Transfer Rumours Summer Transfer window

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think Hackney is a better player than Dan, if we are being honest. There’s a reason Hackney was being selected for England U21’s and Dan was never handed a chance.

If we don’t bring in Xhaka or enough midfield cover then we’ll have to keep Dan. My personal opinion is I just don’t think he’s got the attributes to be a premier league player.
He's probably a little bit better, but not much IMO. The U21 thing is as much to do with timing as anything. If Neil had been born three weeks later he'd have likely been in contention alongside Hackney. He was just too old for the intake - and was battling with prem players as a newly promoted champ player for the 2023 squad.
 
He's probably a little bit better, but not much IMO. The U21 thing is as much to do with timing as anything. If Neil had been born three weeks later he'd have likely been in contention alongside Hackney. He was just too old for the intake - and was battling with prem players as a newly promoted champ player for the 2023 squad.

If Dan Neil’s data was anywhere close to Hackneys last season our fans would be saying he’s a £50m player
 
I think Hackney is a better player than Dan, if we are being honest. There’s a reason Hackney was being selected for England U21’s and Dan was never handed a chance.

If we don’t bring in Xhaka or enough midfield cover then we’ll have to keep Dan. My personal opinion is I just don’t think he’s got the attributes to be a premier league player.

I think they are much of a muchness tbh, neither are stand out, game changing midfielders at championship level although I do believe both are good players and have potential to get better.

it’s a difficult one for Neill (actually think the stuff below is the same for Patto) as I don’t see another PL team offering him much more than we would either wages or playing minutes wise.

he could drop back to the championship to a favourite for promotion but they aren’t going to be offering him much bigger wages in my opinion.

Europe could be an option as he could get a gig in a top level division like serie a but salary wise he is unlikely to get a lot more than what he would get here.

I’d like him to stay as I think he could be a good squad player, question is, is he prepared to become a squad player after being team captain and regular starter for us…psychologically it’s a big drop but could open more doors next season as a free transfer.

ironically if our transfer business had seen defenders and strikers arrive early rather than midfielders he may have he more game time in pre season to impress, feels like he has been left behind and uncertainty of not signing a new deal won’t have helped

if he goes it will be with the best of wishes and thanks for the critical role he’s played in our return to the premier league as well as a little tinge of sadness
 
One of those describes me to a tee RTB, I'll leave it to others to decide which one :emoticon-0102-bigsm:emoticon-0102-bigsm
Eccentric, 100%.

Going by your passion for a certain type of music (protest) and the work that you’ve spoke about doing, that’s always the impression of you that I’ve built up in my head.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Montysoptician
Status
Not open for further replies.