Is it now time to de-activate the summer window thread. There are now links to our possible January transfer business, including the Ukranian youngster from Chelsea and the Ghanian CD from Scandinavia
Winter transfer window
- Thread starter mick65
- Start date
-
Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
-
Maybes the thread title could be changed to just 'Transfer thread'.
No . . . . we should separate them, so this is the new (winter) one 
Iirc someone posted on Saturday that Swansea had 5 loan players in their team and we had none.
Whatever business we do in January I'd prefer permanent signings as I'm not 100% happy playing other club's youngsters despite how successful Amad was.
Whatever business we do in January I'd prefer permanent signings as I'm not 100% happy playing other club's youngsters despite how successful Amad was.
Winter window is here let the fun begin lol 
5 is too many for me because you become reliant but we should look to try and get 1-2 decent bodies through the door on loan imo.
Of course developing our own players is the most important thing but realistically we’re not going to get a player of Amad’s quality unless it’s on loan and that could be what gets us over the line and promoted.
I don't mind loan signings, but they must be good enough to start and make a big difference like Amad did last season.
Our transfer windows have been interesting and generally successful with very little info leaking out. I think most people appreciate that.
And despite us bringing numerous young lads, many foreign, to the NE they've generally been well behaved and represented the club well.
I only mention that as I think it shows we don't seem to take fliers like we used to. In fact, looking back, the worst problems we've had imo were with British players ... Johnson, Diamond, Rodwell, Grigg, etc.
Our vetting process seems to be working, fingers crossed for the this window.
And despite us bringing numerous young lads, many foreign, to the NE they've generally been well behaved and represented the club well.
I only mention that as I think it shows we don't seem to take fliers like we used to. In fact, looking back, the worst problems we've had imo were with British players ... Johnson, Diamond, Rodwell, Grigg, etc.
Our vetting process seems to be working, fingers crossed for the this window.
Last edited:
Based on current form/fitness:
OUT
Hemir (Loan - Someone like Derby or Oxford on the understanding he'll get guaranteed game time)
Triantis (Loan)
Matete (Loan - not totally sold on this, but struggle to see him getting regular game time and he's unproven at this level)
Burstow (Terminate Loan - looks a good kid, but it's the wrong player at the wrong time)
Bennette (Loan)
Anderson (Just give him to Shrewsbury. Bonkers signing in the 1st place)
IN
Striker (with some experience)
CDM (to replace or compliment Evans)
Left Winger
OUT
Hemir (Loan - Someone like Derby or Oxford on the understanding he'll get guaranteed game time)
Triantis (Loan)
Matete (Loan - not totally sold on this, but struggle to see him getting regular game time and he's unproven at this level)
Burstow (Terminate Loan - looks a good kid, but it's the wrong player at the wrong time)
Bennette (Loan)
Anderson (Just give him to Shrewsbury. Bonkers signing in the 1st place)
IN
Striker (with some experience)
CDM (to replace or compliment Evans)
Left Winger
Patterson
Bishop
Hume Ballard O'Nien Cirkin
Pembele Seelt Alese Huggins
Ekwah Neil
Evans New CDM
Roberts Jobe Clarke
Ba Pritchard New LW
Dack Rigg Aouchice
Rusyn
Mayenda
New CF
Bishop
Hume Ballard O'Nien Cirkin
Pembele Seelt Alese Huggins
Ekwah Neil
Evans New CDM
Roberts Jobe Clarke
Ba Pritchard New LW
Dack Rigg Aouchice
Rusyn
Mayenda
New CF
Last edited:
The only thing guaranteed in the window is a meltdown on social media.
Always thought it unlikely Man Utd would loan him out in the Championship again. A PL loan makes far more sense
You're dead right mate, some people will be preparing their attacks on the club as we speak.
We were in for a winger late in the summer so expect to see one come in, cdm and I’d like an established striker but they come at a premium especially in Jan so can’t see that happening, main thing is keeping our star players until the summer then we can reinvest when one or two inevitably move on and this model can go up a notch or two! Exciting few windows coming up
Pitchforks getting sharpened
If we fail to sign a player, for a specific position, some will say that's always the fault of the club.
I'd say failing to try would be the fault of the club.
The reality may be that the club targeted three suitable players for that position ... one decides the NE just isn't for them, the next wants too much money, the third fails a medical or has other issues not known to the public.
So, what do people want. Should we sign someone we didn't think was right at first, break our wage structure and set a dangerous precedent or jump at someone without having done proper background checks on, etc.
Some players just don't want to play for Sunderland, that's a fact. It's all very well raging that we didn't sign Broadhead or Simms or whoever but we can't make people come. If they're the standard of player we need they'll obviously have other others from other clubs ... sadly, if a wife says 'no' that's usually the end of the idea, whether it's the supporters or the players
Rollheiser, 26 starts 6 goals 3 assists
Aravena, or something like that I believe. He said he didn't want to move in the summer, wasn't there an issue of joint ownership as well?