Summer Transfers Mega-Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
And right there, I wonder if you've hit the nail on the head. I said the other day that perhaps we didn't need somebody better than what we've currently got in that CAM/ second striker role, we needed someone who better complements the rest of our side. With Holt as an obvious target for long balls, it didn't matter if Wes was too short, he was there for the knock-downs. With Van Wolfswinkel up front, he's not the same target (I think he lacks the strength if not the height of Holt), so with him and Wes together, the defence have no out-ball when under pressure. We saw against Sociedad Hughton experimenting with Fer in an advanced role, as he offered that target, so perhaps that's the reason behind Elmander signing? What I've just said kinda explains why I thought Toivonen would be such a good signing, as he'd offer both the height and creativity. If that ship has sailed, or we've spent the money elsewhere, then perhaps Elmander is the cheap alternative? Orrr, maybe this is the club putting pressure on Toivonen to make his mind up, by making it seem like we're close to signing a player who Toivonen presumably knows pretty well, and would do a similar job at the club. But that's probably just wishful thinking...

Edit: Amazing how we all picked up on the Hoolahan comment! <laugh> I should probably add I'm not that knowledgeable about Elmander to know whether he could be used in the way I'm suggesting, I've just got that impression from reading a few other bits and pieces.

Looking at his Wiki page (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johan_Elmander), it does seem that he has played a lot as CAM as well as playing as the roving forward behind the primary striker. Could well be a good solution if Toivonen does decide to stay at PSV.
 
My evidence was the 1 in 3 goal ratio in his first season at Gala. I did then accept that his second season was not as good but then said that I don't think that alone is enough to suggest that he is suddenly a poor player

How familiar are you with the quality of the SuperLiqa outside the top4? Anyone who plays as a forward for Gala, be it a lone striker, in a two, or behind a main striker, is going to score a hat full of goals. Elmander made a name for himself when he scored twice against Besiktas, unfortunately, his general lack of contribution has eroded that support both within the club and with fans. He has been available for months - most fans seemed to think he was heading to Hull. I really wish I could be more positive about him but he's simply not a player, I believe, Norwich needs or will perform well. A really bad decision to sign him, even free, if indeed, it happens.
 
I think we are going to have to agree to disagree.

Fair enough - it is after all a forum for discussion and differing views! But, with all respect, I've seen him play many times and you don't seem to have, at least recently...How many Gala forward's don't have a ratio of at least better than 1 in 3? Well, Elmander last year for one. Can't think of anyone else. As a comparison, Burak Yilmaz scored 24 goals in 30 games. Umut Bulut 12 in 26 - and contributing far more all round than Elmander...God, I wish we'd signed him!!!!
 
In all honesty I haven't seen him play since his Bolton days so you're right in that respect. I find it difficult to believe that he has declined as much as you are suggesting though. I don't think a loss of form equates to a loss of ability and if Hughton thinks he can rediscover that then I trust him.
 
In all honesty I haven't seen him play since his Bolton days so you're right in that respect. I find it difficult to believe that he has declined as much as you are suggesting though. I don't think a loss of form equates to a loss of ability and if Hughton thinks he can rediscover that then I trust him.

He is still a regular in the Sweden team, and played all but the last 5 or so minutes of the recent WCQ defeat to Austria in June, together with Ibrahimavic. Surely can't be that bad. <ok>
 
Great signing for saints, they have a great squad now

Talking of italians, am watching Psg vs Ajaccio now, Psg have cavani and ibrahamivoc up front! Not bad