Diomande was decent in the first half yesterday. Some people just need a scapegoat.
Phelan Out
- Thread starter Chazz Rheinhold
- Start date
-
Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
-
I wouldn't have signed an injured player in the first place, but Bruce did, again, - having signed him and got rid of Aluko, I would look at who we had up front and who could track back to defend as well - Abel isn't that man so in the circumstances we have no-one else - our squad is woefully light and that's a combination of poor Bruce signings and the total lack of investment in the squad by the Allams - I've no idea why we spent almost £20 million in two days in August, maybe they thought the sale was done and it was accounted for, maybe the PL told them to spend otherwise they would not give them the tv money because they were taking the piss out of the brand, maybe they were looking after their gift - who knows, but it was too little too late
He was decent until he got a bang on the head after approx 25 mins then looked dazed.
Significantly both times he went down AH remained sat on the bench rather than warming up...also AH wasn't warming up with the other subs at half time !
Dio did fine first half yesterday, but faded in the second.
What was odd for me was playing two midfielders in defence while a centre half sat on the bench.
What was odd for me was playing two midfielders in defence while a centre half sat on the bench.
Diomande isn't good enough for the premier league , I'm not making him a scapegoat , he seems like a decent guy out of his depth that's all
From what I've seen or picked up so far Dio's not on his own in that category. Mason, Henriksen, Meyler, Maloney, Maguire, Keane, Weir spring to mind. It's the manager's job to make the team more than the sum of its parts.
Serious question. What did he do?
They showed two clips on motd. One he chested a ball down and it went ten yards away. The other clip showed him do well hold two players off, get his head up and pass straight to Kante.
He was constantly tracking back and putting tackles in during the first half. He often plays himself into trouble, but first half he was useful. Second half he just became anonymous.
Exactly. 7 points from 7 games. $
7 points from 7 games. 4 losses against top 7 teams. 4 points away from home. 3 at home against 12th place teams and below.
Can't ask for more. Survival form, as you say, with all the other **** happening.
Exactly . Well said.
7 points from 7 games. 4 losses against top 7 teams. 4 points away from home. 3 at home against 12th place teams and below.
Can't ask for more. Survival form, as you say, with all the other **** happening.
What disappoints me, but doesn't surprise me, is that when we had very good reason to be critical of SB, the posters now criticising MP defended SB in the same vitriolic terms they now use to attack MP and his supporters.
Bruce had all of the time in the world and not a small amount of money to prove himself in the PL.
Phelan has had limited resources, he is a temporary manager by default and he did well in games were we thought there was hope and not so well in the games where we thought he had little hope. He also lacks full experience and his distractions are many and hugely unhelpful. I don't necessarily agree with some of his selections, but I can understand why he might make them. What I don't understand is why we have posters jumping on his bones to get out when we all know he is the victim of an Allam clusterfuck.
Bruce had all of the time in the world and not a small amount of money to prove himself in the PL.
Phelan has had limited resources, he is a temporary manager by default and he did well in games were we thought there was hope and not so well in the games where we thought he had little hope. He also lacks full experience and his distractions are many and hugely unhelpful. I don't necessarily agree with some of his selections, but I can understand why he might make them. What I don't understand is why we have posters jumping on his bones to get out when we all know he is the victim of an Allam clusterfuck.
Not to worry; if he does decide to go, we'll surely get £15m for him at least after his outstanding performances this season.
Criticism of Mike Phelan from me is restricted to his starting line up at Liverpool.
We need Dawson back and if we can avoid further injuries and suspension's, I think we will have a better idea of MP's capability to manage a game.
At our level having a full squad to select from is vital. But I am still concerned that Maguire is not being used when he is clearly fit and he is a defender. Its a concern and not a criticism.
Bournemouth away will be a test.
We need Dawson back and if we can avoid further injuries and suspension's, I think we will have a better idea of MP's capability to manage a game.
At our level having a full squad to select from is vital. But I am still concerned that Maguire is not being used when he is clearly fit and he is a defender. Its a concern and not a criticism.
Bournemouth away will be a test.
Do you pick a formation and stick with it no matter what or adapt a formation to fit your best players?
Obviously it's B.
We had Abel Hernandez sat On the bench pissed off. He didn't even warm up when dio got poked in the eye first half. So he knew he wasn't coming on. That's our top goal scorer pissed off.
The other weeks I've been saying play Hernandez and mbokani together he didn't he played Abel with dio. The formation is all then with phelan. So he'd much rather play a forward who is willing to end up at left back tracking back than actually play the two players together who actually might score the goals needed to keep us up.
He's no idea. He's an inexperienced would be manager who Norwich sacked off.
Obviously it's B.
We had Abel Hernandez sat On the bench pissed off. He didn't even warm up when dio got poked in the eye first half. So he knew he wasn't coming on. That's our top goal scorer pissed off.
The other weeks I've been saying play Hernandez and mbokani together he didn't he played Abel with dio. The formation is all then with phelan. So he'd much rather play a forward who is willing to end up at left back tracking back than actually play the two players together who actually might score the goals needed to keep us up.
He's no idea. He's an inexperienced would be manager who Norwich sacked off.
Question chaz.................. if not MP, who would you seriously have as manager?
And you, having never been sacked by Norwich are obviously more experienced and better?
Do you understand why he isn't playing two up top, yes you may score 2 goals in a game but will probably concede 5. You are in a war to stay in the top league, the aim at the moment is not to get in the CL, it's to gain enough points to be safe.
If you are in a position where you have to go with one striker to make the team more secure then you go with the man who has more chance of holding the ball until backup arrives, otherwise you just end up with wave after wave of attacks against you with no respite.
You obviously have an idea of how you would like your team to play (as all supporters do), but try to take the opposition into account and look at what the manager is trying to do with the squad at his disposal.
Not that a want to start a conversation with a sad boring manc **** as you know nowt about us.
The man to hold the ball up is mbokani so why did phelan persist asking Hernandez to do that prior to Chelsea? See you know **** all about us so **** off.
We have. When he's had options, he'd made the wrong choices. When he was needed to make a decision in the game to try and halt something or change something, he left it too late.
No one is pretending managing a club is easy, but we don't have a Martial to come off the bench, and the team needs setting up better from the off. He's not a PL manager by any stretch.
Diomande has been playing left midfield. Why would hernandez come on for him.also if not dio.Who would we pick to play in front of robertson