Saints Stuff

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
You’ve got to be joking me right - did you see the congestion in the Stoke game!

Yes from the opposition, putting two of our players on the post adds to the 5 oppo players in front of the keeper, plus their markers.

Toms point is definitely the bigger reason though.
 
Fair enough. Agree to disagree on this one

I don’t disagree about players on the post, the back post especially. But it is definitely something you rarely see anymore, and there must be some stats/logic to it that means it isn’t as common.

A lot of people hate zonal marking but it is far more common than man now as another example
 
I don’t disagree about players on the post, the back post especially. But it is definitely something you rarely see anymore, and there must be some stats/logic to it that means it isn’t as common.

A lot of people hate zonal marking but it is far more common than man now as another example
Yeah that’s why I’m interested in their answer. Also not ever putting anyone outside the box really bugs me. Hardly any clubs do it but when they do (like qpr did) it’s a no brainer. It gives you a chance to break quickly whilst taking congestion out of the area. Drives me mad!
 
Which begs the question, for RM, why is our last defender pushed so far forward when we have a corner, giving teams the clear opportunity to catch him in no man’s land.
Which begs the other question, why don’t we do the same when defending a corner? :mad:
 
Flick ons?
Can't think of a single instance where I've seen that....can you? Even if it's theoretically possible I'd still prefer to see the defenders defending the goal just can't imagine a player thinking "mustn't flick this on as someone may be in an offside position.
 
You're the ref mate but I wouldn't think that would be offside .....but In any case I've never seen that.
I meant if an attacker heads it, keeper saves it and it falls to another player who scores. If he's ahead of the the player who headed it he would be offside if there's no one on the posts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: milton archer
Can't think of a single instance where I've seen that....can you? Even if it's theoretically possible I'd still prefer to see the defenders defending the goal just can't imagine a player thinking "mustn't flick this on as someone may be in an offside position.

I can’t give you a specific example but I am sure I have seen times when a player has flicked the ball on at the near post and the players knee or something was offside when the player at the back post puts it in.

Anyway as I said how often it happens vs how often player clears ball off line is something I’m sure the stats guys at professional clubs have analysed. Maybe having player off post and in box to block runners/clear the ball has a higher % effectiveness to them being on the line as well, I’m sure they look at lots of things we football dummies don’t consider
 
  • Like
Reactions: milton archer