Summer '24 transfer window

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
I'm generally of the opinion that O'Nien would be fine there. His engine is perfectly capable. While he's not lightning he'll run for the entire 90 perfectly easily. Not sold on Johnson as cover, personally. However, I think Crompton would do a decent job. Good on the ball, mobile. I'd be looking to him as emergency third choice.

Ultimately it comes down to resource allocation. How many of the next 21 games is Trai Hume likely to miss? He has been available for selection for virtually every game in the past three seasons so the evidence says he's pretty robust. It's a gamble, but it's probably not as much of a gamble as it initially looks.
Oh you've done it now! I remember a similar post about Ross Stewart right before he pulled out of the Boro game and he's never really recovered since!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frazier the Lion
We’ve seen how important the FBs are going to be under RLB in terms of being both technically proficient and having the speed and engine to get up and down. Of the rest of the squad, Alese was probably most capable of doing that and then to a lesser extent Hjelde. CBs like Johnson, O’Nien etc will be game enough but don’t have the skill set. I don’t see how a switch to three at the back can be managed with the squad as it is.
Dunno either, but RLB seems to know what he's doing
 
The worry with fullback cover is that even in the 21s we are playing Crompton as a fullback. So there's not a lot there either as Bainbridge is on loan at Killie! Lavery is the only option.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheBronzeBummer
It’s a shame Huggins is built with crisps because he’s perfect cover for both sides. I really don’t think someone immobile like a Johnson or O’nien covering will work in this system where they're expected to get up and down the pitch regularly and contribute so much offensively, admittedly though I haven’t seen too much of Johnson that’s just off the very little I’ve seen.

Brandon Williams is available on a free iirc I’d be all over that.
Brandon Williams was previously on £50k so I'd worry about how much he'd cost us. Also completely disagree about O'Nien's mobility. He's more than capable of getting up and down the pitch for 90. I'd be surprised if there's a fitter player in the squad. Agree about Huggins, though. He's a really good player that would stop any worries about fullback instantly. The calculation for SAFC is whether they can wait for him to return - and what they feel he'll be like when he does get back. If we genuinely think that minutes from NH are reasonably likely after Christmas then I'd certainly be making do till then, personally.
 
He played as a full back in L1 though, amongst a standard of football so bad we thought Carl Winchester was a good full back when he was playing there. I think if it was inverted he’d get away with it but we’re moving away from that to proper attacking full backs. Of course he CAN play there, many players can probably do a job there if they really had to but you don’t want to handicap yourself too much.
I think he can do a role what Hume does tbh, Himes strengths certainly don't lie in his attacking game
 
Will be Aleksic announced today, Samed early tomorrow and Simic later on towards the window closing imo,

Think simic could come today as sounds like his medical and personal terms are already done
 
I think Cannon will be off to Luton, hopefully we get Roko in, it's just whether that will be enough with him, Mayenda and Wilson who will also be asked to play LW at times I'm sure.

A fullback would be ideal but not seeing any names linked so could be RLB is content with the cover
 
I think Cannon will be off to Luton, hopefully we get Roko in, it's just whether that will be enough with him, Mayenda and Wilson who will also be asked to play LW at times I'm sure.

A fullback would be ideal but not seeing any names linked so could be RLB is content with the cover
I think Rusyn could stick around if we only bring one striker in, his cameo was alright against Burnley did what he needed to do, he’s limited but he’s a pest and will force mistakes against tired defences
 
Oh you've done it now! I remember a similar post about Ross Stewart right before he pulled out of the Boro game and he's never really recovered since!!
I almost didn't post it for that very reason! However, it'd be a struggle to describe the evidence of Ross Stewart's career as showing that he was a robust player - apart from that glorious 18 month run of course.
 
I think Rusyn could stick around if we only bring one striker in, his cameo was alright against Burnley did what he needed to do, he’s limited but he’s a pest and will force mistakes against tired defences
I think it'll set the terminally online portion of the SAFC fanbase off no end if we end up with 'an inexperienced foreign kid, a winger plus two failures from last year' as our striker options for this season, but I'd be happy with that lot, personally. I'd even be happy with not getting another winger in - so long as Mundle and Watson are getting minutes.
 
I think it'll set the terminally online portion of the SAFC fanbase off no end if we end up with 'an inexperienced foreign kid, a winger plus two failures from last year' as our striker options for this season, but I'd be happy with that lot, personally. I'd even be happy with not getting another winger in - so long as Mundle and Watson are getting minutes.
The 2 centre mids plus simic is an excellent window for me, would leave us in the any thing else is a bonus camp, not a bad position to be in
 
I have seen a French journalist (albeit just one) say it’s a loan without and obligation, hopefully there’s a clause in which just gives us the option, would be disappointing if not, although not an issue we need to worry about now :emoticon-0103-cool:

Definitely shows where we think he's at, we only seem to do that with players we think are a level slightly above the club (i.e. Amad)
 
  • Like
Reactions: APC