Off Topic Politics Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Even Obamas lawyer has said that DACA would not stand up in court. 9 states were going to take the DACA ruling to court, if 1 state won the whole DACA would be made illegal and all 800,000 people would lose all cover and not be able to work. The only body that can pass a bill effecting so many people is congress. These people have to renew DACA every 2 years, the D in DACA is for DEFERRED, its a bullshit law that just keeps the wolves from the door. No one is being deported and no one is being banned from working, congress will pass a proper law within 6 months or get an extension. DACA applicants can get a 2 year extension upto October. People are reacting like these DACA people are being shipped out. Why are people not slagging off the parents for breaking multiple laws over many years
what happens after the 2 year extension?
 
Where have you heard that?

I very much doubt that will be the case.
It was the case when I posted that as per a government statement. The Dutch and French had sent ships on Wednesday but we have finally decided to send an appropriate response and send HMS Ocean which carries over 1000 men. (Not sure if it is actually carrying that)

Shows how much the government ****ed up with that initial estimation on what response was needed.
 
what happens after the 2 year extension?
If they can not reach some kind of agreement within 2 years, then they should all be sacked. My thinking is that a bill allowing them to stay, whilst working to become full citizens will pass by about 70%. The tax payers have spent millions on each of them, let them become Americans and pay back their debt.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ImpSaint
If they can not reach some kind of agreement within 2 years, then they should all be sacked. My thinking is that a bill allowing them to stay, whilst working to become full citizens will pass by about 70%. The tax payers have spent millions on each of them, let them become Americans and pay back their debt.

There WAS a bill allowing them to stay and become full citizens. In fact there were five or six bills. At least. None of them passed, because of the far right wing. They hated those bills so much that they wouldn't vote for any GOP nominee who had supported them. That's why Bush and Rubio got destroyed in the primaries.

They have always had the numbers. There's a lot more involved than just getting a majority vote, though. They just can't beat some of the Freedom Caucus in the House, or get a veto-proof majority in the Senate.

The tax payers have spent millions on each of them,

errr.... no.
 
Apologies for another NHS related rant, but as some of you may know it's a subject near to my shrivelled heart.

My wife who remains strangely positive about being a nurse has worked hard to get her masters and also qualify as an independent prescriber. The NHS has benefited, she has for years run prescribing clinics in mental health enabling clients to get quicker access and better monitoring.

Three months ago, at her NHS trust's invitation, she became involved in the on call duty Dr rota for east Dorset. Though not a Dr she's actually better trained than most who take this role, it's usually very junior or a locum Dr who does this. It's been a success in that she enjoys the work and ward based staff like having someone admit and prescribe for clients who knows their stuff and the locality/structure.

She will sadly this weekend work her last shift. Why? Well for a start the NHS has not paid her a penny for the six spells of duty so far done. Despite many requests they cannot even tell her what rate of pay she'll get (bare in mind it certainly will be A LOT less than the Doctors she shares the rota with). I personally doubt she would be professionally covered without a contract in place which really worries me. My anxieties are further raised as this mirrors some of the experiences which demotivated myself a few years ago.

The point is many clinical staff in the NHS want to be flexible and pro-active but are poorly served by managers.
My wife, and the other nurse who agreed to take on this role, are not money grabbing. They just want to be paid about a third of what it would've cost the NHS to continue employing locum Doctors.

Oh, and of course they have further eroded the motivation of good staff. Idiots.
 
There WAS a bill allowing them to stay and become full citizens. In fact there were five or six bills. At least. None of them passed, because of the far right wing. They hated those bills so much that they wouldn't vote for any GOP nominee who had supported them. That's why Bush and Rubio got destroyed in the primaries.

They have always had the numbers. There's a lot more involved than just getting a majority vote, though. They just can't beat some of the Freedom Caucus in the House, or get a veto-proof majority in the Senate.



errr.... no.

Errrr. Yes

Trump is showing that he is more than willing to work with the Democrats if he finds the Republicans non responsive. For the last 8 years the Republicans have spent their time just blocking Obama, they will soon learn to work with Trump or he will just bypass them. A new legal DACA replacement could be made at the beginning of next week as all parties want it done, should pass the Senate easily
 
  • Like
Reactions: ImpSaint
We're now starting to fly over troops to the Caribbean. I don't know how May can call this a swift response when we could and should have been doing this before the storm even hit like the French.
 
We're now starting to fly over troops to the Caribbean. I don't know how May can call this a swift response when we could and should have been doing this before the storm even hit like the French.

Has the government managed to do anything at all apart from deal with Brexit (you know the thing that was going to be straightforward) over the past year? They are like rabbits in the headlights and can't give any attention to anything else at all.

They remind me of my daughter learning to drive. Their entire focus is on not running off the road as regards Brexit and, same as her, they wouldn't notice a nuclear weapon going off a mile away.

Vin
 
  • Like
Reactions: VocalMinority
Has the government managed to do anything at all apart from deal with Brexit (you know the thing that was going to be straightforward) over the past year? They are like rabbits in the headlights and can't give any attention to anything else at all.

They remind me of my daughter learning to drive. Their entire focus is on not running off the road as regards Brexit and, same as her, they wouldn't notice a nuclear weapon going off a mile away.

Vin

<laugh> let me know when and where your daughter is having her next driving lesson, so I can avoid the area.

Brexit, unfortunately, is oroving a bit harder to avoid.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Onionman
We're now starting to fly over troops to the Caribbean. I don't know how May can call this a swift response when we could and should have been doing this before the storm even hit like the French.

It's not fair to compare our response to the French, as French colonies in the Caribean remain exactly that - colonies. They are governed directly from Paris, unlike UK dependencies which are self governing.

It's a fair guess that the French - who, mostly on the quiet, maintain military bases all over their former Empire to a far greater extent than we do - already had considerable military resources in the area.

I'm not trying to defend our govt's response to this specific disaster; but your original post suggests that you are probably unaware of the amount of humanitarian work British Forces overseas are routinely involved in. In peacetime that's a good % of what the Royal Marines, for example, actually do.
 
Hurricane José has been upgraded to Category 4 and is expected to strike the Leeward Islands including Barbuda in the near future. Gulp.
 
It's not fair to compare our response to the French, as French colonies in the Caribean remain exactly that - colonies. They are governed directly from Paris, unlike UK dependencies which are self governing.

It's a fair guess that the French - who, mostly on the quiet, maintain military bases all over their former Empire to a far greater extent than we do - already had considerable military resources in the area.

I'm not trying to defend our govt's response to this specific disaster; but your original post suggests that you are probably unaware of the amount of humanitarian work British Forces overseas are routinely involved in. In peacetime that's a good % of what the Royal Marines, for example, actually do.

I'm not sure what you are saying is wrong with my original post considering what I said to do is exactly what the government has done half a day later, taking a large number of troops off a training exercise and send them to the disaster.

I am now complaining about our response time. Both France and the Dutch started sending ships earlier that us, which is irrespective of distance. And when we did respond we sent an auxiliary ship designed to support forces on the ground. However there were no forces to support as it's our island. And it certainly wouldn't have stopped us flying in resources in advance rather than days after the storm hit.

I read something as the storm hit to say our troops on the region were stationed on ships rather than in base like the French so they could be mobile, but if that strategy doesn't allow them to do what they are there to do which is to defend our citizens then it clearly needs a rethink.
 
Errrr. Yes

Use your brain. There are 800,000 registered DACA recipients. Multiply that by "millions." That is a ridiculous, obviously completely mind-bogglingly absurd sum. For a group of people that were until a few years ago, ineligible for any Federal aid.

Trump is showing that he is more than willing to work with the Democrats if he finds the Republicans non responsive. For the last 8 years the Republicans have spent their time just blocking Obama, they will soon learn to work with Trump or he will just bypass them. A new legal DACA replacement could be made at the beginning of next week as all parties want it done, should pass the Senate easily

A DACA replacement will take longer than a week. Nothing in Congress gets done in a week. If it were that simple, then why did Obama have to issue an Executive Order to get DACA done?

Why would the Democrats work with Trump? They don't want the wall, or a travel ban, or tax reform or any of the things that Trump wants. And Trump just slashed the **** out of every program the Democrats want. And no, the Dems cannot just bypass the Republicans in Congress. The GOP controls every committee. The Democrats can't even get their bills on the floor for a vote. Nothing would even reach Trump.

He is using the threat of working with Democrats to try to pressure the Republicans into backing his agenda.
What Trump wants is to for the Republicans to get rid of the Senate filibuster. Then all they need is a simple majority in the Senate, which they have. That would have been enough to repeal Obamacare.

The issue is this is kind of a hollow threat. Trump's base is mainly the far right wing. They would be aghast if all of a sudden Trump started touting liberal bills. He would lose all his supporters.

What Trump also doesn't get is that the Democrats are not the problem. The fact that he can't get along with Republicans is the problem. That and the things he wants aren't that popular, and he doesn't help them at all. He makes it worse. Trump's problem is himself.

The far right and moderate right cannot agree. It's Trump's job to unite them and get stuff done. What Trump does instead is distance himself and then blame them whenever they fail. If they somehow succeed, then he takes the credit. When Trump is supposed to talk about tax reform, he goes off script and creates a race controversy instead. Now every one in the GOP has to spend a week defending the party and getting asked questions about Trump. Same thing with the Russia investigation. Trump creates messes and asks the GOP to clean it up, then gets mad and tries to blame them when nothing gets done.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Onionman
Use your brain. There are 800,000 registered DACA recipients. Multiply that by "millions." That is a ridiculous, obviously completely mind-bogglingly absurd sum. For a group of people that were until a few years ago, ineligible for any Federal aid.

It really is a huge bundle of cash, the $400,000 it costs to put each person through school for 13 years, many costing extra for extra english classes and counseling . The main cost is paying for the DACA programme itself, it's a government body so not efficient or cost effective. The DACA recipients ( can not call them kids) as the average age is something like 25, have to renew their forms every 2 years, done with legal aid who then bill the government which is like printing money. A fair few also get free college, which is a kick in the balls for poor legals. They do not receive welfare or health, but it still costs around 2 million for each recipient for 13 years
 

Yep. And education is by far the biggest expense related to illegal immigration.

The idea that the main cost of DACA is the administrative expenses of running it is absurd. Think of the amount of time and expense involved to educate a student in a classroom face-to-face for 13 years. How could that possibly cost less than processing a DACA application?
 
Hurricane José has been upgraded to Category 4 and is expected to strike the Leeward Islands including Barbuda in the near future. Gulp.

It seems to have stalled, I saw a prediction that it will strengthen in the next couple of days, and be drawn towards New York area because of the low pressure caused by the previous hurricane