Off Topic The Politics Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

Should the UK remain a part of the EU or leave?

  • Stay in

    Votes: 56 47.9%
  • Get out

    Votes: 61 52.1%

  • Total voters
    117
  • Poll closed .
I don't think Brexiteers are as naive as you make out. Everyone, even the ERG, have said that WTO means a temporary bumpy ride. Independence is a sweet concept particularly if the EU struggles and with that in mind, we may well see a rise on anti-EU politicians joining the European Parliament in May.

Of course, if the ERG leave after March, there will have to be a GE. Their calculation must include what would happen if there was. Would they be ready? Would Umunna and chums be ready? Would Corbyn lose more MP's? Who would replace May? Who would lead ERG?
I think we all have been naive in thinking the politicians would do nothing but look after themselves, that's in every party. I can see a and referendum coming to be honest
 
I don't think Brexiteers are as naive as you make out. Everyone, even the ERG, have said that WTO means a temporary bumpy ride. Independence is a sweet concept particularly if the EU struggles and with that in mind, we may well see a rise on anti-EU politicians joining the European Parliament in May.

Of course, if the ERG leave after March, there will have to be a GE. Their calculation must include what would happen if there was. Would they be ready? Would Umunna and chums be ready? Would Corbyn lose more MP's? Who would replace May? Who would lead ERG?
I heard May say today re 'no deal' that it would be a bumpy start but we would prosper. These Euro elections coming up may be full of Eurosceptic MEP's...now that would be funny. Imagine if the whole rotten house of cards fell due to their own stupidness?
 
I think we all have been naive in thinking the politicians would do nothing but look after themselves, that's in every party. I can see a and referendum coming to be honest

Don't think a second ref would get through Parliament to be honest, Bob. A lot of Labour MP's in Leave constituencies are against it. Most of the Tory party are against it.
 
I heard May say today re 'no deal' that it would be a bumpy start but we would prosper. These Euro elections coming up may be full of Eurosceptic MEP's...now that would be funny. Imagine if the whole rotten house of cards fell due to their own stupidness?

I suspect leaders of the large member states don't reflect their electorate. Look at Macron, one of the most unpopular presidents ever. Merkel has had her day. EU economies are doing pretty badly. Youth unemployment is high in southern states. I suspect there's a lot of discontent out there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ELLERS
I suspect leaders of the large member states don't reflect their electorate. Look at Macron, one of the most unpopular presidents ever. Merkel has had her day. EU economies are doing pretty badly. Youth unemployment is high in southern states. I suspect there's a lot of discontent out there.
Agree Goldie the great European Pillars of the EU are crumbling. Farage said the EU are in for a surprise with the next elections.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Goldhawk-Road
How do you see it going then Goldie ?
I’m ****ed if I know anymore and I’m pretty much beyond carrying if I’m honest.

Unless May pulls an incredible rabbit out of the hat in the next two weeks (unlikely), we'll have an extension until the end of June. Negotiations will continue but without the no-deal pressure on the EU and Ireland, the backstop will stay.

So in June, Parliament may vote on May deal with indefinite backstop or no deal. Beyond that, Stainsey, I'm with you, I cannot see how this could resolve itself. We may see splits in parties at this stage, and/or a General Election where the Tories try to get a working majority.

We could also see people taking to the streets...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Staines R's
Why are people so desperate for the EU to crumble or for it to go pear shaped? I seriously dont understand why someone would wish that on others. Is it the British spirit? 17 m of us dont want to be part of it so we hope it fails. Quite sad really
 
  • Like
Reactions: Stroller and sb_73
Unless May pulls an incredible rabbit out of the hat in the next two weeks (unlikely), we'll have an extension until the end of June. Negotiations will continue but without the no-deal pressure on the EU and Ireland, the backstop will stay.

So in June, Parliament may vote on May deal with indefinite backstop or no deal. Beyond that, Stainsey, I'm with you, I cannot see how this could resolve itself. We may see splits in parties at this stage, and/or a General Election where the Tories try to get a working majority.
Hopefully without May because with her at the helm the party is ruined. These really are weird times. Labour are crap under Comrade Corbyn. He will never be PM. Tories are in big trouble due to the handling of Brexit. The Limp Dems are as irrelevant as 'TIG'. There will be room for a new party. Hopefully a Brexit party will come forward.
 
Why are people so desperate for the EU to crumble or for it to go pear shaped? I seriously dont understand why someone would wish that on others. Is it the British spirit? 17 m of us dont want to be part of it so we hope it fails. Quite sad really

It's not schadenfreude. The worse the EU does, the easier it is for reluctant UK Remain MP's to move to a more Brexit position. And the more difficult it is for Europhile MP's to claim the EU is the Land of Milk and Honey. EU economies are doing badly, even Germany. The May elections could be a further watershed.
 
It's not schadenfreude. The worse the EU does, the easier it is for reluctant UK Remain MP's to move to a more Brexit position. And the more difficult it is for Europhile MP's to claim the EU is the Land of Milk and Honey. EU economies are doing badly, even Germany. The May elections could be a further watershed.
Best jump ship then
 
Hopefully without May because with her at the helm the party is ruined. These really are weird times. Labour are crap under Comrade Corbyn. He will never be PM. Tories are in big trouble due to the handling of Brexit. The Limp Dems are as irrelevant as 'TIG'. There will be room for a new party. Hopefully a Brexit party will come forward.

Yes, I think a Brexit Party wouldn't take long to establish. Everyone knows what their main manifesto pledge will be... It would attract millions of votes from Leave voters nursing a huge injustice
 
  • Like
Reactions: ELLERS
Yes, I think a Brexit Party wouldn't take long to establish. Everyone knows what their main manifesto pledge will be... It would attract millions of votes from Leave voters nursing a huge injustice

Who would be leader of the ‘Brexit Party’ ?
I couldn’t see many hard line (ex) Labour voters, like myself, voting for ****s like JRM or Farage.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sb_73
totally agree I don't think he fully understands what will happen. It is just a remainers view and they will just say anything. I now think that the ERG need to walk and set up a Brexit party. They would get 17.4M voters who will feel betrayed and would probably have the majority. The Tories and Labour will be toast. 'We are a funny race and when pushed we will stick two fingers up at them'.
I like this shrill, hysterical Ellers. Oh oh, I have been betrayed, I’m a snowflake victim, be scared of what I might do! I might vote for a bunch of nationalist populists to piss you off! Fill your boots baby blue.

Your ERG mates couldn’t organise a piss up in a brewery, let alone an effective political party. It took them months to get a no confidence vote together, which they lost. Their rich mates are busy getting their cash out of the country. Much more likely that May will go before the next election, Johnson will take over with the help of the gammons and blue rinses in the constituencies, and many of your 17.4m mates, who only have influence through their vote, will be conned into voting for him. Splitting the Brexit vote between Tories and Nationalists. Then your chums will get to vote for the people who betrayed them from the word go, the ones who lied to them throughout the leave campaign.
I don't think Brexiteers are as naive as you make out. Everyone, even the ERG, have said that WTO means a temporary bumpy ride. Independence is a sweet concept particularly if the EU struggles and with that in mind, we may well see a rise on anti-EU politicians joining the European Parliament in May.

Of course, if the ERG leave after March, there will have to be a GE. Their calculation must include what would happen if there was. Would they be ready? Would Umunna and chums be ready? Would Corbyn lose more MP's? Who would replace May? Who would lead ERG?
Brexit voters believed the **** peddled through the referendum campaign, I’d say a large proportion of them are naive and probably now angry. Not of course the middle class ones like you and Ellers, but the huddled masses of the dying industrial north and the deprived seaside towns. I’m confident none of them voted for a ‘bumpy ride’, they are barely surviving now and were expecting some instant benefits from the referendum result, let alone Brexit itself. These are the people who will genuinely suffer from a no deal Brexit, I’ll just be inconvenienced like you. Neither of us has the right to speak for them. None are natural Tory voters, their vote is more likely to go far right or far left. And the far left have a better story for them, from what I can see.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Stroller and bobmid
I like this shrill, hysterical Ellers. Oh oh, I have been betrayed, I’m a snowflake victim, be scared of what I might do! I might vote for a bunch of nationalist populists to piss you off! Fill your boots baby blue.

Your ERG mates couldn’t organise a piss up in a brewery, let alone an effective political party. It took them months to get a no confidence vote together, which they lost. Their rich mates are busy getting their cash out of the country. Much more likely that May will go before the next election, Johnson will take over with the help of the gammons and blue rinses in the constituencies, and many of your 17.4m mates, who only have influence through their vote, will be conned into voting for him. Splitting the Brexit vote between Tories and Nationalists. Then your chums will get to vote for the people who betrayed them from the word go, the ones who lied to them throughout the leave campaign.

Brexit voters believed the **** peddled through the referendum campaign, I’d say a large proportion of them are naive and probably now angry. Not of course the middle class ones like you and Ellers, but the huddled masses of the dying industrial north and the deprived seaside towns. I’m confident none of them voted for a ‘bumpy ride’, they are barely surviving now and were expecting some instant benefits from the referendum result, let alone Brexit itself. These are the people who will genuinely suffer from a no deal Brexit, I’ll just be inconvenienced like you. Neither of us has the right to speak for them. None are natural Tory voters, their vote is more likely to go far right or far left. And the far left have a better story for them, from what I can see.
Brilliant