by whats gone on the lynching happens first, then the night actions. Tash was hanged last night after night fall and we didn't hear anything until 10am on beardsley. my understanding is that all actions must be in before 9pm but nothing happens on the thread from that lynch til the following morning.
anyway I have mostly been pulling penfold's chain as theres nothing (well I'm avoiding work really) to do here. All I know is what ACS said and obviously how penfold reacted Here is what I do know: Mafia 1: godfather? Mafia 2: Mafia 3 ARSONIST: (i got doused) Neutral: ? Sheriff: Dead (valley) Doctor: dead (tash) bodygaurd: dead (beardsley) Investigator: claimed by ACS?? there were 14 at the start so now there are 11 thus: from 10 other than me i know 5 are bad. 50/50 change to get them.. same for all town roles (if you can kill). I think if the town doesn't act fast we will lose this as mafia are untouched while theres 5 town left. If I believe ACS and of course know I am town then 5 out of 9 are filthy.... IBWT Get Ritchie DPP Mustyfrog Penfold Mikey MoreHope Chaos Jurgen This means with 3 votes the mafia can lynch who they like if the town fails to get its act together... eg they could lynch a town and kill ACS tonight mkaing this 3v3v1v1. ...................................... my role: as I am doused I aint lasting long. I would PRESUME there's one other who is doused who never fessed up to it. why they failed to share i don't know but my sharing helps town as it knows a type of neutral now. I presume that this arsonist needs 3/4 doused before they set it off so they can win... but they might decide just to let it go. so: I am the MEDIUM I talk to the dead. I have been told one thing and one thing only by the dearly departed. I was told that more than one kill attempt may have occurred on valley. So that MIGHT mean a serial killer or might mean werefolf or might mean a lucky vigilante. It is not much but again it helps town. I consider the role fairly unneeded by town at this point as either ACS coughs up what he knows on penfold or he doesn't today. If ACS is lying its no loss either as the role doens't actually do anything till a lot of dead come in with info and nobody has any. This now narrows the field and there isn't much hiding spaces for the lads now.
If you read the thread and Beardsley's comment and the timing of it, my comment was clearly a joke. As for ignoring your question, when? Post s 243 and 247. Also 250-253. Hardly ignoring it, is it? Do the Mafia have an investigator, I don't know I'm not Mafia but it is one of the roles they could have and therefore could explain why him. Lets see what Chippy comes up with.
ok being a good guy and if I believe everyone else I am pretty sure I know who 2 of the 3 baddies are, awaiting clarification as to what I can say and what I cannot
over to you guys. I've told you lots If ACs is not lying (and real investigator, if one exists can disprove) IBWT Get Ritchie DPP Mustyfrog Penfold Mikey MoreHope Chaos Jurgen 5 of 9 are bad.
I can't tell that. I noted that very early both said they were "good" not "town" not vanilla etc etc. is that a tell? probably highly marginal. I tried repeating the good guy line neville used but got no reaction. valley got killed first. very circumstantial evidence as anyone could have done it. I thought initially hey penfold is after ACS here and though maybe executioner? again thats just a hunch I also thought hey IBWT dropped tow posts yesterday that i though.. ah ha! but thats not proof there for example They might be on a team or they might not. I can't tell really.
yes but there are 2 nuetral roles as well. 3 mafia and 2 neutrals who are bad guys = 5 one i know is an arsonist.
Indeed but I could just reveal my role and what I know for certain. Unless you think its a bad idea for a town to do so?
Chippy has revealed and so has Mitsy, assuming both are telling the truth. Agree with Mitsy it is now tight for Town. My view disclose away but not until others say whether good idea or not I would suggest.
You gotta make that call. I revealed mine cos i was doused and it gave me two real bits of info to share before i get torched. Put it this way. A mafia sitting here right now has a list of 7 and either they say now.. ok ACs is investigator he's got to go or mito is just the medium.. now we have only 6 to pick out of... or they kill me anyway i dunno. Anyway. In theory a mafia team could have a list coing ok we kill ACS tonight, Mito is not that important so which of the 5 left do we kill. That's your issue. do you just say well you are mad enough to make it easy for them but i won't... OR you could have info that reveals another mafia. In general... if you know 100% a bad guy then unless you think its vital not to reveal then mafia theory says reveal. Given we lost valley day one and ACS is out that can be the issue. plus ACS might be lying...
being 9 hrs ahead of you guys and difficult to keep up I will disclose what I know - a certain player visited both Valley and Beardsley and then they were dead - didn't you DPP
