Thought id get this started to get folks thoughts on the summer transfer window. As always great to hear folks opinions and anyone who hears any rumours get them in this thread
Summer '24 transfer window
- Thread starter Scout73
- Start date
-
Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
-
Couple new names to me (we havent been linked with these lads but players ive scouted) that we should monitor:
Uran Bislimi - Lugano, can play on the wings or CM - technically outstanding and now in and around the Switzerland senior squad. Yes he has no championship experience but good experience in Switzerland. Has really kicked on this season and is a player that could be a cracking signing for us
Matonvic - CF (yes a possible striker), this lad is 6ft 4, has very good hold up and link up and is now scoring goals in germany. He turns 21 this month, hes on loan at Karlsruher from Frankfurt. Has scored 13 goals this season but hes scored 10 of them since start of December. German youth International and has the presence we need in a CF. Again i get hes not a championship experienced striker but hes someone with big upside who is a big improvement on what we have now. He isnt rapid but has good enough pace but he knows how to use his strength n body while being technically very good
Uran Bislimi - Lugano, can play on the wings or CM - technically outstanding and now in and around the Switzerland senior squad. Yes he has no championship experience but good experience in Switzerland. Has really kicked on this season and is a player that could be a cracking signing for us
Matonvic - CF (yes a possible striker), this lad is 6ft 4, has very good hold up and link up and is now scoring goals in germany. He turns 21 this month, hes on loan at Karlsruher from Frankfurt. Has scored 13 goals this season but hes scored 10 of them since start of December. German youth International and has the presence we need in a CF. Again i get hes not a championship experienced striker but hes someone with big upside who is a big improvement on what we have now. He isnt rapid but has good enough pace but he knows how to use his strength n body while being technically very good
I certainly feel this could be a pivotal summer for us. We must get the head coach appointment spot on, someone who will grow with us over a few seasons.
This summer will possibly see one of our key players sold. It'll be interesting how we reinvest the money.
Hopefully a few legacy deals will expire allowing us to increase our income streams.
This season was always going to be harder than the previous one. I'd love for us returning to playing fast exciting football.
Noooooooo Scout its way to early 
Anyway, finding the balance this window is going to be really tough. Naturally us fans will want to see signings made quickly. But in reality a lot of our signings might be dependant on selling first. Or if not dependant, then at least beneficial.
For example - if we sell Ballard we will want a new CB to replace him. So we don't want to go out and buy a £1m center back earlier in the window when we might have £5m to spend on one later on.
Likewise for Neil and Clarke.
But on the flipside, once we have sold for large fees, clubs will know we have money.
So whilst this is going to be a pivotal window for Speakman, its also going to be an incredibly tough one.
Anyway, finding the balance this window is going to be really tough. Naturally us fans will want to see signings made quickly. But in reality a lot of our signings might be dependant on selling first. Or if not dependant, then at least beneficial.
For example - if we sell Ballard we will want a new CB to replace him. So we don't want to go out and buy a £1m center back earlier in the window when we might have £5m to spend on one later on.
Likewise for Neil and Clarke.
But on the flipside, once we have sold for large fees, clubs will know we have money.
So whilst this is going to be a pivotal window for Speakman, its also going to be an incredibly tough one.
Haha I know, probably is too early but i like looking aheadNoooooooo Scout its way to early
Anyway, finding the balance this window is going to be really tough. Naturally us fans will want to see signings made quickly. But in reality a lot of our signings might be dependant on selling first. Or if not dependant, then at least beneficial.
For example - if we sell Ballard we will want a new CB to replace him. So we don't want to go out and buy a £1m center back earlier in the window when we might have £5m to spend on one later on.
Likewise for Neil and Clarke.
But on the flipside, once we have sold for large fees, clubs will know we have money.
So whilst this is going to be a pivotal window for Speakman, its also going to be an incredibly tough one.
This summer is one of the biggest weve ever had imo, if we sell clarke (which im 95% sure we will) we need to invest it in real quality. Not unproven players that might be good in a few yrs but it must be players that have played senior football at a good level and can hit the ground running
The south american market is always a good one to target, not a market i know that well but the value is always great and the leagues are played at a good tempo
Every window is hard but if we have money from selling one of our top players then we can come out of the window better than we went in
Get all giddy when I see these posts haha, for me a similar approach to what we are doing but a level up, easier said than done, would like some experience but I’m not talking 30+, plenty of 23 year olds are experienced enough to come in and make a difference, definitely need a centre forward and centre mid then see who leaves and what other gaps we need to fill
Totally agree, i want us to sign younger players but some most have experience so they can hit the ground running. Signings like roberts, clarke, ballard were huge - all had their best yrs ahead of them but had good experience there as well
I wouldnt mind adding 1 or 2 seasoned pros (not sure who at the minute) that can help kick our youngsters on
At the end of the day whether they have experienced or not, they must improve us immediately. I would like 1 or 2 going into our u21s to develop but last summer the majority were players that fell into that category
My usual suggestion Miles Leaburn from Charlton 
I think the fringes of the premier league/their top under 23s is a good way to go, the Mubama’s, Charlie cresswells is where there is the right blend of youth and being ready for the championship, as you have said the South America market has proven successful recently I’d like to try that abit more too
I think the model is, our young players this season will be our experienced players next season.
Only thing I disagree with in this is ‘one’ of our key players being sold. I think it will be more unless we have refreshed ambition. Massive summer for us and a bad time to lose trust in our recruitment team.
I see it as a core of trusted quality players for this level more than age with some innovation across the squad.
S
Sour Patch
Guest
Think he's injured until the end of the season which is a shame, hopefully doesn't become a injury prone player. He's also going to be entering his final year of his contract so a bargain to be had, especially with Methven in charge. Would definitely take if his injury disappears.My usual suggestion Miles Leaburn from Charlton
Outgoings:
Jack Clarke, we should be seeking £25m all in, Lazio were allegedly willing to pay £16m, if we can get someone to go £20m with £5m on the backend, we’d be doing okay.
Dan Ballard, we really need to be looking for north of £15m, ideally something like £18m. West Ham were heavily linked in the summer, perhaps a deal can be struck for a little less if they’re willing to wipe off any sell-on clauses associated with Ekwah and Aji’s deals.
Dan Neil, as close to £20m as possible, lesser players have moved from the Championship for similar fees.
These are the three most likely to leave for better things imo and I would insist on only letting 2 of the 3 go this summer.
Jack Clarke, we should be seeking £25m all in, Lazio were allegedly willing to pay £16m, if we can get someone to go £20m with £5m on the backend, we’d be doing okay.
Dan Ballard, we really need to be looking for north of £15m, ideally something like £18m. West Ham were heavily linked in the summer, perhaps a deal can be struck for a little less if they’re willing to wipe off any sell-on clauses associated with Ekwah and Aji’s deals.
Dan Neil, as close to £20m as possible, lesser players have moved from the Championship for similar fees.
These are the three most likely to leave for better things imo and I would insist on only letting 2 of the 3 go this summer.
Assuming Clarke leaves and everyone else stays:
Sell/Release
Bishop
Bass
Taylor
Anderson
Matete
Dack
Diamond
Loan Out
Hemir
Mayenda
Triantis
Bennette
Squad
You must log in or register to see images
Some glaring holes there. Think we need:
1 x GK (Unless Richardson or Younge step up)
1 x CB
1 x LW
1 x CAM
2 x CF
That is in an ideal world, although you assume Speakman will double down on Hemir, Mayenda and Rusyn as being our starting strikers
Just spent 700k on Bishop from Man Utd, unless we’re making that back we’re not paying up his contract for him to sign for free elsewhere.
Wow. That much? Admittedly it's only one game but he didn't look any better than Bass when I saw him. Guess we're stuck with him then
Same with Bass, we paid £165k but also some of the Denver Hume fee was used a makeweight so potentially around £250k from Portsmouth for him. AFC Wimbledon’s record transfer fee is £25k. No chance they’ll x10 their current record.
@Scout73, can I just say I love your input on here mate.
Very knowledgeable and very insightful....and very much appreciated.
Very knowledgeable and very insightful....and very much appreciated.