The Premier League Thread

Dreadful decision. Never a yellow.

 

Stonewall 2nd yellow!

 

Tom, if you think that’s a yellow card after seeing the replay, you shouldn’t be allowed to referee football games. Barely a foul.

 

Keep in mind Mike Dean is reffing........

 

Late challenge. Not much contact but that's not the issue. It was a reckless challenge.

 

And already on a yellow. Got to be more clever.
102 reds for Dean now, and more to come before he's out to pasture,.

 

Never a yellow card.

 

Awful decision. Understand var not reviewing all yellow cards but don't see why can't do it with second yellows.

 

Because VAR is not here to take over from referees.

 

Noble’s dive was far more of a second yellow than that non-tackle.

 

Well someone needs to, because it was a diabolical decision. I’d actually now give you a stadium ban for life, having watched it again!

 

Noble should have gone, I agree but so should Masuaku.

 

Just linesmen?

 

Do you enjoy red cards, Tom?

 

Even if VAR had reviewed that it wouldn't have overturned the red card. And watching it live it looked a stonewall second yellow so don't know how you can have a go at Mike Dean. Replays showed minimal contact but it's still a foul and 2nd yellow as he would have been away down the right.

 

Because it’s not a yellow card. If VAR was allowed to review it, and still said it was a yellow, then VAR should join you on that stadium ban.

 

Well it was a yellow card as Masuaku discovered.

 

Even if var didn't overturn it that doesn't necessarily mean it would be the correct decision.

I expect it probably wouldn't have been seeing as it's just backed the refs up so far, I was just posing the question as I don't see the difference really in reviewing that and a straight red as they're both potentially game changing decisions.

 

A yellow card was given. That doesn’t make it the right decision.