Transfer Rumours The 2015 Summer Transfer Window Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think he's a good manager, too many people judge him on the England job imo. Given time & money I think he will do well there - he done a fantastic job at another (smaller) north east club. He also learnt from the best.

I think he'll do well at Newcastle and is a good appointment. He had one and a half very good seasons at Derby.

I don't agree he did a fantastic job at Boro though. Four months before he got the England job, a Middlesborough fan ran on the pitch and threw his season ticket at him; it wasn't because he was doing a fantastic job. Two exciting comebacks in UEFA cup games (arguably from positions that tactical nativity had got them into) got him the England job. He was never the man for that and he wouldn't have got that if the BBC hadn't been so dogged in their desire to expose Fat Sam as a bit of a "dodgy dealer" a few weeks before the appointment.
 
The former, where you will likely be adored by 50,000 hardcore geordies, and could become the king of tyneside, or the latter, where you will rot in the reserves, as a mere side-thought to a bunch of arrogant, racist twats.

Name those supporters in one!
 
I think he'll do well at Newcastle and is a good appointment. He had one and a half very good seasons at Derby.

I don't agree he did a fantastic job at Boro though. Four months before he got the England job, a Middlesborough fan ran on the pitch and threw his season ticket at him; it wasn't because he was doing a fantastic job. Two exciting comebacks in UEFA cup games (arguably from positions that tactical nativity had got them into) got him the England job. He was never the man for that and he wouldn't have got that if the BBC hadn't been so dogged in their desire to expose Fat Sam as a bit of a "dodgy dealer" a few weeks before the appointment.

The bottling of those two seasons at Derby are at the end of the day the legacy he leaves there. Blowing it completely from two very strong positions. A manager who is in charge of that has too many shortcomings for me.
 
The bottling of those two seasons at Derby are at the end of the day the legacy he leaves there. Blowing it completely from two very strong positions. A manager who is in charge of that has too many shortcomings for me.

You seem avid in your dislike of a man who has managed other clubs. Did he release you as a youngster from a club? :)

Ask a Newcastle fan if they'd like to be top 6 all the way til next March, then bottle it and finish 8-10th, playing good football. I bet they snap your fingers off!
 
You seem avid in your dislike of a man who has managed other clubs. Did he release you as a youngster from a club? :)

Ask a Newcastle fan if they'd like to be top 6 all the way til next March, then bottle it and finish 8-10th, playing good football. I bet they snap your fingers off!

No - just think he's a Championship manager at best. Doesn't have what it takes at top level, he's shown that since England days. Anyone who understudied SAF for as long as he did should have more to his bow than McClaren. I actually often feel a bit sorry for him - he doesn't look like he needs the hassle most of the time, and I'm sure he's a great grandad. My view of him clarified at the time he was linked to the Saints job - would you want him at Saints? I'm shuddering writing it...
 
What are everyone's thoughts on Cabaye? Wants out from PSG and to return to the PL. Palace are the frontrunners because of Pardew. He is 29, but surely would give us something different?
 
No - just think he's a Championship manager at best. Doesn't have what it takes at top level, he's shown that since England days. Anyone who understudied SAF for as long as he did should have more to his bow than McClaren. I actually often feel a bit sorry for him - he doesn't look like he needs the hassle most of the time, and I'm sure he's a great grandad. My view of him clarified at the time he was linked to the Saints job - would you want him at Saints? I'm shuddering writing it...

He wouldn't be my choice, but we'll just see if he's as bad as you say, or as "ok" as I say. I don't think he's great by any stretch but a much maligned coach who was handed the job offer he couldn't refuse at just the wrong time (or anytime for that matter).
 
What are everyone's thoughts on Cabaye? Wants out from PSG and to return to the PL. Palace are the frontrunners because of Pardew. He is 29, but surely would give us something different?
Bearing in mind he went to PSG, I think we can assume his wages will be very high which would rule him out of coming to SMS which is a shame as he showed he was a very creative attacking midfielder
 
Gaston heading back to Italy? Bologna want him back after getting promoted.

I was one who thought he had all the ability needed to make it here, but sadly he just didn't deliver anywhere near enough.
 
Gaston heading back to Italy? Bologna want him back after getting promoted.

I was one who thought he had all the ability needed to make it here, but sadly he just didn't deliver anywhere near enough.

Very similar to Bryan Ruiz at Fulham imo. Obviously got a lot of ability but just couldn’t adapt to the speed of the English game, shows the odd flash but nowhere near regularly enough to warrant a place in the squad.
 
I'm getting a little worried that this famous black box is actually big Les playing FM, as 90% of the players we get linked with i have never heard of yet all the FM addicts on here rave about them. :emoticon-0102-bigsm
 
I'm getting a little worried that this famous black box is actually big Les playing FM, as 90% of the players we get linked with i have never heard of yet all the FM addicts on here rave about them. :emoticon-0102-bigsm
Or people like myself watch a lot more footy then you. :emoticon-0110-tongu
 
Status
Not open for further replies.