Transfer Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Half decent, yeah I'll take that <ok>

Behave KO, i meant decent half a season <laugh>
He is on par with Aguero (who has missed quite a few games), and a whole two goals above the legendary Charlie Austin (of the swash buckling QPR). All i am saying is he has not exactly torn the league apart yet and still has a way to go <ok>
 
I don't know. How do you know we don't have a chance? Answers is that you don't.

Ultimately he probably won't leave Barca but if he choose to, you'd probably say there are only 5-6 realistic destinations and we'd be in there somewhere. City and PSG clearly don't give a **** about FFP though so could well be one of those (though what a waste Messi in the French league would be!!)
 
I dont reckon he could take the rigours of premiership football. A good example of this is the sick note you bought from Monaco who didn't cut the ice in France. Messi is a master in the less physical La Liga where they love to play tippy-tap football and no real tackles. Exceptions of this phenomena are Aguero and Costa who have proved they can handle the rough and tumble of English football.


Messi has gotten the crap kicked out of him nonetheless in Spain.

Never stopped maradona, he got kicked up and down the pitch in most games.

So, Messi can hack the CL and La Liga, and in fact is record goal scorer in both, but he wouldn't hack the physicality of the PL? <laugh>

besides I think you'll find Messi is a lot stronger than you realise plus he has a low centre of gravity, you'd do well to even get shoulder to shoulder with him so most resort to kicking him.

I think he'd do just fine in the PL.

Sicknote has never been the same since returning from that injury. He's not half the player he was then

Besides La Liga is not that weak, it's just that the top 2 sides are so much more wealthier than the rest, look at the EL winners only 3 English winners since 1984.
Goes to show that English sides outside of the top few teams are not so great compared to European counterparts. Even though there is plenty more money in the PL, that says tehnique > physicality in general.
 
Last edited:
Messi has gotten the crap kicked out of him nonetheless in Spain.

Never stopped maradona, he got kicked up and down the pitch in most games.

So, Messi can hack the CL and La Liga, and in fact is record goal scorer in both, but he wouldn't hack the physicality of the PL? <laugh>

besides I think you'll find Messi is a lot stronger than you realise plus he has a low centre of gravity, you'd do well to even get shoulder to shoulder with him so most resort to kicking him.

I think he'd do just fine in the PL.

Sicknote has never been the same since returning from that injury. He's not half the player he was then

Besides La Liga is not that weak, it's just that the top 2 sides are so much more wealthier than the rest, look at the EL winners only 3 English winners since 1984.
Goes to show that English sides outside of the top few teams are not so great compared to European counterparts. Even though there is plenty more money in the PL, that says tehnique > physicality in general.

They didn't do it properly then, when I was playing they didn't get back up and if they did they rarely came back for seconds. :)
 
The Express reckons our bid for Cuadrado has been accepted (£23m), which is odd since his manager came out only yesterday saying they weren't gonna sell, and £23m is £2m under his buy out clause, yet the Express says we are now agreeing terms? odd....
 
The Express reckons our bid for Cuadrado has been accepted (£23m), which is odd since his manager came out only yesterday saying they weren't gonna sell, and £23m is £2m under his buy out clause, yet the Express says we are now agreeing terms? odd....

I find the signing a little odd anyway. We're quite well covered in wide areas and it's quite a lot of money for someone who is probably going to need adjustment time as well. Only reasoning I can see is if someone is waiting in the wings to take Salah or Schurrle and Jose thinks this move strengthens the squad.
 
Lot of rumours about possible players to join us in the summer -

From the Continent
Koke (44m) - Should be great addition. 28M would be good. But don't think will be cheap.
Doug Costa (20m) - Should be good addition
Pogba (70m) - We can break the bank
Hummels (25m +) - should be great addition

From PL
Victor or Morgan of Saints (20m)
Ward-Prowse needs to improve his finishing. Would be good additon


And 2 Ex-Saints
Theo - I would go ~6M + Cech, But Willian is pretty similar to him.
Bale (75m release clause??) - not sure about this..
 
Lot of rumours about possible players to join us in the summer -

From the Continent
Koke (44m) - Should be great addition. 28M would be good. But don't think will be cheap.
Doug Costa (20m) - Should be good addition
Pogba (70m) - We can break the bank
Hummels (25m +) - should be great addition

From PL
Victor or Morgan of Saints (20m)
Ward-Prowse needs to improve his finishing. Would be good additon


And 2 Ex-Saints
Theo - I would go ~6M + Cech, But Willian is pretty similar to him.
Bale (75m release clause??) - not sure about this..
Do you really think Walcott and Willian are similar players? Like chalk and cheese to me.
 
When Hummels leaves it will be for United

Pogba 70m Has the Di Maria lesson not beeen learned. Let him come to the PL and do it and then if he does call it 70m. 45m max the guy is worth, Italy's also ran teams would be relegated from the championship let alone the PL.
 
Do you really think Walcott and Willian are similar players? Like chalk and cheese to me.
I am not biased, but you cannot call Theo Chalk..
Both Ws have little composure. Willian was never played through the middle for us or in an advanced position, unlike Theo.
Have you seen the defensive discipline of Willian?
 
I am not biased, but you cannot call Theo Chalk..
Both Ws have little composure. Willian was never played through the middle for us or in an advanced position, unlike Theo.
Have you seen the defensive discipline of Willian?
Yes, but not from Walcott. I'm not saying one is better, just that they play different games. Walcott is about running off the shoulder of the last defender and scoring, Willian is a worker who gets back and fills in spaces. Has ability going forward, but that's not what I see very often.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Blueman
Lot of rumours about possible players to join us in the summer -

From the Continent
Koke (44m) - Should be great addition. 28M would be good. But don't think will be cheap.
Doug Costa (20m) - Should be good addition
Pogba (70m) - We can break the bank
Hummels (25m +) - should be great addition

From PL
Victor or Morgan of Saints (20m)
Ward-Prowse needs to improve his finishing. Would be good additon


And 2 Ex-Saints
Theo - I would go ~6M + Cech, But Willian is pretty similar to him.
Bale (75m release clause??) - not sure about this..

The Bale 75 million release clause has to be the most ridiculously bad piece of transfer rumour journalism I've seen in a while.

Why would Madrid spend 86 million on Bale and set his release at 75 million? Spurs should have just taken him straight back and pocketed a tidy 11 mill profit!!

Where do these 'reporters' get this nonsense from??

Pogba at anywhere near 70 m is bloody ridiculous too. The guy looks a talent but has done nothing yet of any real note.

Some promising names in there but I expect 95% of it is bollox.
 
The Bale 75 million release clause has to be the most ridiculously bad piece of transfer rumour journalism I've seen in a while.
Why would Madrid spend 86 million on Bale and set his release at 75 million? Spurs should have just taken him straight back and pocketed a tidy 11 mill profit!!
Where do these 'reporters' get this nonsense from??
Pogba at anywhere near 70 m is bloody ridiculous too. The guy looks a talent but has done nothing yet of any real note.
Some promising names in there but I expect 95% of it is bollox.
Top of the heap is Varane leaving Real for less than 30m <doh>

But I would be thrilled to get any of these players for reasonable price.
 
Yes, but not from Walcott. I'm not saying one is better, just that they play different games. Walcott is about running off the shoulder of the last defender and scoring, Willian is a worker who gets back and fills in spaces. Has ability going forward, but that's not what I see very often.
Partially agree. They are different players because of attitude.
Walcott is no Filipo or Goal post, to warrant the name 'off shoulder player'.

Both their starting positions are same and G/A contribution is comparable.
But work ethic - no contest.