games.

Would you rather have McGregor or Flapupovic?