Zonal marking

That's why Evandro is marking Benteke, to stop him having a run on the defender.

Problem was, they put someone to block off Evandro, (who was there to stop Benteke's run), leaving Benteke a free stroll onto the ball- it was obvious we needed another blocker in there. Shambles
 
But we weren't man marking. We were using the worst defensive strategy I have ever seen. It doesn't work. Full stop.

Using Evandro on his own to try and block off 3 runners today- one of theirs simply blocked Evandro, allowing Tomkins and Benteke a free run in every time....joke strategy. Zonal marking might work, at least if you gave yourself a chance. Should have had N'Diaye blocking off- let them and try and get round him!
 
But I think the point is someone running and jumping would go higher than someone with a standing jump, which presumably is why you're not allowed to for that test?

I don't want to bore everyone (was going to pick you up on the jump post before) but it's transference of horizontal to vertical momentum - from a standing start you have less kinetic energy to transfer into the jump.
 
Using Evandro on his own to try and block off 3 runners today- one of theirs simply blocked Evandro, allowing Tomkins and Benteke a free run in every time....joke strategy. Zonal marking might work, at least if you gave yourself a chance. Should have had N'Diaye blocking off- let them and try and get round him!
You're supposed to use smaller players to block and taller players to mark zones. We needed more than Evandro doing it as they overloaded each time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hovetiger
I think you need a full preseason to get players playing a completely different way than they are used to.
 
Somebody put the stats up then

Saying zonal marking never works is clearly not true , unless people are saying it doesn't work in this country
 
Considering we shipped far more goals before Marco arrived, it really doesn't.

We've been **** on set-pieces, whatever system we've played.

We've also changed our centre halves. So the first half of the season is probably more down to personnel. The second half of the season and our piss poor attempts at defending set pieces has almost entirely been down to zonal marking.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Edelman
We've also changed our centre halves. So the first half of the season is probably more down to personnel. The second half of the season and our piss poor attempts at defending set pieces has almost entirely been down to zonal marking.
Seems that way to me.
 
We've also changed our centre halves. So the first half of the season is probably more down to personnel. The second half of the season and our piss poor attempts at defending set pieces has almost entirely been down to zonal marking.

That's somewhat overstating it, we added Ranocchia for the past fifteen games, it was hardly a radical overhaul of our defence.

The reality is that we shipped far more goals under Phelan than we have under Marco.

I'm not a fan of zonal marking, but the reality is we've been equally **** under both systems.
 
I not a lover of zonal marking but the fact is the right ball whipped in to a well timed run by Benteke usually has one end result.

I don't think if Harry, Daws or Nokia had been man to man with him they'd have stopped him from scoring.

He's beast in the air, on a par with Carroll as the best in the PL and maybe Europe.

IMO.
 
That's somewhat overstating it, we added Ranocchia for the past fifteen games, it was hardly a radical overhaul of our defence.

The reality is that we shipped far more goals under Phelan than we have under Marco.

I'm not a fan of zonal marking, but the reality is we've been equally **** under both systems.

I haven't checked but I don't think Maguire featured regularly in the early days.