Just putting this out for discussion..... The mafia now have a large number of claimed roles to aim at. It is likely that they will try and go for a safe kill rather than going for the vigilante. I know that if I visit the Vigilante I die. I do not know if this applies to other town roles. Is it worth the vigilante claiming his role so that I can aim for somebody else to block? I have confirmed that I am able to block a mafia kill, so if I block the Godfather then no kill happens. My suggestion: Vigilante claims role. I block Penfold (thinking he might be the GF) and we lynch DPP
I will support a DPP vote. nev is on him and you are thats 3 votes. we nee done more min to ensure he swings guys if anyone of course is a executioner this is ideal
I would assume the mafia have a list now yes 1. ACS 2. vigilante as he's only killer we have so we will see won't we. If anyone denies any of the claims like that would be fun. DPP is obvious candidate to suddenly jump up and say hey... I'm the vigilante!!!
We need to think about the second neutral vote too. I suspect that it will be either a Werewolf or Vampire.
I'm not buying this, why would you just randomly block me on night one. And then again the second night. I don't like this theory at all. DPP and Nev - these are my picks. Its clear we all must vote PENFOLD as he is the most likely Godfather, and we need to test my theory. If we kill the godfather we know Nev is likely lying about blocking me and it was the game rule of the godfather not dying at night which stopped me. What we cannot have is people running amok and wasting this opportunity to find information. Therefore Nev you need to get on board and vote PENFOLD. All town do - we may even weed them all out in one go here. We'll either get a baddie or narrow down the game further. We might of course kill the godfather and you could still have been telling the truth but I'd be suspicious about this.
Not sure why I'm being voted for! Yes I voted for Tash and musty for both the same reason, completely active without saying anything which always seems guilty to me. Stay hidden! It's already been pointed out that Penfold and MHWR appear to be in cahoots! I'm going for More Hope With Rafa Also strange that these quieter ones all of a sudden appear pinning it on the likes of ickle ol' me claiming they are town when looks to me as if they are all in it together and are most likely one of the 5 bad guys!
My reason for voting DPP is that he is confirmed as having visited both people killed on both nights of a mafia hit. My reason for visiting you twice is that I thought there was an outside chance of you being a neutral killer and that being why there was only one kill/action. There was also an element of self-preservation. If I visited the Veteran or SK I would die. I knew after night one you were a safe choice to block.
Lol! First night was a free for all and second night I voted Musty - I only then voted for Tash in the second bit as he was active but not saying anything so appeared dodgy!
I will block Penfold tonight. If he is the GF then this means that the mafia cannot kill. If there is no mafia kill tonight we can virtually take it as confirmed that Penfold is the GF. The evidence points to DPP being at the scene of a mafia killing two nights in a row. This is the biggest evidence we have of a definite mafia connection.
You switched to Tash before 9pm and then immediately edited your post. This is why Roland also asked you to confirm whether it was a vote for Tash or not.
Edit: I meant that the Veteran could claim the role. Anyone visiting him would die. This is a risk to town as well as mafia.
This is terrible from the town. We know DPP is likely mafia - therefore he is not a priority. There is little reason to waste a lynching on him. DPP and Nev are steering us away from the godfather here - PENFOLD. The reasoning is obvious. They won't know whether I'm going to kill DPP or Nev. One of them is the consort and can prevent my action. I can't kill the godfather on a nighttime. Essentially they can see 2 of their team of 3 getting wiped tonight and they don't like the odds. Remember my action is first. They like the odds of the godfather going unharmed, and then the consort blocks my action. They may lose DPP but then will they, if they all switch at the last moment. There is simply no reason not to vote PENFOLD bar us believing Nev is the Escort and miraculously blocked my action without knowing who I am. How about all town switch to PENFOLD and we see what Nev and DPP do with their votes for each other. I can't recommend strongly enough that all town should vote PENFOLD.
Nah we just kill PENFOLD (The godfather) and I kill you (the consort) or DPP (the framer) Of course if you are the escort, I'm sure you can see the importance of taking out the godfather and therefore testing the theory
I am the town ESCORT and not the mafia consort. If I am NOT the town Escort then somebody else can counter this claim. I am blocking Penfold tonight. If he is the GF then he cannot kill. If no mafia kill happens tonight then we will KNOW that either Penfold is the GF or (worst case scenario) the mafia decide not to kill tonight to frame Penfold. Either way we lynch a known mafia in DPP and the mafia don't kill a town.
ok guys. lets just be clear and base on evidence from here lets agree as town players who to kill I've seen lots of claims and lots of "well i think cos i saw this" Lets test those out a) Penfold. the claim is he is godfather as there was an attempt to kill which failed. Did anyone block this kill?? b) DPP. the claim is he was sent to kill both mafia kills and also visited jurgen c) killing penfold would block a mafia kill.. this i don't know. both nights mafia killed. anything else. lets be really clear what we are doing and why. we need 4 votes on the final guy!
MITO, MUSTY, ACS - we must join forces and vote for PENFOLD. We need to force DPP and Nev into a corner here.
