Tough one really. I'd accept Hendo or Skrtel no problem (people underestimate the pure grit Skrtel puts into every single performance even when he's not playing well) but in a way Rodgers may see this as a sticky one.
The local rumour mill suggests he sees Lovren as his long term captain (if he settles as well as he should). If he gives VC to Hendo can he then promote Lovren over him when Gerrard goes? He might be able to do that a bit easier with Skrtel as vice captain simply because he can use the "long term future" excuse to Skrt's. Can't do that with Hendo so easily. Might even keep Skrtel a bit more settled at the club if Sakho does start more often and he's getting fewer games.
Genuinely think both would do us proud either way though