This Maguire thing is becoming a circus. Problem is, even if we bank a load of cash from him, other clubs will know we have that and what effect could that have on our subsequent purchasing? Also, we’ve sold a key player the last three years. If Maguire is not pushing for it, would it be of more benefit to stop that run and keep him. I see two different arguments when the effect on incoming players is mentioned. Some say it will reflect badly in terms of ambition and put players like Tielemans off and others that it’ll attract young talent if they know we won’t get in their way. It’s a difficult one
I wouldnt sell Maguire. We dont need the money and he is a good player. Is he worth anything like the numbers being thrown about? Never in a million years
And if Man U think he is the person that will solve all the defensive problems again they are terribly mistaken. I think Maguire is only as good as the defenders around him. His form yoyoed like Wes Morgans did and only when Evans got a run in the team did Maguire look like the defender we know he is again
IMO Evans is the best defender we have. He reads the game so well which is Maguire’s weakness at times. When De Ligt is offer for £65M and Mats Hummels goes for £37M. You have to question the madness in paying £80M+ for Slabhead
So from that sense I dont think we can lose whether Maguire stays or goes
But Top doesnt want us to be seen as a selling club. We have lost a key player every summer we have been in the Prem
Esteban Cambiasso didnt sign a new deal. His direct replacement was Gokhan Inler which didnt work but Kante more then made up
N’Golo Kante had a release clause that made us powerless to stop him going. Took us 6 months too long to replace him but found a great replacement in Ndidi
Danny Drinkwater forced his move and we got probably twice what he was worth. Just we made another bad attempt at replacing him with Adrien Silva. He didnt really get replaced until Youri Tielemans came in on loan
Riyad Mahrez again pushed his move through and was badly replaced with Ghezzal. But I think the team has much better balance and all round quality with Maddison, Ricardo and Tielemans covering Mahrez loss
I do feel though signing Tielemans is more important then keeping Maguire