Player comparison thread

[You'veBeenTiote'd]

Baines

Van Persie v Hernandez (Chicarito)

Van Persie by a mile!

Vagner Love vs Doumbia

 

[Obertan's Rancid Toe]

Van Persie by a mile!

Vagner Love vs Doumbia

Doumbia

Obertan or Routledge

 

[Minty Fresh]

Doumbia

Obertan or Routledge

Obertan

Sammy vs Shola

 

[Sanchin0]

Sammy

Van Der Vaart or Kaka

 

[G4rdToonArmy]

Sammy

Van Der Vaart or Kaka

VDV

Ronaldo or Messi

this is fun!!!

*Oh its already been done does that mean i lose???

 

[Minty Fresh]

Kaka

Kagawa or Gotzë

 

[Obertan's Rancid Toe]

Kaka

Kagawa or Gotzë

Gotze

Scott Sinclair or Taarabt

 

[Sanchin0]

Sinclair

Morrison or Graham

 

[Mod Face]

Gotze

Scott Sinclair or Taarabt

Sinclair

Pennant or Routledge

 

[You'veBeenTiote'd]

Sinclair!

Torres or Bent

 

[Smudger]

Sinclair!

Torres or Bent

Torres

Gotze v Ozil

 

[Sanchin0]

Sinclair

Pennant or Routledge

Pennant any day. Better crosser of the ball on his day.

Cattermore or Karl Henry?

 

[Obertan's Rancid Toe]

Torres

Gotze v Ozil

Ozil (at the minute)

Reina or Valdes

 

[Chappaz]

Valdes imo

Heskey or Carlton Cole?

 

[Sanchin0]

Carlton Cole. Better ''all-round'' player. But that isn't saying much to be honest.. there both average at best and Championship standard.

Cattermore or Karl Henry?

 

[Mod Face]

Carlton Cole. Better ''all-round'' player. But that isn't saying much to be honest.. there both average at best and Championship standard.

Cattermore or Karl Henry?

Cattermole. Poor judgement when tackling and a bit of a temper but unlike Henry, has some redeeming features.

Scholes NOW or Guthrie?

 

[Sanchin0]

Cattermole. Poor judgement when tackling and a bit of a temper but unlike Henry, has some redeeming features.

Scholes NOW or Guthrie?

Guthrie, obviously. I actually rate Guthrie.

Anyways.. Graham or Morrison?

 

[THE LEFT BOOT OF ROBERT]

graham

elliot or harper

 

[Obertan's Rancid Toe]

Cattermole. Poor judgement when tackling and a bit of a temper but unlike Henry, has some redeeming features.

Scholes NOW or Guthrie?

Scholes now.

Coloccini or Ferdinand

 

[Sanchin0]

Right now.. it has to be Colo.

Peter Crouch or Zigic?