Town Of Salem

[Joelinton's Right Foot]

Nah we just kill PENFOLD (The godfather) and I kill you (the consort) or DPP (the framer)

Of course if you are the escort, I'm sure you can see the importance of taking out the godfather and therefore testing the theory

I am happy to switch to Penfold if others do. However, as it stands if I vote for Penfold then I will get lynched, the GF survives, the other mafia survive AND the mafia will kill.

 

[Joelinton's Right Foot]

ok guys. lets just be clear and base on evidence from here

lets agree as town players who to kill

I've seen lots of claims and lots of "well i think cos i saw this"

Lets test those out

a) Penfold. the claim is he is godfather as there was an attempt to kill which failed. Did anyone block this kill??

b) DPP. the claim is he was sent to kill both mafia kills and also visited jurgen

c) killing penfold would block a mafia kill.. this i don't know. both nights mafia killed.


anything else.


lets be really clear what we are doing and why. we need 4 votes on the final guy!

I blocked Get Ritchie last night - as I have already said. I also got confirmation from Roland that I successfully blocked last night, something I didn't get on night one. This fits with Get Ritchie being the Vigilante as the Vigilante cannot kill on night one and I blocked him both nights for the reasons I have already explained.

 

[Darren Peacock’s Ponytail]

Confirmation that Roland also saw DPP's original post

Also gave my reasons there and then as well - I changed my mind from musty to Tash and then back again! Thought both were mafia due to not saying anything!!

 

[Warmir Pouchov]

I am happy to switch to Penfold if others do. However, as it stands if I vote for Penfold then I will get lynched, the GF survives, the other mafia survive AND the mafia will kill.

Exactly why we need to all vote PENFOLD. If MITO, Musty and ACS vote PENFOLD with me we have 4 votes.

 

[Warmir Pouchov]

Also gave my reasons there and then as well - I changed my mind from musty to Tash and then back again! Thought both were mafia due to not saying anything!!

Just switch to PENFOLD with the rest of us DPP

 

[Darren Peacock’s Ponytail]

You switched to Tash before 9pm and then immediately edited your post. This is why Roland also asked you to confirm whether it was a vote for Tash or not.

And? I voted for Musty not Tash until second round otherwise Tash would have been killed outright!

Not sure how anyone can be linked to mafia based on first night voting otherwise all those who voted that night are mafia?

I'm not mafia and I'm not the vigilante!

 

[Joelinton's Right Foot]

Exactly why we need to all vote PENFOLD. If MITO, Musty and ACS vote PENFOLD with me we have 4 votes.

As long as we lynch one of them clearly I don't care which it is. However, we need to have one clearly lynched so that others can take actions against the other one.

 

[Warmir Pouchov]

MITO we need to do this. Now Nev is starting to sway me, but this whole charade with DPP could be just clever gameplay.

 

[moreinjuredthanowen]

Nah we just kill PENFOLD (The godfather) and I kill you (the consort) or DPP (the framer)

Of course if you are the escort, I'm sure you can see the importance of taking out the godfather and therefore testing the theory

Why is DPP the framer

and DPP also visited More Hope the evening Beardsley was killed, hmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

musty said he visited More hope. he may or may not be either. Musty is bascially saying here that if DPP is mafia nev can't be.

 

[Warmir Pouchov]

Why is DPP the framer




musty said he visited More hope. he may or may not be either. Musty is bascially saying here that if DPP is mafia nev can't be.

I don't that DPP is the framer, that was all more tongue in cheek.

Musty said he visited Nev? **** I'll have to read back what he found - why can't they be on the same team? I still think the smart move is to all vote PENFOLD. We'll see what everyone does once we do that. What is the current votes situ? Did ACS lodge a vote earlier?

 

[Joelinton's Right Foot]

Why is DPP the framer




musty said he visited More hope. he may or may not be either. Musty is bascially saying here that if DPP is mafia nev can't be.

I don't understand how musty visited us both. What am I missing?

 

[Darren Peacock’s Ponytail]

Just switch to PENFOLD with the rest of us DPP

Why is DPP the framer




musty said he visited More hope. he may or may not be either. Musty is bascially saying here that if DPP is mafia nev can't be.

Sounds like musty is the Framer! Surely only 2 people would possibly be able to find out who the framer is; 1) the sherrif or 2) the investigaer - now bearing in mind someone has claimed that role and the other is dead then only the framer would know?

 

[Joelinton's Right Foot]

I don't that DPP is the framer, that was all more tongue in cheek.

Musty said he visited Nev? **** I'll have to read back what he found - why can't they be on the same team? I still think the smart move is to all vote PENFOLD. We'll see what everyone does once we do that. What is the current votes situ? Did ACS lodge a vote earlier?

ACS voted for me based on there being a 66% chance I was bad based on his investigation result. I am confused about who Musty visited last night too.

 

[Warmir Pouchov]

DPP it is then

Musty switch

 

[Joelinton's Right Foot]

Musty switch

Musty has gone to bed mate. He is in Oz. Not sure we will see him again before nightfall.

 

[Warmir Pouchov]

Why did DPP visit Nev?

I understand he visited the two dead lads, but Nev isn't dead. How can DPP have visited three people in two nights?

 

[Warmir Pouchov]

Musty has gone to bed mate. He is in Oz. Not sure we will see him again before nightfall.

Handy for mafia that. Nevertheless if we all vote PENFOLD, late switches will reveal all

 

[Darren Peacock’s Ponytail]

Why did DPP visit Nev?

I understand he visited the two dead lads, but Nev isn't dead. How can DPP have visited three people in two nights?

Getting a bit worried with my sleepwalking by the looks of it!

 

[moreinjuredthanowen]

MITO we need to do this. Now Nev is starting to sway me, but this whole charade with DPP could be just clever gameplay.

DPP came from musty.

if you take it that musty is telling truth then Nev is not mafia. he could be nuetral still but so far nobody is denying his role

.....


1. Musty says 100% DPP is mafia

2. You say penfold was your target but you coudl not kill

3. Nev says he blocked oyu

4. Musty says he saw dpp visit nev. IF DPP is mafia why could he visit his own team mate.

This is a circular argument coming down to do we believe musty.

I see no reason not to beleive him

The questions then are:

1. What is DPP. i don't think godfather due to visits

2. Is penfold godfather? he could well be.

3. what happens if penfold is blocked as nev claims... i don't know.

4. what happens if penfold is alive tomorrow.. I don't know.

5. do we risk killing penfold and leave a known DPP alive?

6. If we lynch penfold will this block the mafia kill?

7. if we lynch penfold and he is not mafia then we see get ritchie killed then theres no point saying oh kill dpp... also the mafia role blocker will be blocking actions


....

remember any plan agreed on this board is visible to mafia so.... it must be you guys deciding what you do on yor own or a plan they cannot break with thier own actions.

 

[Warmir Pouchov]

Getting a bit worried with my sleepwalking by the looks of it!

I'm actually slightly suspicious of Musty suggesting you are visiting 3 people in 2 nights?